News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Knots on Mars (and a few thoughts on NASA's knots) (2012) by imglorp on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:12AM (#39479236)
I think it's the knot application and not the culture driving the requirements. For example, we all know what a square knot is, but it's difficult to untie when stressed and wet. A reef knot on the other hand has a loop for its second half hitch which makes it easy to untie. This is why it was used to reef sails at sea when wet and bouncing.
Re:Knots on Mars (and a few thoughts on NASA's knots) (2012) by rrr_oh_man on Friday February 23, 2024 @06:16AM (#39479261)
Aren’t square and reef knots one and the same?
Re:Knots on Mars (and a few thoughts on NASA's knots) (2012) by GuB-42 on Friday February 23, 2024 @07:32AM (#39479756)
They are, what GP is describing is called a slipped reef/square knot.

Reef knots without the loop can also be capsized for quick untying. It is a dangerous property of that knot for some situations, and a reason some people think is shouldn't be taught as a general purpose knot. But it can be useful in specific cases like in reefing, as its name suggests.

Re:Knots on Mars (and a few thoughts on NASA's knots) (2012) by RetroTechie on Friday February 23, 2024 @10:57AM (#39482199)
> I think it's the knot application and not the culture driving the requirements.

Bingo! From article:

"Knots are still used in this high-tech arena because cable lacing has long been the preferred cable management technique in aerospace applications. That it remains so to this day is a testament to the effectiveness of properly chosen knots tied by skilled craftspeople."

If there's a better way (not saying there isn't!), prove it. Knots 'just work', use a minimal amount of material (weight), and are reliable low-tech proven over ages.

Of course, effectiveness / reliability depends heavily on "properly chosen knots" (+materials) and "tied by people who know what they're doing". I'd think NASA has that covered.