I parsed that as "50% of the time, monty opens another door and it has a car and you win immediately, and 50% of the time, monty opens another door and it has a goat". In retrospect I think my brain just sort of pictured that and proceeded to assume there was no reason to switch, and it wasn't until I read some answers (not her explanation) that I understood I was wrong (and I went through a lot of anger, like many of the commenters, and thought she was very wrong before that).
If there had been exactly one more sentence saying "monty always opens a door showing a goat", I'm pretty sure I would have recognized that. BTW I was familiar with the game (I liked Jeopardy better, as Let's Make a Deal was a fairly dull show) and I don't think they had a game that was identical to the problem as described.
Why would you think you won? You didn't choose that one with the car and you aren't offered the opportunity to switch to the open one, only the closed one. The only interpretation which makes sense is that he always shows you a goat.
edit: this is wrong, dekhn was right, see below
edit: i ran a monty carlo simulation¹ and i was doing the math wrong. it really does matter if monty knows or not. here's the simulation where he knows:
In [15]: non_censored_trials = got_car_trials = 0
In [16]: for trial in range(100_000):
...: car_door = random.randrange(3) # the other two doors have goats
...: your_door = random.randrange(3)
...: monty_door = random.choice(list({0, 1, 2} - {your_door, car_door}))
...: if monty_door == car_door:
...: print("Monty showed the car, never mind")
...: continue
...: non_censored_trials += 1
...: your_new_choice = next(iter({0, 1, 2} - {your_door, monty_door})) # you change your choice
...: if your_new_choice == car_door:
...: print(f"You got the car because you changed from {your_door} to {your_new_choice}")
...: got_car_trials += 1
...: else:
...: print(f"Too bad you changed; you should have stuck with {your_door}")
(...output omitted...)
In [17]: got_car_trials / non_censored_trials
Out[17]: 0.66921
so in ⅔ of the cases, switching doors gets you the car. by contrast, if monty didn't know which door would reveal a car, it's only ½ of the cases: In [21]: non_censored_trials = got_car_trials = 0
In [22]: for trial in range(100_000):
...: car_door = random.randrange(3) # the other two doors have goats
...: your_door = random.randrange(3)
...: monty_door = random.choice(list({0, 1, 2} - {your_door}))
...: if monty_door == car_door:
...: print("Monty showed the car, never mind")
...: continue
...: non_censored_trials += 1
...: your_new_choice = next(iter({0, 1, 2} - {your_door, monty_door})) # you change your choice
...: if your_new_choice == car_door:
...: print(f"You got the car because you changed from {your_door} to {your_new_choice}")
...: got_car_trials += 1
...: else:
...: print(f"Too bad you changed; you should have stuck with {your_door}")
(...output omitted...)
In [23]: got_car_trials / non_censored_trials
Out[23]: 0.49987257709086
so if monty picked the goat door on purpose, you do gain by switching. but if he just got lucky, you don't______
¹ thank you, manoj
Edit: having written this, thinking about the 100 door case. If 98 random doors open (that aren't the one I picked) then the fact they all contain goats is pretty suggestive that I have the car, or at least 50/50. I'm not convinced by the code example though.
-There's a 1/100 chance my door is a car, in which case it doesn't matter which of the others stays closed, it will always be a goat. The game will proceed, and switching will lose.
-There's a 99/100 chance my door is a goat, in which case the car is behind some other door. Choosing 98 out of 99 doors to open at random is the same as choosing 1 out of 99 doors to leave closed at random. So the chance that the car stays hidden in this case (so that switching will win) is 1/99, and 98/99 that the game ends early because the car is revealed.
-Adding it up, the game ends without the chance to make a choice 99/100 * 98/99 = 98/100 of the time. Of the remaining 2%, 1/100 comes from the first case (switching loses) and 99/100 * 1/99 = 1/100 comes from the second case (switching wins). The strategies are equally effective.
That's exactly the point. If he doesn't know, then it's exactly 50/50 and there is no reason to switch. If he does know, then it's 1/NUM_DOORS versus NUM_DOORS-1/NUM_DOORS, so you'd be crazy not to switch.
The point is, if he picks at random, in the 100 door case, the vast majority of the time he will open the car door while opening those 98 doors. The case where you get to pick again would be exceedingly rare. Conversely, if he only opens goat doors, you will get your second pick 100% of the time.
So you thought that eliminating them you were left with the original 1/3 vs 2/3, when you actually removed half of the 2/3.
In the random-open case, you really know nothing new about either of the closed doors. If you can talk yourself into switching, you could make an equally good argument for switching back.
In the Monty-knows-and-always-shows-goat case, you have gained information about one of the closed doors. You haven't gained any information about your initial pick door. But the other remaining door, you know there's a 2/3rds chance that Monty was forced to avoid it so as not to reveal the car. Only in the 1/3rd case where you were already on the car does Monty have freedom to open either door willy nilly.
I've always admired folks who can do these sorts of things in their head, while it takes me a bunch of time to inspect the code and convince myself it's an accurate representation of the word problem.
There is no randomness in this sentence. The door has a goat, not a car.
Then again, you might read it as an example outcome. But even if the door was chosen randomly, it would not justify the 50%/50% answer.
Independently of that, assuming that the host chooses the door with the car and the goat with 50% probability each is the same mistake that confused so many, you cannot always assume uniform probability only because there are 2 options.
(I wanted to point out the flaws in your thinking because this has also been a confusing problem for me)
Personally the whole thing taught me is one true hallmark of intelligence is the ability to eliminate unnecessary ambiguity and find the "right" answer.
I don't think it's obvious that Marilyn's interpretation is the correct one. Two possible interpretations could be equally valid.
In law we have the "rule of the last antecedent" that says descriptive clauses modify the nearest antecedent noun.
Under this interpretation "which has a goat" modifies the exemplary door "say #3". Same as saying host opens a door, for example door #3 containing a goat. It could have been say door #2 containing a car.
Marilyn's interpretation is that "which has a goat" modifies "host opens another door." Same as saying the door opened by the host always has a goat.
Language is inherently ambiguous. I don't think either interpretation is unreasonable...
Suppose you’re on a game show, and you’re given the choice of three doors. Behind one door is a car, behind the others, goats. You pick a door, say #1, and the host, who knows what’s behind the doors, opens another door, say #3, which has a goat. He says to you, "Do you want to pick door #2?" Is it to your advantage to switch your choice of doors? Craig F. Whitaker Columbia, Maryland
Yes; you should switch. The first door has a 1/3 chance of winning, but the second door has a 2/3 chance. Here’s a good way to visualize what happened. Suppose there are a million doors, and you pick door #1. Then the host, who knows what’s behind the doors and will always avoid the one with the prize, opens them all except door #777,777. You’d switch to that door pretty fast, wouldn’t you?
-----
Yes, the question as posed by a reader was ambiguous but Marilyn made a very reasonable interpretation based on what someone at that time would probably tend to know about game shows. And she even gave an explanation (using more doors) that I find tends to work with folks combined with the explicit assumption that the host will always pick goats.