Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by asciilifeform on Tuesday December 16, 2008 @04:08PM
(#400063)
Dr. Lenat still refuses to disclose the source code of Eurisko. He is even on record as having claimed that it was "lost", which seems unlikely.
What is more probable is that the program's much-hyped accomplishments were done with substantial human hand-holding a la Deep Blue, and the author will not risk his decades of academic prestige by allowing us to see the code and judge how high it could have flown on its own.
Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by Tangurena on Saturday December 13, 2008 @06:19PM
(#397058)
I used to play Traveller, and our group at college didn't play the ship-to-ship combat part, just the role playing game (think of it as D&D with only 6-sided dice, space ships and other planets instead of dungeons).
Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by gaika on Saturday December 13, 2008 @03:48PM
(#396944)
Unit of bogosity is the lenat, named after Douglas Lenat. Like the farad it is considered far too large a unit for practical use, so bogosity is usually expressed in microlenats.
Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by akkartik on Saturday December 13, 2008 @05:09PM
(#397004)
But it wasn't always thus. In the dawn of time Lenat actually did stuff.
Funnily enough, I've been playing around with a port of AM for the past coupla weeks. I've had the code for years and never looked at it until now. What got you on Lenat, Peter?
I think the world's coolest AI programs are Eurisko, Copycat and AM.
Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by cabalamat on Saturday December 13, 2008 @08:46PM
(#397149)
> In the dawn of time Lenat actually did stuff.
Harsh, but probably fair. Or as Eliezer Yudkowsky put it "EURISKO may still be the most sophisticated self-improving AI ever built [...] by Douglas Lenat before he started wasting his life on Cyc."
> I've been playing around with a port of AM for the past coupla weeks.
From where is the code for AM available? I ask because some people on an AI list I subscribe to think the Eurisko code is unavailable (but would like to get hold of it). You wouldn't have the Eurisko code too, by any chance?
> I think the world's coolest AI programs are Eurisko, Copycat and AM.
I would agree, in terms of modelling general cognition.
Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by akkartik on Saturday December 13, 2008 @09:54PM
(#397185)
No, eurisko nobody has :) The version of AM I have was written by one of my professors at the University of Texas Austin, and is in an ancient dialect of prolog. I'm not sure if it was ok to redistribute. Let me check.
I got it working on gprolog last week, but it seems to cause stack overflows :(
Re:Eurisko, The Computer With A Mind Of Its Own
by akkartik on Sunday December 14, 2008 @05:13PM
(#397702)
Yes, the original papers indicate it was in lisp. "Why AM appears to work" suggested that a lot of the reason math was a good domain for discovery was just that lisp is well-suited to the domain. And Eurisko could modify heuristics expressed as s-expressions.
People have asked him, but I'm not aware of Lenat ever commenting on the source code. Cycorp is substantially funded by DARPA, and I wouldn't be surprised if Eurisko is part of its IP now.
What is more probable is that the program's much-hyped accomplishments were done with substantial human hand-holding a la Deep Blue, and the author will not risk his decades of academic prestige by allowing us to see the code and judge how high it could have flown on its own.
Thanks for bringing this story back up.
Funnily enough, I've been playing around with a port of AM for the past coupla weeks. I've had the code for years and never looked at it until now. What got you on Lenat, Peter?
I think the world's coolest AI programs are Eurisko, Copycat and AM.
Harsh, but probably fair. Or as Eliezer Yudkowsky put it "EURISKO may still be the most sophisticated self-improving AI ever built [...] by Douglas Lenat before he started wasting his life on Cyc."
> I've been playing around with a port of AM for the past coupla weeks.
From where is the code for AM available? I ask because some people on an AI list I subscribe to think the Eurisko code is unavailable (but would like to get hold of it). You wouldn't have the Eurisko code too, by any chance?
> I think the world's coolest AI programs are Eurisko, Copycat and AM.
I would agree, in terms of modelling general cognition.
I got it working on gprolog last week, but it seems to cause stack overflows :(
So why is that? Does Lenat not want anyone to see it? Or was the code lost?
BTW am I right in presuming that the original AM was written in Lisp?
People have asked him, but I'm not aware of Lenat ever commenting on the source code. Cycorp is substantially funded by DARPA, and I wouldn't be surprised if Eurisko is part of its IP now.
Feel free to email me to take this offline.