Re:YouTube dominates TV streaming in US, per Nielsen's lates...
by benatkin on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:27AM
(#39463849)
I don't mind the short videos. What I do mind is that they co-opted the word "shorts" which means something else in the context of videos. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/movies/story/2024...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:YouTube dominates TV streaming in US, per Nielsen's lates...
by shiroiushi on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:56AM
(#39465145)
Perhaps not: I think your link is talking about "short movies" or "short films". YouTube's Shorts are "short videos". Movies (films) and videos are not the same thing: movies/films are a type of video, but there are many other types of video that are not movies, most notably TV shows, and also "music videos", but really anything that involves a moving picture. A "movie" (or to some, "film") these days is commonly meant to refer to a specific form of art, meaning a visualized stand-alone story that usually takes 1-4 hours to watch, and frequently gets played in a cinema.
Similarly, a "book" is a collection of bound paper pages, but a "novel" is a specific type of book that contains a story, and is usually a certain length (if it's too short, it's called a "short story").
So I think it's ok for YouTube to call their 60-second videos "shorts", as long as they don't call them "short films" or "short movies".
Re:YouTube dominates TV streaming in US, per Nielsen's lates...
by benatkin on Thursday February 22, 2024 @01:02PM
(#39470745)
The term "shorts" is also part of that and is what YouTube was trying to co-opt. In the link you can clearly see the word "shorts" being used to refer to these. Here's one from 2010: https://thescorecardreview.com/tsr/review/film-reviews/2010/...
Re:YouTube dominates TV streaming in US, per Nielsen's lates...
by Dylan16807 on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:06PM
(#39472370)
That's just context allowing for abbreviation. "Shorts" has always meant different things in different contexts.