News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by proc0 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @04:57PM (#39803057)
This would be the final straw for me and I would have to move states. It's unbelievable what these state employees spend their time on, as if they are some kind of lordship ruling over the peasants.

> But amid the debate over rate design, we’ve lost sight of the much bigger challenge of how to bring down utility costs overall

You increase supply!! Build more nuclear!! Then it will be cheap for everyone. But nooo, somehow the cost of nuclear is more than the cost of climate change.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by readyman on Saturday March 23, 2024 @08:17PM (#39804030)
>Build more nuclear!!

The private sector is uninterested in such long term ROI so "building more buclear" would require a major expansion of public investment. Would you support that? If so, the next question is whether that investment is delivered to the private sector as a subsidy or whether the infrastructure will be built and maintained publicly, because the former has a terrible track record while the latter has shown great historical success (France, Germany, and even the US) but is not in the imaginations of the current ruling class. What do you prefer?

Re:California Income-based electric bills by proc0 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @09:57PM (#39804518)
Yeah I would support public investment in nuclear. I think it would be good to at least explore the options, build smaller nuclear facilities if possible, learning along the way. Renewables are still great for smaller use cases, and it can continue improving.

I think either way it has to be a collab. between private and public sectors because of the magnitude of the risk, which in theory is largely understood but in practice people can make mistakes and those will be costly. Ultimately this would only be done because of climate change, otherwise we could just take our time switching to renewables.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by jerlam on Saturday March 23, 2024 @07:33PM (#39803800)
It's not supply that's the main driver of costs:

One of the biggest such costs in California is the billions of dollars being spent on hardening and burying power lines to reduce the risk of them sparking wildfires. Utilities are also bearing the costs of compensating the victims of wildfires caused by poorly maintained grid equipment

Re:California Income-based electric bills by proc0 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @07:53PM (#39803908)
That's part of supply. It's how the energy is supplied to the customer. Mismanagement of the supply includes both the wild fires caused by not clearing the dry brush, the poor maintenance of the grid, and the shutting down of nuclear plants without building new ones. All of this affects how much energy people are getting and increases prices. If at least we had a good production by building nuclear, the other factors would be alleviated.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by Arrath on Saturday March 23, 2024 @08:06PM (#39803971)
While I think I agree with you the broader sense, what youre describing is typically broken out into "distribution" and "generation". Sure it's pedantic but surely so is their accounting.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by proc0 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @09:33PM (#39804399)
No, that's fair. I could be more precise in terminology there, next time.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by jsyang00 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @04:59PM (#39803068)
pretty much nothing the rotten state of California does should constitute a surprise to anyone anymore
Re:California Income-based electric bills by throwaway5959 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @06:49PM (#39803584)
Nuclear would be more expensive than the solar, wind and battery storage tech we’re building out now. Please do some research before you comment on posts here, this isn’t X.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by proc0 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @07:15PM (#39803715)
Renewables don't scale and don't have the energy density to satisfy the demand that would require replacing fossil fuels. It's not even close. We don't know when that new battery tech will be ready, it could easily be another decade or more... so the real question is do we want to risk climate change more and more, or should we use nuclear to replace fossil fuels immediately while the renewable tech matures.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by throwaway5959 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @08:16PM (#39804023)
California gets most of its electricity from renewables, a small amount of nuclear and the balance is natural gas and imports. https://www.caiso.com/TodaysOutlook/Pages/supply.html
Re:California Income-based electric bills by thedrbrian on Saturday March 23, 2024 @08:37PM (#39804123)
Even in summer CAISO admit it's only getting 47% from renewables. YTD from the December report is 35%

https://www.caiso.com/market/Pages/ReportsBulletins/Renewabl...

Re:California Income-based electric bills by throwaway5959 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @10:00PM (#39804530)
Only 47%. lol OK. Let’s check back in five years from now and see where CA is at.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by iknowstuff on Saturday March 23, 2024 @08:53PM (#39804218)
I’ve explained here before how the cost of installations like tesla megapacks we have in CA + solar is still significantly cheaper than nuclear. With a much faster ROI.

Nuclear makes no financial sense in CA.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by throwaway5959 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @11:41PM (#39805003)
Plus no radioactive waste to manage for thousands of years, which no one seems to factor into the cost.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by Newlaptop on Saturday March 23, 2024 @06:55PM (#39803611)
Nuclear is only expensive because we've spent decades bureaucratically strangling it with red tape.

The technology exists to safely do nuclear at low cost. We just need to remove the billions of dollars wasted in intentionally-bad regulatory processes that were written into law to prevent nuclear from being successful.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by stop50 on Saturday March 23, 2024 @07:07PM (#39803673)
There are only a few countries that can deal with their nuclear trash in a semipermanent solution and those never had much and are relativ save from problems that could happen.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by marcusverus on Saturday March 23, 2024 @07:22PM (#39803745)
Cheap solar is a meme. Zero solar farms can provide their sticker output overnight after an overcast winter day. Most can't provide their sticker output all night after a sunny summer day! Of course, these shortfalls can't result in blackouts, so instead we simply keep extra backup capacity on standby. The studies never price this in, but you can rest assured that the energy companies do.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by fragmede on Monday March 25, 2024 @05:26AM (#39814168)
Thankfully, California's main problems in the southern California region is the need for electricity to run air conditioners during the day, so that's not the worst problem. Nuclear would be better but there are other problems with it that make it unviable.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by marcusverus on Monday March 25, 2024 @11:40AM (#39817722)
California's own regulations will soon be adding a lot of evening/night-time demand [0]. Surely it's a problem that a huge amount of demand will be coming online just as solar output is falling to nil?

Nuclear plants have been powering France for 50 years, of course it is viable!

[0] https://archive.is/https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/29/us/cal...

Re:California Income-based electric bills by MuffinFlavored on Saturday March 23, 2024 @08:49PM (#39804202)
> This would be the final straw for me and I would have to move states.

There will still be 39,000,000+ people left in the state if you do.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by iknowstuff on Saturday March 23, 2024 @09:01PM (#39804252)
Explain the nuclear fixation please.

The construction of new nuclear reactors at Plant Vogtle in Georgia provides a real-world example to re-evaluate the costs associated with building nuclear power versus a combination of solar power and battery storage.

The Plant Vogtle expansion involved the construction of two new reactors, Units 3 and 4, which faced significant delays and cost overruns. Initially estimated to cost around $14 billion with an expected operational start in 2016, the project's expenses ballooned to over $30 billion, more than double the original estimate. This increase does not include an additional $3.68 billion paid by the original contractor, Westinghouse, to the owners after going bankrupt, which brings the total spending to more than $34 billion. The construction started in 2009, with Unit 3 reaching "initial criticality" in 2023, marking the beginning of a self-sustaining nuclear fission reaction. Unit 3 is expected to come into service in mid-2023, with Unit 4 following in late 2023 or early 2024 [1](https://www.gpb.org/news/2023/05/25/georgia-nuclear-rebirth-...) [2](https://www.gpb.org/news/2022/05/09/georgia-nuclear-plants-c...) [3](https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/nuclear/georgias-big-ne...).

- Nuclear (Vogtle): The total projected costs for the Vogtle expansion are nearing $35 billion for two reactors, providing a combined capacity of 2.2 GW. This translates to approximately $15.9 billion per GW.

- Solar + Megapack: the capital cost for solar power is around $1 billion per GW. Adding battery storage to match the continuous output capability of nuclear plants significantly affects the total cost. Tesla Megapack costs vary, but an estimate of around $200 million for 1 GWh of storage was given. The exact cost for solar plus Megapack to achieve comparable 24/7 output capacity as nuclear would depend on the required storage duration to offset the variability of solar generation.

The Vogtle project's cost overruns and delays highlight the financial risks associated with large-scale nuclear projects. The actual cost of Vogtle significantly exceeds initial projections, emphasizing the challenge of managing complex nuclear construction projects within budget and timeline expectations. In contrast, solar and battery storage projects, such as those utilizing Tesla's Megapack, offer faster deployment times and have seen decreasing costs over time. However, to achieve a continuous power supply similar to a 1 GW nuclear plant, substantial investment in storage would be necessary, potentially narrowing the cost difference.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by barbacoa on Saturday March 23, 2024 @10:10PM (#39804592)
It's not fair to compare 1 GW of solar to 1 GW of nuclear power.

A solar plant will produce at full capacity an equivalent of ~5 hours a day.

Nuclear will produce at full capacity for 24/7/365.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by iknowstuff on Sunday March 24, 2024 @12:50PM (#39808356)
Feel free to calculate how many GW of solar you can build for the price of 1GW of nuclear
Re:California Income-based electric bills by fragmede on Monday March 25, 2024 @05:34AM (#39814217)
did you want explanations for the nuclear fixation or just want to argue? it's a way cooler technology, even if the real world intrudes upon its implementation.

it's not the cost of solar you've got to look at, but the cost of solar + batteries to cover the problem with solar: it doesn't work when the sun isn't shining. Now, that's less of a problem for most of California (it's an issue in snowy Tahoe), and grid-sized energy storage can cover the shortfall, but nuclear fission simply doesn't have that problem. It has other problems instead, which make solar the better choice for California, imo, but not everywhere is LA.

Re:California Income-based electric bills by dalyons on Saturday March 23, 2024 @09:24PM (#39804357)
Nuclear would increase costs, due to it being the most expensive form of new generation we have.
Re:California Income-based electric bills by EarthMephit on Saturday March 23, 2024 @10:30PM (#39804686)
Surely if the government wanted to go down this route, it would be a lot fairer and simpler to manage with the government sending a low-income rebate/refund check to low-income households when they do their taxes?

They could then collect the costs off the energy companies.

The proposed solution seems like a corporation's wet-dream - Being able to charge consumers exactly the maximum amount of what they are able to pay for a product.