In the minds of everyone who is not in the group that makes that distinction it sounds like you're trying to justify something. It's essentially identical to the argument college kids make to me all the time: "I'm not stealing anything, I'm pirating it." Of course you are, but if I explained this issue to, say, a Senator, they would say it's stealing. At that point, yes, correct said Senator, then you're in a real discussion about a real issue. Swooping in and correcting some guy who casually uses the term "stealing" on an Internet form just grates on me because you sound like those college kids trying to justify themselves.
We correct you because you're using misleading terminology, as cryptoz explained.
Language matters and it's hard to have a useful discussion when either side keeps on falling back to prejudiced terminology.
Stealing and pirating are both taking something that is not rightfully yours, but they are barely in the same category of crime.
It's as if you correct everyone who uses the term "soccer" by saying "It's actually 'football'" or correcting everyone who conflates a alligator and a crocodile in casual conversation. In the end people will just ignore you.
I am not "swooping in," I noticed your comment and decided to remark that your terminology is incorrect. I did this because by referring to it as stealing you are taking part in the rhetoric that supports such acts as PIPA and SOPA.
In US jurisdictions, that's a misdemeanor.
Theft would be a criminal offence. Shop-lifting would be counted as theft.
Violating copyrights is illegal, but it's not a criminal offence. You're not going to be arrested for it. The Crown Prosecution Service won't do anything.
The rights holders can sue for loss of earnings - that's 79pence per track. They can try and sue for the stuff you've shared.
Copyright violation becomes criminal offence if done as part of trade - burning movies to DVD and selling them, for example.
And unless the UK has draconian shoplifting laws I've never heard of, the same holds true there.
People get fined for shoplifting. Sometimes they don't pay the fines. They go to prison for not paying fines.
Also, Canada is signatory to the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights; having collections of pirated material deemed to be of "commercial scale" is a criminal offense.
I get that you're trying to distinguish between what are often civil vs. criminal matters, but it's a bit of a stretch. "Stealing" is a term that gets used for a lot of things other than literal theft in criminal law.
No. While the large numbers illustrate my point better, the small ones hold true as well. Steal one album: arrest, criminal record. Download one album: nothing.
> Also, Canada is signatory to the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights; having collections of pirated material deemed to be of "commercial scale" is a criminal offense.
I'll have to look into that - thanks.
None of that can happen to you if you pirate an album. Framing the issue to make it sound like you can be a criminal facing time in jail for downloading an album is absurd. It's very far removed from reality and builds a culture of hatred and fear that is not actually present.
Stealing and pirating music are very different things. It's wrong to talk about them as though they are the same. That's the only point I'm trying to make.
Pirating digital content is wrong. It's an issue that urgently needs attention. I'm not trying to justify the actions or call out in support of pirates. I am trying to make sure everyone knows that "stealing" has an important legal definition that is irrelevant to pirating music.