But make no mistake - we could, as a society, invest heavily in developing privacy-first platforms and software, and have it all. I can't even say that we choose not to; it's more that representative democracy is not particularly representative in practice, and mostly works as a form of veto.
People choose to watch youtube with ads rather than pay for youtube premium without ads.
People buy the kindle with ads on the lockscreen over paying $20 or whatever more for an ad-free one.
When given the choice of a $3 app store app with no ads vs an identical free one with ads, users pick the ads.
Picking ads is effectively the same as choosing a lower price (free) over privacy, and people seem to consistently pick in this direction.
Because of that, I don't think it's fair to say that users aren't actually making any choice here. Users are choosing free services over privacy.
Ads are orthogonal to privacy. We've had privacy-preserving ads in physical newspapers for hundreds of years.
There is no reasonable way for a normal person to consistently choose privacy these days.
The average American isn't exactly awash in cash to spend on privacy, you know.
We are not talking about a lot of money in most cases. I usually compare it to coffee shops. People will pay $10 at a coffee shop for a latte and a snack, but they refuse to pay even $5 for a software app or game that they might use every day.
The government pushes surveillance too but in my experience it’s the secondary driver, at least in the US. Might be different in other countries.
I’m really pessimistic about privacy online given that every single incentive both public and private encourages maximum privacy invasion and centralization. I mean every single incentive. It’s almost impossible to resist.
We might have a chance if end users cared enough to pay for privacy and avoid things that invade it, but very few do. Most people care about convenience, features, and cost, and that’s it. Nothing else matters.