Around age 12 I discovered software development and became my greatest passion. It helped me escape MMORPG addiction and being happy (have a family, buy a home, pursue my hobbies).
If I lost my job I would be sad, no doubt, but I would still be me, a passionate software developer. If you told me I wouldn't be able to write code anymore because of some illness, I would be in a very bad spot, way worse than if I lost my job.
My profession is part of my identity in a strong way, my job is business (although I do love the place I work at).
By the time o graduated from college in 1996, I programmed as a hobbyist in assembly on four architectures - 65C02, 68K, PPC and x86.
The last time I programmed as a hobbyist was 1996.
For the next 15 years my hobby was teaching fitness classes, running and lifting weights.
I got married in 2012 and became a father to a 9 and 14 year old.
When the youngest graduated in 2020 and a year after Covid lifted, my wife and flew across the US from October 2022 to October 2023 visiting over a dozen cities while I worked remotely,
Software development supports my passions.
I would spend more time in the gym and go back to teaching fitness classes and do personal training.
I would learn a couple of foreign languages.
My wife and I sold everything we owned and bought a unit in a condotel (https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/condotel.asp) it is our legal official “home”.
From 10/2022 - 10/2023 we traveled around the US taking one way flights and rented our place out.
We would do more international traveling. I was limited to traveling mostly in the US since I had to fly to client’s sites, restrictions on logging in outside of the country for some GovCloud work and time zones.
But, to be fair, work != your specific company. It's stupid to tie your identity to the people hiring you.
These two concepts may seem related but they often aren't.
If you spend a large part of your waking hours working on something enjoyable, absolutely embrace that. Conversely, if your work is drudgerous but you enjoy the simple things in life - like food and shelter - and it provides that then maybe some separation of identity is a good option too.
Besides: If your one and only goal with work really is "do as little as possible to not die", this is easily accomplished in the modern world by working for a year or two in the US and then moving to, e.g. rural Nepal to live off $1-2000 a year for about 3 or 4 decades, zero work required. Indeed the "4% rule" in FIRE circles says this should be permanently sustainable with savings of only about $20-40,000. (Arguments like "but what happens when you get older" willfully ignore the fact thathaving a year of prime healthy adulthood totally free is almost certainly worth quite a bit more than having a year of elderly, ill adulthood "free" in a nursing home.) Yet we almost never see people do that.
There are plenty of people doing that (until their funds run out, which always happens faster than planned).
"My work is how I directly make the world a much richer place than it would be without me "
And richer in real ressources? Numbers of money are a arbitary thing and do not necessary relate, if they actually make the world a better place.
(How annuities work, roughly: Say you have $100,000 in that nest egg. I'm sure you could find some financial firm willing to take it off your hands today and give you $4,000 per year for 50 years, and maybe even in perpetuity. That's because $100k sitting around in their index funds will likely have ballooned to $1m+ over that timeframe, whereas the payout to you would be a mere $200k.)
The fact such annuities aren't very common suggests your phantom population isn't either.
Well, just travel a bit through south east asia then and you will meet quite some (white) folks living there, but not working.
"I'm sure you could find some financial firm willing to take it off your hands today and give you $4,000 per year for 50 years"
I surely could find such a company, but not sure if I could find one I would trust(not that I am rich anyway). And africa can be quite unsafe for rich people, too.
Also, like I said: the main issue those people have, who want to retire in poor countries is, that wealth goes away quite fast. Even when you don't want to buy a house and have a family which most people want at some point etc. and which is something that is expensive as a westener in those countries, too. But for some time, you can live like a king there, sure.
You are probably going too far. You are spending a reasonable fraction of your waking life at your career. So you can make it a reasonable fraction of your identity.
I think there's some crossed wires there. You both could be correct, but arguing different specific points.
You can make your skillset/vocation/etc a part of your identity. You should never make your position at a company a part of your identity.
"I write software" is something that will be true even when I am no longer employed. "I'm a principle engineer at a FAANG" is a transient thing that is only incidental to my identity.
I ask this as a thought experiment because I personally believe that we THINK people care about our jobs more than they really do. True friendship should (and does) transcend "jobs".
Maybe I'm an outlier - but I believe most folks just want to have a good time with their friends - specific careers be damned!
Granted having Google on the CV looks good to recruiters, but my friends didn't care that much.
Knocking your ego down to a reasonable size is nice, but it probably also means not making very much money.
I often think about that Isabel Fall attack helicopter story [1], where pilots of the AH-70 Apache Mystics must have their brains rewired to include the helicopter as part of their gender, so that they'll fly by intuition. Otherwise they wouldn't be good enough to fly.
I thought this was an interesting premise already, but now I wonder how much of my programming skill is really ego. How much of my code takes up space in my brain where gender or religion or joi de vivre or something was supposed to be stored.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Sexually_Identify_as_an_Atta...
I certainly agree about the apathy part. I can’t sustain mediocre or poor performance for long without having it spill into other areas of my life.
As for the impossibility of compartmentalizing software work… I hope you’re wrong. But my experience doesn’t exactly contradict you. Whenever I’ve felt good at my job it’s also been quite all-consuming.
In 1963, Kurt Vonnegut called it a _granfalloon_: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cat%27s_Cradle#Bokononism
- _karass_ – A group of people linked in a cosmically significant manner, even when superficial linkages are not evident.
- _granfalloon_ – a false karass; i.e., a group of people who imagine they have a connection that does not really exist. An example is "Hoosiers." Hoosiers are people from Indiana, and Hoosiers have no true spiritual destiny in common. They really share little more than a name.
This is not an easy task when many (most?) adults spend the majority of their waking hours either working or going to and from work.
https://www.fuqua.duke.edu/duke-fuqua-insights/kay-passion-e...
> The researchers found that people consider it more legitimate to make passionate employees leave family to work on a weekend, work unpaid, and handle unrelated tasks that were not in the job description.
> The team found passion exploitation consistently across eight studies with more than 2,400 total participants. The studies varied in design, in the participants (students, managers, random online samples) and in the kinds of jobs they considered.
> In one study, participants who read that an artist was strongly passionate about his job said it was more legitimate for the boss to exploit the artist than those who read the artist wasn’t as passionate. This finding extended to asking for work far beyond the job description, including leaving a day at the park with family and cleaning the office bathroom.
It's just obvious there's a chip on their shoulder. By default, no one cares about these things.
One of my friends cares most about her family, her husband cares about that but work is a much stronger part of his identity.
Many of my smartest friends work remotely very successfully. Others like me, just as smart, work in person well.
Our friends and family who work in restaurants and factories and driving buses are often happy, though some are not. And more of the knowledge workers are happy because they're wealthier but some are unhappy regardless.
But the most striking thing is the difference between the ones who are choosing their path and secure vs. the ones who show other signs of insecurity: it's the statement of their choices as being their own without the obligatory put down of the other. This mechanism of justifying their choices. Insecurity pervades. The person choosing other than them is always flawed in some way they are not. The other's choices alloyed by some sin.
My work is only part of my identity.
I'd argue that unless you're literally curing cancer, it should be the least important part of your identity.
I've never let work be more than the tiniest facet of my existence that provides the resources necessary to well... not die.
I understand this isn't the easiest thing for most people - tribalism and pack identity is a powerful thing.
It's why we have entires throngs of people who follow celebrities / twitch streamers / influencers / voice actors / etc. It's why things like the "reality distortion field" around Steve Jobs exists. And well, it's why when people suddenly find themselves let go from a job, it apparently affects them in a powerfully and I would argue irrationally emotional way.
In a way, these things have sort of acted as a de-facto substitute for more traditional tribalism (patriotism, national pride, etc) for a lot of Gen Z / Millennials. Shrugs. Or maybe this is just a personal observation.
Note: Just to be fair, I think her breakdown was FAR FAR more understandable than many people who are let go given that: