News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by camg55 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @02:37PM (#39707444)
Think this is great for Vancouver which needs more housing. The zoning is broken, and far too conservative. Glad to see the Squamish addressing a need that will likely benefit all, and hopefully this encourages the city of Vancouver to do the same on their own accord.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by spxneo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:28PM (#39707990)
Building more homes in Vancouver will not result in lower prices because this is not a supply problem it is the financial assetization of home equity that drives higher and higher prices. Blue collar workers turned multi-millionaires rely on the continued rise of home prices to purchase cheap credit which they use to speculate on more homes. When they couldn't find anymore locals they turned to the international market to sell their bags. Now these 20k homes ppl are celebrating are NOT going to be sold under market prices no matter how much reddit and hn crowd wants it to be true. It will only stabilize the prices at current inflated levels.

Be careful what you wish for. The only type of housing they are building is not white picket fenced backyard with a shed that is being converted to homes but high/low rise apartments primarily for rental, a hotbed for crime.

Since David Eby overrode the strata no-rental rules, while not responsible it resulted in huge increase in cases of squatters, petty theft, drug labs and brothels. This does not include what a retired VPD officer describes as an "Amazon of drug labs and brothels" which is familiar to vancouver high rise but now its even easier for criminals. Vice reporters were even reporting on it years ago but now these cases are accelerating since Eby stepped in a populist spirit.

I'm all for alleviating housing situation but we need to stop and ask if those people who are demanding/feel entitled to it really have the necessary income to justify it. Often I see people making 60k CAD/year lamenting how they can't find a home to live in. You can't afford anything in developed urban centres except in emerging economies.

So I think rather than building more housing we need to ask who really has merit to be here and the biggest determining factor is income not how long you lived in Vancouver like certain demographic of locals are suggesting which is basically dogwhistling to say the market forces should not apply to them because of their skin colour.

Simply blaming this on local housing policy failure like reddit does when housing prices has been appreciating all over the world, not just Vancouver, is myopic. There are cities that are far more dense than vancouver and has even more ridiculous real estate prices. They love Vancouver and the blue collar Canadian workers that bought their homes after 6 month of work in the 70s, 80s are not desperate to sell as they have nowhere else to go.

Lot of people are being setup for major disappointments if they think vancouver home prices are coming back down to 2012 prices. There is simply no way to force homeowners to sell when they have no urgency or financial stress to do so. over 50% of homeowners in Vancouver do not have mortgages.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by soperj on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:58PM (#39708299)
> Since David Eby overrode the strata no-rental rules, it ended up increasing cases of squatters, petty theft, drug labs and brothels. This does not include what a retired VPD officer describes as an "Amazon of drug labs and brothels" throughout vancouver high rise. I mean Vice reporters were even reporting on it years ago.

David Eby has been premier since October 2022, strata property act happened soon after in November. Maybe, just maybe, the squatters, petty theft, drug labs and brothels aren't a result of the strata changes. Certainly not the ones that Vice reporters reported on years ago.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by Seattle3503 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @03:45PM (#39708183)
It is a mistake to blame the high cost of housing on market forces. It is largely the product of local housing policy. It is a choice.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by janalsncm on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:15PM (#39708460)
I think it’s both. Housing policy can help or hurt but overall many places in the world have stuggled to keep housing prices affordable.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by smallmancontrov on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:53PM (#39708835)
> stuggled to keep housing prices affordable.

The political system does not strive for affordability, it strives to make housing a good investment. Unaffordability is just the inevitable consequence.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by astrange on Friday March 15, 2024 @03:46PM (#39719897)
Expensive housing is almost entirely an Anglo nation problem. If you don't restrict infill development you won't have this issue.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by janalsncm on Friday March 15, 2024 @06:03PM (#39721177)
Housing is extremely expensive in China as well. It’s one of the main barriers to Chinese yuppies having the three kids their government wants them to.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by astrange on Saturday March 16, 2024 @03:41AM (#39724021)
Isn't China having a real estate overproduction crisis right now? There can be different problems in different places, I mean, it's a big country, but that's mostly the opposite problem.

The hukou system also can't help - you can stop immigration to an expensive city but presumably you also stop emigration to a cheaper one.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by janalsncm on Saturday March 16, 2024 @02:33PM (#39728287)
China has overproduction in undesirable places. Desirable places are still expensive.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by julienb_sea on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:53PM (#39709407)
Local housing policy only sets housing costs explicitly if they override market forces e.g. via rent control. There are plenty of examples of how the market responds to this type of intervention, by not building more supply, letting existing supply fall into disrepair and constricting uncontrolled supply, resulting in much higher market rate.

In general, housing policy affects supply, and market forces decide the prices. Notably increasing supply doesn't always lower prices as demand is elastic.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by lazyasciiart on Thursday March 14, 2024 @07:30PM (#39710253)
They override market forces explicitly with zoning rules that forbid building more housing. The ability to produce more supply in response to demand is the market at work. That’s why everyone who complains that rent control distorts the market can be ignored unless they are also complaining about zoning, building codes and permit processes.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by spxneo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:16PM (#39711091)
I think you meant inelastic demand. Housing would fall under that category where supply does not impact price, which is my point.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by AuryGlenz on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:17PM (#39711421)
Home prices in Canada and US have been climbing at insane rates pretty much everywhere, including rural areas. People in cities tend to ignore market force because they’re only focused on their city.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by zoklet-enjoyer on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:36PM (#39708654)
You could have saved a lot of time by just saying "fuck poor people"
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by spxneo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:23PM (#39711128)
You misunderstood me because you didn't read what I wrote carefully but I don't care to convince you of your biases. I don't have time for this BS anymore.

Listen my neighbour just died. He was a struggling renter. I'm deeply saddened by this and everybody struggling. I know its even harder to leave behind what's familiar but it's not going to get better but the longer you stay in a financially strapped situation and waiting for a bailout from the government the more you suffer. This is why I'm telling people to forget about this miserable city and look elsewhere as I am.

The Canadian government is taking 60% of my income. Why isn't it being used to alleviate this situation?! My sadness is turning into anger and disappointment.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by klyrs on Friday March 15, 2024 @08:42AM (#39714876)
> The Canadian government is taking 60% of my income.

The top tax bracket is 33% in Canada. You should fire whoever's doing your taxes.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by SpaceNugget on Friday March 15, 2024 @12:22PM (#39717470)
That's for federal income tax. In BC the top provincial income tax bracket is 20.5%, so a total 53.5%. I assume the person is also including property tax, EI, MSP premiums or other vaguely government related payments, or rounding up pretty generously to get to 60%.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by brailsafe on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:10PM (#39708419)
Property boomer checking in for duty
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by smallmancontrov on Thursday March 14, 2024 @04:55PM (#39708852)
> feel entitled

It's funny how the people who sling this as an insult so often have a literal deed/title and are pursuing policy that pumps its value to the detriment of others.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by aclatuts on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:13PM (#39709052)
This is like the tech bro version of: private investors buying properties is inflating property prices.

The problem is blue collar people, which is a new one to me.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by davis on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:33PM (#39709237)
Building more housing (of all kinds) == cheaper housing. Sorry but it really is that simple.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by spxneo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:26PM (#39711141)
you are assuming (incorrectly) that housing demand is elastic.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by AuryGlenz on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:17PM (#39711424)
Or, alternatively, less people/demand.
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by Izikiel43 on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:52PM (#39709392)
Houses there are a luxury, you would need to be a multimillionaire to buy something there. Also, most of Vancouver is zoned for sfh, check a zoning map. Your entire comment can be summarized as: Build buildings-> more rentals -> lower price -> lower income can afford it -> poor people are criminals.

I lived there for 2 years, and a local tech salary was barely enough to afford living in downtown/near downtown renting an apartment.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by spxneo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:36PM (#39711208)
Incorrect. There are affordable homes outside city of Vancouver. Vancouver itself is now rezoning for multistory units and converting shed into housing.

Building more supply when you have inelastic demand is unrealistic and will do nothing to the price. As I've said it is the banking relationships of those multimillion dollar homes that is fueling this speculative bubble from locals + foreigners. The only way to attack this problem is to start from the root. Banks are incentivized to give HELOC because many Canadian retirees are relying on it for their livelihood and why would banks kick their own bee hive.

If you lived here for 2 years then you would know where False Creek is and why building 20,000 units around one of the most expensive area is NOT going to result in trickle down effect like most are claiming.

I'm suggesting rental controls that is on a sliding scale based on income NOT based on how long you lived in Vancouver which is what a certain political elements are trying to pull.

If somebody is making 60k/year they are not going to own homes period and its irresponsible to give them that insane leverage without auditing. Somebody making 600k/year should own homes because the sliding scale model would make their rental expensive.

Your other point conflating low income as criminals is another attempt to shove words in my mouth. I said these rental units attract criminal elements not that poor people are committing crimes (as you wrongfully assumed). If you lived here you would know these are kids from upper middle class joining gangs and becoming drug dealers. I don't have an answer to why that is. Could be the result of pluralnational dynamics creating isolated disenfranchised second gen.

If you wish to have a worthy discussion that will yield new insights I'm all ears but so far all I've seen people attacking me, they are purposefully infatuated with their own fixed (incorrect) workings of supply & demand (elastic) to a highly inelastic demand market.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by masterj on Thursday March 14, 2024 @06:42PM (#39709818)
Of all the bad racist NIMBY rants, this is definitely one of them
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by spxneo on Thursday March 14, 2024 @09:43PM (#39711252)
I do not own a home so I can't be a NIMBY. If you understood remotely what is taking place here in the Western world, you wouldn't be saying this.

Instead what you should be describing is a inverse colonialism in the West where NIMBYs are the benefactors treating everybody like serfs. Those NIMBYs were blue collar workers in the 70s, 80s who bought when homes cost next to nothing, and now oppressing everybody.

Be careful when you throw around accusations of racism just because somebody has a different view that you can't even offer a rebuttal on. I take it you didn't even read about my sliding income rental proposal in the other comment.

I know this because you logged in after 3 months just to write some half assed comment without offering anything insightful. This is why there is so much stagnation, people like you simply brush off anything they don't understand (because they can't even pay attention if its not a short video format) as racism.

Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by masterj on Thursday March 14, 2024 @10:13PM (#39711399)
Sure thing bud
Re:Vancouver's New Mega-Development by FooBarBizBazz on Thursday March 14, 2024 @05:34PM (#39709240)
Yeah, this is great. The way I see it, potential sovereigns gain legitimacy by organizing things for the good of the people. Right now it looks like the exercise of Squamish sovereignty is in the interest of all people (except property leeches). In which case, by all means run the show. You're doing a better job than the other guys.