News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:47AM (#39549979)
UBI is so dystopian I would hope the US is smart enough to reject it wholly. Sadly, just like every bad scheme, there won't be an opt out.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by ceejayoz on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:48AM (#39549985)
Sure there is. Just give it back if you don't want it. https://www.fiscal.treasury.gov/public/gifts-to-government.h...
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by gameman144 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:55AM (#39550095)
As a general rule, "if you don't like this rule we're adding, don't take advantage of it" is a pretty terrible argument. It's absolutely fair to say that a rule shouldn't be implemented while also acknowledging that if it is, it is the best strategy to take advantage of it if it is.

For instance, imagine if the NFL decided to give up to two extra points after a touchdown for how stylishly the players celebrated, as voted by a panel of judges in the end zone. This would be a terrible addition in most people's eyes. If it went through anyway, though, you can bet that every team would start dancing their hearts out after each touchdown.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by ceejayoz on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:27AM (#39550606)
> This would be a terrible addition in most people's eyes.

Implementing UBI nationally in the US would almost certainly require a constitutional amendment, which is going to require overwhelmingly positive sentiment about it from the electorate.

Individuals remaining opposed at that point will have the same fiscal recourses they have to not liking NASA sending probes to Mars.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by xyst on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:03AM (#39550226)
I used to think “streamers” and “influencers” started the donation farming trend. But it was the US government that started the begging trend in 1843.

Just like donos to bathtub streamers and influencers via patreon, this is also a significant waste of money and time.

Doesn’t look like these gifts would be tax deductible either. Lol

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:52AM (#39550042)
That doesn't solve the whole problem. It requires more interaction with the state instead of just allowing an opt out. It also doesn't allow opting out at the paying in layer.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by ceejayoz on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:57AM (#39550127)
> It also doesn't allow opting out at the paying in layer.

This is the case for every other program, right?

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:01AM (#39550197)
There's a lot we need to fix in the USA, but adding more mandatory programs will make that more difficult.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by danielbln on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:51AM (#39550027)
Things look pretty dystopian as it stands, and if concentration of wealth continues, we'll speed down that dark road even faster. If not UBI, what other solution is there? Especially as automation sweeps through cognitive work?
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by Gormo on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:12AM (#39550380)
What do you see is the fundamental problem with concentration of wealth (by which I assume you mean concentration of relative wealth, which seems to be what most people who discuss this topic are looking at)?

I'd agree that if absolute wealth is being concentrated, that could pose a serious problem, because it would ultimately make large swaths of the population dependent for their livelihoods on a small, centralized set of people who determine the disposition of wealth.

But I'm not sure how UBI -- a program that would make large swaths of the population dependent for their livelihoods on a small, centralized set of people who determine the disposition of wealth -- is a solution to this problem rather than a de jure entrenchment of it.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by endominus on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:59AM (#39550162)
"We don't have a solution to fix it so let's try the solution that makes it worse" is not a very compelling argument.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by danielbln on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:11AM (#39550376)
That's OP's argument, I don't think UBI is a solution that makes things worse. That said, I'd like to know what the alternative could be, hence my line of questioning.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by endominus on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:16AM (#39551307)
Have you looked into Georgism?
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:54AM (#39550085)
We need to be radically cutting immigration now along with collapsing birth rates such that worker supply and worker demand reach equilibrium.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by drcongo on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:01AM (#39550193)
Aaaaand there it is.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:02AM (#39550219)
Is your proposal that the USA needs to import more people we don't have work for so we can put them on UBI?
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by dagw on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:40AM (#39550813)
The more likely scenario if the US implements UBI, is they'll probably need to import a lot more people on various work visas (and who won't get UBI) to do all the jobs people on UBI won't do any more.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by spiderfarmer on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:12AM (#39550385)
There are more than enough jobs. If your deepest fear is that people with different cultural backgrounds will replace people like you, you don't want have an actual debate about policy. You just want to remain in your safe space.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:19AM (#39550504)
You are leaving money on the table if you haven't used your mind reading skills to get the James Randi Educational Foundation million dollar prize.

The question was how do we deal with the coming lack of jobs without UBI. The answer is we peacefully reduce our population. This pre-supposes a lack of jobs. If you want to change the conditions of the question and say there will be more than enough jobs then we don't need UBI.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by drcongo on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:07AM (#39550299)
I'm not proposing anything. It's just inevitable that when a right wing throwaway account posts about anything, it's just so they can steer around to their favourite topic of The Foreigns.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:11AM (#39550370)
At some point it has to come down to that. The USA is (mostly) not growing through birth so any proposal to gradually decrease the population has to include immigration. As AI advances I believe having a lower population will be a competitive advantage.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by drcongo on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:06AM (#39551181)
Nothing ever "has to come down to" foreigners unless that's your preassigned agenda that you want to bring everything around to. Pretty much every study ever done has concluded that immigration is a net benefit to a country's GDP and emigration is a net loss.

> The USA is (mostly) not growing through birth so any proposal to gradually decrease the population has to include immigration.

You're going to need to explain how you've managed to bring The Foreigns into this, you've just glued together two unrelated statements. You say that the US population isn't growing through birthrates, and then talk about population decrease and immigration as though that's related. If the US population isn't growing through birthrates, and people continue to die (which is pretty much a given), then you've got your wish without ever needing your racism.

Out of interest, which of the First Nations tribes were you born into?

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:20AM (#39551383)
> You're going to need to explain how you've managed to bring The Foreigns into this, you've just glued together two unrelated statements. You say that the US population isn't growing through birthrates, and then talk about population decrease and immigration as though that's related.

As far as I can tell, population growth in the USA is from people moving here from other places. Not as a result of growth from people having children.[1]

Assuming we live in a world where AI eats jobs, which as far as I can tell is what we are talking about, I would expect population growth, regardless of birth or flowing from another country to stop being beneficial. I agree with you that under current system it is a net benefit.

>Out of interest, which of the First Nations tribes were you born into?

How is that relevant?

[1] https://www.brookings.edu/articles/new-census-projections-sh...

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by drcongo on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:37AM (#39551663)
> Assuming we live in a world where AI eats jobs, which as far as I can tell is what we are talking about

No, this is a thread about billionaires lobbying against UBI. You brought AI into it so you could have a go about the foreigners.

> How is that relevant?

It's relevant because you're so anti-immigration that surely you must be native to the land you live on, otherwise you're just another racist pulling the ladder up behind you.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:47AM (#39551814)
> You brought AI into it so you could have a go about the foreigners.

I think you'll find I was answering danielbln about AI and a lack of jobs.

> It's relevant because you're so anti-immigration that surely you must be native to the land you live on, otherwise you're just another racist pulling the ladder up behind you.

Why are you wasting your time with me when you could be winning a James Randi Educational Foundation million dollar prize for showing off your mind reading? Since you're wrong about my internal state I have no use responding to you.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:24AM (#39551452)
Don't feed the troll, folks, This is a junk comment, probably by a bot.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by throwawa14223 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:55AM (#39551953)
I think my comment above was made in haste because UBI seems dire to me. But, barring some sort of Cartesian evil demon tricking me I am not a bot.
Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday February 29, 2024 @07:38PM (#39557129)
Then perhaps post under an actual account? That one does not lend itself to much credibility.

I normally don't reply to such accounts at all.

Re:Billionaire-Fueled Lobbying Group Behind the State Bills ... by effingwewt on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:50PM (#39558630)
Would have been better had you not. Many people have many reasons not to post under their government names.

Just because yours looks real doesn't make it so. Anyone can make up a real-sounding name.