News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by rkudeshi on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:20PM (#3969297)
Just me or is it a bit creepy that not only do they have a city-wide CCTV system, but they apparently used it to track specific vehicles?

Perhaps it's just the US mentality of tremendous respect for civil liberties[1], but what they did is actually appalling to me.

[1]: Please, let's not make this a discussion of how civil liberties aren't uniformly enforced in the US. I think we can agree that things like the Bill of Rights affirm more individual liberties in the US than many other countries.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by nextparadigms on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:48AM (#3969499)
Well UK is the country that has just passed a porn ban, and wants to pass a new law to monitor all Internet communications in the country. That puts things into perspective for what we used to think about this "modern western country".

US is actually not that far behind from doing this and more - Constitution or not. They'll just pass the laws and deal with it 10-20 years later. After all US still has the Patriot Act, and that never seemed too constitutional to me.

What's funny is that the Eastern Europe countries are probably the least likely to go this path anytime soon, and that's because it wasn't that long ago when they had revolutions over this kind of thing. But UK and US hasn't really done that in a long time, so neither the Governments nor the people there really get what it means to have mass-surveillance and have the Government know everything you did or want to do, and how bad of a thing that truly is.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by danssig on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:11AM (#3969856)
Don't forget; the UK also put someone in jail for tweeting.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by adamt on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:54AM (#3969972)
For tweeting no. For making vile racist comments over the medium of twitter yes. There is a difference.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by danssig on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:11AM (#3970877)
Well, that's the thing: even in the US, as bad as it has become, saying vile racist comments on the internet wouldn't get you put in jail.

Is the guy a scumbag? Obviously. Should people go to jail for speaking their mind? That's probably where we diverge and think each other are crazy, but the key is: if you can be put in jail for, say, racism then a corrupt government need only make disagreement be framed as racist, for example. It's safer to just allow anyone to say what they want (with obvious exceptions like yelling "FIRE!") and point out why their argument is stupid.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ljf on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:44AM (#3970385)
Might have been referring to: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-south-yorkshire-1173678...

For some balance, the USA didn't let someone into the country because of their tweets: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2093796/Emily-Buntin...

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by melling on Monday May 14, 2012 @07:39AM (#3970514)
Do you realize that this comment is misleading? People make this sort of argument all the time, and I think it's one of the reasons that we waste so much time on irrelevant points. It's basically a game that people play.

Has anyone given it a name? It would be nice to call people out on this.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ScottMFisher on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:23AM (#3969596)
>Well UK is the country that has just passed a porn ban

Excuse me?

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by corin_ on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:54AM (#3969679)
He's thinking of http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120507/02272218799/uk-gov...

But yeah... we're not banning porn. We're not even actually going to start using an opt-in / opt-out system, either.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ljf on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:49AM (#3970399)
As of yesterday TalkTalk (ISP) are now setting all new accounts to 'blocked' by default, users will have to opt in.

It's not /law/ yet, but once all the ISPs fall in line, it won't need to be law.

http://www.techdigest.tv/2012/05/talktalk_turn_o.html

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mike-cardwell on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:17AM (#3970903)
Numerous mobile phone networks also already do this in the UK.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:14AM (#3970323)
He regurgitating the liberal agenda driven drivel from Reddit. Shame they don't fact check anything.

The UK didn't pass a porn ban. Some ISPs now offer an "opt-out" option for people who want the ISP to block things for them.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mike-cardwell on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:33AM (#3970980)
Whilst we're "fact checking", which UK ISPs are offering "opt-out"? Talk Talk is "opt-in" for new accounts. O2 is "opt-in" for their mobile network too. I believe several other mobile networks are "opt-in" too...

[edit] Just to clarify, by "opt-in", I'm referring to opting in to receive everything. Perhaps "opt-out" in reference to opting out of the block, is clearer.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:55AM (#3971043)
For talktalk, you have to opt-in to enable their filtering.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/talktalk-to-offer-paren...

Mobile networks have always done silly blocking, and it takes a phone call to them to ask them to remove it. I assume it's more about them not wanting you to use more data than anything else.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mike-cardwell on Monday May 14, 2012 @10:07AM (#3971102)
Hmm. According to http://www.techdigest.tv/2012/05/talktalk_turn_o.html all new customers get the block unless they specifically ask for it to be removed.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:02PM (#3971924)
Who knows...

It's a bit ridiculous (from the article) "meaning that any new TalkTalk users who require access to such content will first have to "opt-in" through a highly embarrassing call to customer services."

It's hardly "highly embarrassing" to ask them to remove a filter.

If they do go that route though, and as the article claims, ask you to opt-out once a year, then they'll simply lose customers to ISPs that don't hassle their customers.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mike-cardwell on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:21PM (#3972029)
"It's hardly "highly embarrassing" to ask them to remove a filter."

I completely disagree. Many people would be very embarrassed phoning up to have an adult content filter removed. You can argue that they shouldn't be, but that's a different thing altogether.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ktizo on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:49AM (#3969667)
I tried searching for a reference on google, but given the keywords got sidetracked by, well, you know...
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by nodata on Monday May 14, 2012 @02:53AM (#3969811)
> Perhaps it's just the US mentality of tremendous respect for civil liberties .. Please, let's not make this a discussion of how civil liberties aren't uniformly enforced in the US

Then don't write flamebait.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by sneak on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:17AM (#3969419)
The reason I moved out of NYC (and out of the country) was because the NYPD put up cameras on my local (135th Street 1/2/3) subway entrance.

If you think the billions of USD of antiterrorism money is somehow not funding purchase of facial recognition software, you're foolin' yourself.

Collect enough uniquely-identified John Does and you can link them statistically to MetroCard swipes, and then you've got names from the credit cards used to purchase them...

Ride the subway enough times with (a) friend(s), and then they've got part of your social graph, too.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by felipemnoa on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:43AM (#3969483)
Anecdotally speaking, I know people in NYC that live in communities with high crime rates that are happy knowing that their neighborhood is being monitored by the police 24/7. Whether in the long term this is actually a good or a bad thing to have cameras in the streets, I just don't know.

Devil's advocate here, there are countries that have had no such instant surveillance and still managed to oppress their people quite effectively. I don't want to start a flame war so I won't name a country. And many times all it took for you to get arrested was for somebody to accuse you that you were a traitor or that you were badmouthing the government.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by sneak on Tuesday May 15, 2012 @07:04PM (#3979418)
If the cameras did what they're supposed to do, by putting them up, they'd no longer be high crime rate communities.

Were it that cameras reduced crime, we could have a reasonable and rational discussion about where the "privacy/security" lever could be set.

Unfortunately, they don't.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by aes256 on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:04AM (#3970116)
> The reason I moved out of NYC (and out of the country) was because the NYPD put up cameras on my local (135th Street 1/2/3) subway entrance.

You moved out of a city because a CCTV camera got put up on a subway entrance? You're kidding, right?

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by sneak on Monday May 14, 2012 @10:01AM (#3971076)
No, not city, and not just one— I moved out of a COUNTRY because CCTV cameras got put up on EVERY subway entrance. It just happened to be the one next to my house that catalyzed it for me personally.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by eps on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:58AM (#3969687)
Where did you move if you don't mind me asking?
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by bluelu on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:11AM (#3970142)
He probably moved to guantanamo bay. There are no cameras there. ;)
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by zht on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:20AM (#3969428)
there are large swaths of the country without such video surveillance.

did you consider staying within the country?

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by sneak on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:36AM (#3969466)
There aren't large swaths of the country without the USA PATRIOT Act.

From http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/12/realtime/ :

"Federal law enforcement agencies have been tracking Americans in real-time using credit cards, loyalty cards and travel reservations without getting a court order, a new document released under a government sunshine request shows."

There's no hope for privacy or civil liberties in that country. The only nonviolent solution is to leave forever.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by andrewflnr on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:40AM (#3969477)
Where are you now?
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by _delirium on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:44PM (#3969350)
Vaguely, but it sounds like it was a fairly 'manual' sort of tracking: they attached GPS devices to the vehicles, so watching them on CCTV just meant switching to feeds based on the GPS location, rather than some kind of automated vehicle-following algorithm.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mryan on Monday May 14, 2012 @02:24AM (#3969751)
The UK has a scarily-advanced automatic number plate recognition system in place throughout many parts of the UK, particularly London and the south east. The police can, and do, track vehicles in real time using this system. This is particularly true in London, where this is used to enforce the congestion charge.

Although the collection of the congestion charge is automated, this system can be used to alert police to the location of a vehicle in real time.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police-enforced_ANPR_in_the_UK

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by willyt on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:50AM (#3970400)
Civil liberties covers more than just tracking. The UK police are a lot more likely to automatically fine you for speeding or for forgetting to pay you vehicle tax. But on the plus side, they are a lot less likely to shoot you if they come to arrest you for it. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3966187

The focus should be on having a healthy criminal justice system which is completely free of political interference and effective in enforcing sanctions on the police when they behave unjustly and neither Britain or the US can claim that at the moment.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by RyanMcGreal on Monday May 14, 2012 @08:05AM (#3970617)
> I think we can agree that things like the Bill of Rights affirm more individual liberties in the US than many other countries.

The Bill of Rights is so 18th century. I think you'll find that most industrialized liberal democracies have constitutional guarantees of freedom that are more modern and comprehensive than the US version. The UK is something of an anomaly in that it still relies on common law and tradition rather than an explicit bill or charter of rights. The honour system works fine and tends to be self-correcting over the longer term, as long as the government is willing to play along nicely.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by rtkwe on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:16AM (#3969413)
They had planned the IOC's route through the city and had GPS in the cars with them so I doubt the tracking was automated. And England seems semifamous for it's intense use of CCTV systems, on the traffic side larger US cities with advanced traffic control systems have cameras at most (major) intersections.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by shabble on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:38AM (#3970995)
I think a good chunk of it was probably installed as a consequence of terrorist attacks during The Troubles[1], which led to the "Ring of Steel"[2], a fortified security/surveillance cordon around the financial districts.

If you compare those measures to the US response to Sept 11th and others, I think you'll find a lot in common. I think at the time the measures were widely welcomed by the public too, although I'm not certain.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Troubles

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_of_steel_%28London%29

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ljf on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:47AM (#3970392)
Not only that, but number plate recognition means that ANYONE is and can be tracked as you drive around the 'city' of the London - once you enter certain zones your plates are checked to see if you have committed and crimes etc. It's done by a system alongside the CCTV, but doesn't need someone to visually track the car, the system does that automatically.

It part of the same system that charges people for entering the congestion charging zone, and those that drive in bus lanes.

http://www.cityoflondon.police.uk/CityPolice/Advice/TrafficT...

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by aes256 on Monday May 14, 2012 @02:20PM (#3972387)
> Not only that, but number plate recognition means that ANYONE is and can be tracked as you drive around the 'city' of the London - once you enter certain zones your plates are checked to see if you have committed and crimes etc. It's done by a system alongside the CCTV, but doesn't need someone to visually track the car, the system does that automatically.

It's an impressive system, and despite being an ardent supporter of civil liberties, I don't have any problem with it myself.

Vehicles are only stopped if the police have good reason to do so, i.e. they have reason to believe the driver is committing a categorical offence (e.g. the car has no insurance or tax), or if the vehicle/owner has previously been involved in serious crime (e.g. there is a marker on the vehicle linking it to drugs or firearms)...

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ljf on Monday May 21, 2012 @08:01AM (#4002420)
Similarly, I have no issue with it, in fact I like it, a few years ago someone stole parts from a friends car - I was able to get the plate as they escaped. It was great knowing every time they went through London they were likely to be stopped.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by jefftchan on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:48PM (#3969362)
I feel that it's mostly the American mentality of civil liberties. CCTV's are ubiquitous not just in UK but also in Japan, China, Taiwan, etc
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by rkudeshi on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:57PM (#3969385)
Really? I did not know that! Are they as ubiquitous as London's system? (ie. literally every street and corner in the city is covered by a camera)

The only use of cameras in the US that I know of is for red-light cameras, and even those are hotly debated.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by georgespencer on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:08AM (#3970126)
> (ie. literally every street and corner in the city is covered by a camera)

Many street corners have CCTV cameras. The vast majority of them are run by businesses rather than the government and are decentralised, as has been pointed out elsewhere in this thread. It is possible for law enforcement and intelligence agencies to obtain footage from the CCTV stations with warrants if they physically go to the businesses and ask for it. You are perpetuating a half-truth.

(Context: I am from London. I do not give a shit about CCTV cameras OR the Olympics.)

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:20AM (#3970339)
Perhaps that's why the US has such a massively high crime rate compared to London.

Given a choice between being knifed/shot/mugged etc, and having a camera watch me, I'd choose the latter.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by darklajid on Monday May 14, 2012 @07:01AM (#3970418)
Or perhaps not.

Other countries in western Europe are fine without it, and with a low(er) crime rate to boot.

You believe in a connection between surveillance and crimes. Exactly that assumption is the part that seems debatable - even if we ignore the whole privacy argument.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @07:53AM (#3970568)
CCTV increases conviction rates, and acts as a deterrent.

It also serves to make the public feel safer.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by darklajid on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:16AM (#3970898)
And your source is..? I think my post stated that this is exactly the problem: The 'facts' you list are disputed, the discussion ongoing.

This interpretation of yours is not proven. Opponents argue that most statistics are of the causation != correlation kind and that thinking that CCTVs stop crimes is like believing in stopping piracy by suing old ladys for downloading 3 Britney Spears songs.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by helen842000 on Monday May 14, 2012 @07:23AM (#3970471)
Unfortunately it still happens, the only difference is they have footage.

It's not just CCTV, cameras are ubiquitous, in everyones pockets.

Just look at the London riots, and the mugging of a student after he had already been attacked.

It was caught both on smartphone and on CCTV. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-15232750

Even faced with video evidence they pleaded not guilty. http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2012/03/02/john-kafunda-reec...

They've now been sentenced to 5 and 3.5 years in jail.

The cameras didn't stop it happening. The police watch from afar and convict later.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @07:52AM (#3970564)
You're picking out a couple of rare cases, and saying "it still happens".

Try living in the US for a while. Over there it happens every day.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by helen842000 on Friday May 18, 2012 @05:09PM (#3994002)
I'm picking out a case that was caught on CCTV

I'm suggesting that while CCTV provides footage for conviction it doesn't actually make you safer and stop things in progress.

It doesn't matter where you live.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by rangibaby on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:17AM (#3969418)
I would like a source for this, particularly for Japan.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by jbm on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:16AM (#3969582)
I live in Japan. No source, but most utility poles in Tokyo have surveillance cameras attached to them. I can provide pictures if you'd like.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by alan_cx on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:20AM (#3970164)
We British are such scum we cant be trusted with freedom. And then we have....... immigrants. OMG, they are taking over, we are over run...

Yeah, I do like to poke at the US, but the UK is equally fecked up. I think the one real thing we in the UK and US have in common is the notion that we the people are now seen as the enemy of the state.

Trouble is, Im yet to find a suitable country, with the same good stuff the UK has, which is not also equally fecked up. I can imagine Americans like me might think the same thing.

Frankly, I do not know of a country where one can live good and not feel like the enemy of that country.

What I want to know is when will the people, yes us privileged westerners, stand up and say we have had enough. Maybe in Greece and France it has already begun.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by gouranga on Monday May 14, 2012 @03:59AM (#3969979)
The number plate recognition is 100% ineffective.

People use fake plates all the time.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by aes256 on Monday May 14, 2012 @05:12AM (#3970144)
Number plate cloning is a problem, but many of the people who do it aren't the sharpest tools in the shed.

You would have to clone a number plate from an almost identical car (same make, model, colour, etc.) in order not to raise any suspicions.

In many areas of the country there are police forces with ANPR on their patrol cars, and you can bet they'll pull over a car over a mismatch. Most probably quite aggressively, on the presumption that other criminality is involved (e.g. the car is stolen, has been used in bilking of petrol, etc.)

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by cturner on Monday May 14, 2012 @08:45AM (#3970783)
With sufficient processing power, they could hamper this by tracking the region that each number is. If a plate pops up over the other side of town too quickly, or fails to pass through intermediate sectors, it could raise a flag.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ktizo on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:03AM (#3969395)
Not just specific vehicles, the London camera system is setup to try and automatically track all numberplates of all vehicles moving in the city, which is how the congestion tax is implemented. It is run by IBM and Seimens, so they presumably have gathered a lot of valuable data there between them.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/London_congestion_charge#Operat...

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by nknight on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:45PM (#3969352)
Of course it's creepy, but it's not new, either. The UK went Big Brother long before even 9/11, their CCTV obsession has been making international news since the 90s.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by d503 on Monday May 14, 2012 @12:56AM (#3969518)
At least they don't try to hide it. Remember these lovely posters from 2002?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/24992147@N03/2644171457/

Now available in mug and t-shirt form.

http://www.ltmuseumshop.co.uk/search.html?SearchTerm=watchfu...

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by Jimmie on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:11AM (#3969568)
That poster looks like it's advertising a cheesy sci-fi movie.

It creeps me out.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by gaelian on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:48AM (#3969663)
That poster could have come straight out of Alan Moore's "V for Vendetta".

England prevails!

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by slavak on Monday May 14, 2012 @01:51AM (#3969673)
Wow! That is in fact creepy as fuck.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by ticks on Monday May 14, 2012 @02:38AM (#3969777)
I think what outsiders don't realise (due to this hype) is that most of the CCTV isn't linked together. The majority of it is privately run by local businesses and households - it is used after a crime is committed to provide evidence of said crime.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by mibbitier on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:17AM (#3970333)
It's a lost cause trying to explain this to people who don't live in the UK IMHO.

The liberal agenda prevalent on Reddit etc simply refuses to believe that there isn't a huge conspiracy theory, where all those private CCTV systems installed in corner shops, all those local council run CCTV schemes, are all linked together and tunneled into the government so they can spy on people.

But just for the hell of it:

Most CCTV in the UK was installed in the 70s and 80s, when the hardware became cheap. Independent Shop owners installed it so they could catch and prosecute shop lifters. It typically goes straight to a VHS tape which is cycled through and taped over after a few days.

Also for example, you have CCTV in petrol stations to catch people not paying. For some reason this type of thing doesn't seem to exist in the US...

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by freehunter on Monday May 14, 2012 @09:01AM (#3970835)
The US sure does have cameras watching fuel stations, at least here in Michigan. When you drive off without paying, the video is immediately sent to the State Police. CCTV is in almost every store, as well.

The only difference is the wide swath of area between CCTV installs. They don't tend to watch the roads.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by darklajid on Monday May 14, 2012 @06:49AM (#3970398)
I'm an outsider. I didn't realize this.

But this article (I cannot comment on the claims therein) states that people sitting in the "London Traffic Control Center" "followed them using London's infamous CCTV".

So.. If(!) that's true or close enough, then outsider seem to have the right impression?

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by desas on Monday May 14, 2012 @08:25AM (#3970718)
The london congestion charging cameras are all necessarily linked, these are the only ones that they would need.

On major roadside and traffic hotspots we also have cameras to help with accidents & traffic management. I have no idea if these are blinked with london congestion charging cameras.

Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by rsanchez1 on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:22PM (#3969304)
I also find it creepy, but I wonder if the CCTV and traffic light network can be hacked to help you arrive somewhere on time, or even to have a rival arrive late to make them look bad.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by arethuza on Monday May 14, 2012 @04:21AM (#3970020)
Market forces should be applied - each set of traffic lights should take bids from the waiting vehicles. Whoever bids the highest gets to go through.
Re:London traffic lights rigged to win International Olympic... by cubicle67 on Sunday May 13, 2012 @11:50PM (#3969370)