Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer...
by int_19h on Monday March 04, 2024 @03:00AM
(#39588061)
People pick ads, it is true. They do not explicitly pick "track you everywhere to build a hyper-accurate profile of you that can then push precisely tuned ads at you", though. That part is buried in the EULAs.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer...
by slavik81 on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:03AM
(#39590604)
You cannot buy privacy with a credit card. You tie your identity to an account when you pay for it.
Ads are orthogonal to privacy. We've had privacy-preserving ads in physical newspapers for hundreds of years.
There is no reasonable way for a normal person to consistently choose privacy these days.
Re:Commerce Department Proposes Imposing "Know Your Customer...
by CatWChainsaw on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:47PM
(#39598902)
I have never heard of an ad-free lockscreen on Kindle and I pay for Kindle Unlimited. So I have to pay even more to get ad-free, if that's even possible. And I'm sure that's just for Kindle. Need to cough up a few more dollars for ad-free Prime Video. And ad-free shopping on Amazon. And that's just one service. Can't wait to hear what I'd need to spend for the same if I used Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, and a Quest even though Meta owns all of them. And I can just imagine the hellscape Microsoft will create when you have to pay a subscription fee to use Windows 12 Home With Ads, as your baseline option.
The average American isn't exactly awash in cash to spend on privacy, you know.
People choose to watch youtube with ads rather than pay for youtube premium without ads.
People buy the kindle with ads on the lockscreen over paying $20 or whatever more for an ad-free one.
When given the choice of a $3 app store app with no ads vs an identical free one with ads, users pick the ads.
Picking ads is effectively the same as choosing a lower price (free) over privacy, and people seem to consistently pick in this direction.
Because of that, I don't think it's fair to say that users aren't actually making any choice here. Users are choosing free services over privacy.