These days it comes off very much as “I have liked and subscribed to multiple varied topics/channels on YouTube making me quite knowledgeable and naturally that makes me special/intellectual in a world where everyone else are ASMR seeking simpletons”
Re:Polymaths Are Late Bloomers
by reducesuffering on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:33PM
(#39506760)
I think in these intellectual bubbles, people wildly overestimate how much the average person has any interest or knowledge in the kind of breadth things like HN and OvercomingBias offer. Polymaths are highly over-represented here. There are 18m people in Greater Los Angeles. How many are involved in anything close to the variety of topics HN and OvercomingBias ponder?
Re:Polymaths Are Late Bloomers
by SantalBlush on Sunday February 25, 2024 @07:17PM
(#39506383)
I'd personally add "autodidact" to that list as well.
Re:Polymaths Are Late Bloomers
by whimsicalism on Sunday February 25, 2024 @09:20PM
(#39506998)
I disagree - polymath to me implies Newton or Euler, autodidact just implies that you are good at learning on your own.
Re:Polymaths Are Late Bloomers
by SantalBlush on Sunday February 25, 2024 @11:10PM
(#39507571)
Agreed, but whether or not someone is capable of accurately self-assessing how well they've learned a topic depends on how well they've actually learned the topic.
This means someone can do a bad job of learning a topic on their own, but still believe they're an autodidact. I think that happens a lot.
My first reaction as well. His bio [1] does seem to support the assertion, and I've heard of his work on prediction markets and the term the Great Filter, but that same bio is also all sorts of red-flaggy to me. He has "1100 media mentions?" You need to put that in your university bio page?
Re:Polymaths Are Late Bloomers
by aodonnell2536 on Monday February 26, 2024 @12:35AM
(#39507968)
Most true polymaths (and autodidacts in the colloquial sense) don’t refer to themselves as such, solely looking at their breadth of work is enough
I don't know, at this stage calling yourself polymath is a big red flag for me. Like calling yourself an "intellectual" or "thought leader".