News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by tracerbulletx on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:14AM (#39676143)
I'm saying grouping all of those things together is dumb and meaningless. As a taxonomical choice. "this food was processed" is not a useful category for analysis.
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by thereisnospork on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @12:44AM (#39676276)
I would concur: specifically the taxonomy doesn't offer any indication of mechanism, how is the 'processing' negativily affecting my biology? There's nothing in the naming to create a rule from.

Unlike say glycemic index: high glycemic index > releases glucose fast > body can't compensate fast enough > bad (diabetes, poor satiety, etc.) right now it's just processed > ???? > bad (in unspecifiable ways, by unspecifiable means).

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by tornadofart on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:52AM (#39676814)
I don't like that your comment and the parent both got negative reviews. It is a valid contrarian question.

However I would suggest researching about cirrhosis and fatty liver in children. It is a new disease that was unknown up until the 90s and is now common in developed countries. And it has to do with the following: your digestive system has the ability to process nutrients at a certain rate, depending on how hard they are to break down. For example sugar. The cells have a certain rate at which they can metabolize nutrients. The temporary excess is stored in the liver.

Then it becomes not a question of quality rather than quantity. The question then is not "how high is the glycemic index of food X" but "at which rate (i.e. mg of sugar per minute) can this food X be processed by our digestive system, and is this rate too fast for our cells to metabolize, which in turn causes our liver to store the temporary excess?"

Then the boolean variable "is this food X highly processed " becomes a plausible proxy variable, IMO, since refined sugar is something else than whole bread, when we talk about the rate at which nutrients enter the blood stream.

Do I make sense?

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by thereisnospork on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @09:28AM (#39679231)
You make sense, but whats needed is a word that isn't 'processed' that means: 'proxy variable for rate at which nutrients enter the bloodstream' and an objective measure for that word[0].

To put up a bit of a strawman: By what empirical measure, is an apple different (healthier) than an apple-equivalent of raw glucose/fructose + multi-vitamin + fiber supplement? The latter is obviously more processed, but I literally lack the means[1] to say how, why, and to what degree, one is 'healthier' than the other.

[0]Regardless of name, afaik there is no meaningful way to say e.g. kraft mac and cheese is '80% processed, where as homemade with box pasta, fresh cheddar and bechamel, is 50%, and homemade w/ hand-pulled noodles is 25%.

[1]e.g. a test of 'rate of which simple sugars leach in a ISO standardized simulated stomach'.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by stakhanov on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:16AM (#39676674)
I agree as well.

"Processing" food is literally what people do in their kitchens. But that's presumably not what they mean.

Certain kinds of processing have to be applied to food to make it safe for consumption. But that's presumably not what they mean either.

Certain kinds of processing make the nutritional contents of food more bioavailable. Not what they mean.

Certain kinds of processing are required to preserve food. If humans stopped doing it, their environmental footprint would be orders of magnitude higher than it now is. Presumably, that's not what anyone is suggesting who is opposed to processed foods.

Fermenting is a kind of processing, and fermented foods may be playing a role in a healthy microbiome. ...whoops. Again: Not what they are talking about.

So what exactly are they trying to say? ...surely, picking a word other than "processed" would help in clarifying.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by daemonologist on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @01:26AM (#39676454)
I think the category is intended to be useful as a rule of thumb, which people can apply to make snap decisions at the pantry or grocery store. It might make analysis noisier than precisely defined mechanistic categories but if it gets people to act on the research maybe that's worthwhile.

(Of course research into better defined categories and the underlying mechanisms of their health impact is also necessary and extremely valuable.)

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by katzenversteher on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:24AM (#39676707)
I believe in most cases processing means (by choice or accidentally) making faster digestible. Most processes kind of destroy the food (blending, crushing, popping, juicing, extruding) and increase it's surface area so in the digestive tract it digests faster. In case of carbohydrates that often causes a bigger insulin spike and since this is a "growth" hormone it makes the body take in all the other stuff faster as well.

However, I'm also wondering if we have any processing that makes food less digestible and that decreases it's surface area. If so, it would probably be interesting to compare this kind of processing with the other.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by imjonse on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:25AM (#39676715)
You need to find a middle ground between a high level and easily labeled category and scientific rigor. If the aim is raising awareness in consumers, erring on the side of generality and dumbing down is preferred.
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by card_zero on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @02:42AM (#39676776)
What if my aim is to raise awareness of how harmful dumbing down is?
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by imjonse on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @03:06AM (#39676879)
It may not be harmful overall, that is the point. You can get people to eat less of the stuff that makes them ill without requiring them to have time for or interest in science and details. Anyone with enough energy to care will pick the subset of processed foods that they feel are healthy or harmless.

What you call dumbing down is in line with how science works. Rough and inaccurate models first, refined in time or on demand.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by card_zero on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @03:49AM (#39677111)
Terry Pratchett advocated something called "lies-to-children" to communicate science. I saw that, and was ashamed of him. Richard Dawkins wanted "consciousness raising" about certain issues around atheism (in fact, around lying to children), and this activist attitude made me uneasy, because it seemed manipulative, with its inbuilt assumption of correctness and the expected outcome of changing minds in a specific way. Various politicians endorse "nudge theory" with greater or lesser degrees of openness about it. I can't approve of any of this coercion, or your apologetics on the grounds of "it does them good".

Having said that, I think all communication is inescapably slightly manipulative, starting from the mere fact of grabbing the audience's attention. But that doesn't mean we should double down on it.

Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by imjonse on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @05:49AM (#39677717)
I don't think this is about principles, manipulation or anything that is usually a subject of heated and never settled debates. Saying processed food causes illness is a generalization which is very largely true, and considering that a large percentage of the population does not even think of food on the healthy/harmful axis, stating this as publicly as possible is actually the opposite of dumbing down. It is raising awareness for many people, or solidifying a message that others have already heard, and it's raising eyebrows in a smaller percentage of the population, who either already know this and are nitpicking about the message detail, or are generally bothered by the state/media/influencers interfering in how one leads their own life, or fear that such generalizations incorrectly put some traditional food in a bad light (see above comment about cured meats).
Re:The New Science on What Ultra-Processed Food Does to Your... by stakhanov on Tuesday March 12, 2024 @08:05AM (#39678517)
One problem I see (besides the paternalism, and talking down to people) is that "rigid schemas" of the kind that drives normies insane when nerdy types exhibit them and being smart vs. dumb are actually two very separate things.

So, there are tons of people who have rigid schemas, and are actually quite dumb, and watching health food nuts on YouTube is actually a great way to observe them in the wild. If you tell them "don't eat anything that doesn't look the way it looks in nature", they are going to start eating raw soy beans and poison themselves, because "science said so".

I don't think it's doing anyone any good if otherwise reputable news outlets, and actual scientists, throw even more oil into the fire of inaccurate information about nutrition.