Remember that perjury is also a crime and you’re not “allowed” to commit perjury just because you’re testifying in your own defense (which is your choice).
If you’re actually guilty, your defense is supposed to challenge the validity of the evidence the prosecution is using to convict you. Not lie to the court and hope your lies are more convincing than the prosecution’s evidence.
Ideally yes, but prosecution (and the entire process leading to arrest) lies and breaks the law and takes advantage in every way possible. It's a very dishonest process to try to be honest against.
But he seems like an odd person [1] and I wonder what might be atypical about his experiences? It would be interesting to read the experiences of other public defenders. It’s their job to look for problems.
[1] https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/4rsRuNaE4uJrnYeTQ/defunding-...
Regardless of any public defender's opinion, I am inclined to not fully respect opinions of people who are deeply embedded in the thing they have an opinion about, especially if it's in defense of the thing they're deeply embedded in. Humans lose perspective very easily, and especially when their identity is wrapped up in it.
Yes, it's possible that insiders might have a biased view. However, in general, I do respect the opinions of people who have had experiences and write about them more than the comments of random internet strangers who, as far as I know, have no experience.
If you're guilty, the system is not designed to protect you, and there's no reason why it should permit the guilty to commit perjury out of some desire to balance out (?) the fact that the prosecution and police sometimes lie as well.
What is a scenario where an innocent person needs to be allowed to lie to present an effective defense?
The purpose of the justice system should not be to give guilty people the best chance to stay out of prison.
Yes, if you're guilty, lying may be your best defense. That doesn't mean the justice system should encourage it! If you're guilty, the justice systems want you to go to jail. All the protections exist to protect innocent people.
You know, it would be terrible if I was found guilty of willful copyright infringement under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which carries "A fine of not more than $500,000 or imprisonment for not more than five years, or both, for the first offense"[1]. If I had committed such a terrible act as torrenting seven movies, the insult to my conscience would surely move me to accept the felony penalties with civic stoicism - after such twisted malice from myself, the additional moral consequences of pleading "Not Guilty" would be too great to bear.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_law_of_the_United_St...
I'm not expressing an opinion on whether throwing someone in jail for torrenting movies is the right moral outcome. What I am saying is that a system which officially says "Yes, lying in court is legally permissible as long as you're lying about something related to a bullshit law" is not exactly sustainable.
I think the DMCA is a stupid and unfair law. The mafia probably thinks RICO is a stupid and unfair law. Someone who is a habitual drunk driver (but is convinced they can 'handle their liquor' better than the general public) probably thinks drunk driving laws are stupid and unfair. What of it?
This interpretation of 'eleven magic words' also suggests it matters: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33471299
Or if you really think you can lie your way to acquittal, then you can successfully convince your lawyer of your lie. If your lawyer can see through your bullshit as easily as the examples he gives, you're not going to fool the court.
And then you shot her, correct?!
Answer: No I did not shoot her! I never did that.
And your lawyer knows it is a lie that you indeed did shoot her, it could be problematic at that point, depending on some jurisdiction.
I guess it depends if you think an effective defense should allow the guilty to go free?
But the fact we're debating how open defence lawyers are supposed to be and there is jurisdictional variation is a good indication of why criminals might feel they're best served lying to their defence lawyer, and lying as elaborately as possible rather than just avoiding confessing. The potential consequences of telling the truth are much worse than merely having your public defender think you're a fool. Plus if you're intending to test whether your denials are believable before you use them in court, you won't get a better opportunity than a privilege-protected conversation with someone who's seen a lot of excuses...
Say someone says to their lawyer they shot the person but really they are covering for their wife even to mthe lawyer. The lawyer then hears them say in court they didn’t shoot (the truth) but the lawyer just knows they are saying something different now to what they said before. It could be that.
I'm not the author of the post referred to here, but I suspect that 'guilty' was intended to be read as 'actually committed the crime'.
To be clear, I support the principle that it is the acquittal of a perpetrator is far less of a miscarriage of justice than is the conviction of someone other than the perpetrator.
That said they also say here it depends on the jurisdiction so in some jurisdictions it won't matter that you know if your client is lying.
hmm - potentially can you start a case in jurisdiction 1 where rules are a certain way and then get case moved to a different jurisdiction where it is different? Seems unlikely and probably not something competent lawyer would allow - but still...
No its not, holy shit.
Lying to your lawyer is a terrible idea. The lawyer is there to HELP YOU and present an effective defense. If you lie to the lawyer, the lawyer works with a different set of baseline arguments for your defense. If the lie is revealed, the defense is broken, it doesn't matter anymore. Months of work tossed out the window, nobody trusts the defendant anymore, and the lawyer needs to figure out damage control rather than actually defending you.
Repeat. If anyone finds out you lied, you are FUCKED. Trust goes out the window, Judge thinks you're a unrepentant idiot, most possibility of leniency in the case you are considered guilty is dropped.
It's literally one of the worst things you can do at trial.
There is zero reason to lie to your lawyer, all you do is make them less prepared in their defense.
> It’s true, a client can show me where they buried their dozen murder victims and I wouldn’t be allowed to tell a soul, even if an innocent person is sitting in prison for their crimes.
At least in Alabama (for no specific reason other than it was the first hit I found):
> RULE 3.3: CANDOR TOWARDS THE TRIBUNAL
> (a) A lawyer shall not knowingly:
> (2) fail to disclose a material fact to a tribunal when disclosure is necessary to avoid assisting a criminal or fraudulent act by the client
Seems to me that knowing that your client is materially guilty and an innocent person has been convicted for their crimes is "assisting a criminal or fraudulent act" by your client.
'I'm sorry your honor, I have to withdraw from this matter because my client, who is a bit dim, has just told me at the lunch break that he totally did the thing, and also that he's going to lie his ass off about it when he gets up in the witness box in just a minute'
But the next time you hear a lawyer withdraw because they're 'forensically embarrassed', you'll know what happened