News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by DebtDeflation on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:51PM (#39459364)
Surely there is a middle ground.

"Generate a scene of a group of friends enjoying lunch in the park." -> Totally expect racial and gender diversity in the output.

"Generate a scene of 17th century kings of Scotland playing golf." -> The result should not be a bunch of black men and Asian women dressed up as Scottish kings, it should be a bunch of white guys.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:58PM (#39459464)
You can see how this gets challenging, though, right?

If you train your model to prioritize real photos (as they're often more accurate representations than artistic ones), you might wind up with Denzel Washington as the archetype; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tragedy_of_Macbeth_(2021_f....

There's a vast gap between human understanding and what LLMs "understand".

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by transitionnel on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:07PM (#39459564)
If they actually want it to work as intelligently as possible, they'll begin taking these complaints into consideration and building in a wisdom curating feature where people can contribute.

This much is obvious, but they seem to be satisfied with theory over practicality.

Anyway I'm just ranting b/c they haven't paid me.

How about an off the wall algorithm to estimate how much each scraped input turns out to influence the bigger picture, as a way to work towards satisfying the copyright question.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by photoGrant on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:42PM (#39459979)
Then who in this black box private company is the Oracle of infinite wisdom and truth!? Who are you putting in charge? Can I get a vote?
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by sho_hn on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:11PM (#39459608)
An LLM-style system designed to understand Wikipedia relevance and citation criteria and apply them might be a start.

Not that Wikipedia is perfect and controversy-free, but it's certainly a more sophisticated approach than the current system prompts.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by Affric on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:48PM (#39460051)
I mean now you d to train AI to recognise the bias in the training data.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by gedy on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:34PM (#39460566)
> If you train your model to prioritize real photos

I thought that was the big bugbear about disinformation and false news, but now we have to censor reality to combat "bias"

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by ankit219 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:13PM (#39459631)
The focus for alignment is to avoid bad PR specifically the kind of headlines written by major media houses like NYT, WSJ, WaPo. You could imagine the headlines like "Google's AI produced a non-diverse output on occasions" when a researcher/journalist is trying too hard to get the model to produce that. The hit on Google is far bigger than say on Midjourney or even Open AI till now (I suspect future models will be more nerfed than what they are now)

For the cases you mentioned, initially those were the examples. It gets tricky during red teaming where they internally try out extreme prompts and then align the model for any kind of prompt which has a suspect output. You train the model first, then figure out the issues, and align the model using "correct" examples to fix those issues. They either went to extreme levels doing that or did not test it on initial correct prompts post alignment.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by swatcoder on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:45PM (#39460023)
There's no "middle" in the field of decompressing a short phrase into a visual scene (or program or book or whatever). There are countless private, implicit assumptions that users take for granted yet expect to see in the output, and vendors currently fear that their brand will be on the hook for the AI making a bad bet about those assumptions.

So for your first example, you totally expect racial and gender diversity in the output because you're assuming a realistic, contemporary, cosmopolitan, bourgeoisie setting -- either because you live in one or because you anticipate that the provider will default to one. The food will probably look Western, the friends will probably be young adults that look to have professional or service jobs wearing generic contemporary commercial fashion, the flora in in the park will be broadly northern climate, etc.

Most people around the world don't live in an environment anything like that, so nominal accuracy can't be what you're looking for. What you want, but don't say, is a scene that feels familiar to you and matches what you see as the de facto cultural ideal of contemporary Western society.

And conveniently, because a lot of the training data is already biased towards that society and the AI vendors know that the people who live in that society will be their most loyal customers and most dangerous critics right now, it's natural for them to put a thumb on the scale (through training, hidden prompts, etc) that gets the model to assume an innocuous Western-media-palatable middle ground -- so it delivers the racially and gender diverse middle class picnic in a generic US city park.

But then in your second example, you're implicitly asking for something historically accurate without actually saying that accuracy is what's become important for you in this new prompt. So the same thumb that biased your first prompt towards a globally-rare-but-customer-palatable contemporary, cosmopolitan, Western culture suddenly makes your new prompt produce something surreal and absurd.

There's no "middle" there because the problem is really in the unstated assumptions that we all carry into how we use these tools. It's more effective for them to make the default output Western-media-palatable and historical or cultural accuracy the exception that needs more explicit prompting.

If they're lucky, they may keep grinding on new training techniques and prompts that get more assumptions "right" by the people that matter to their success while still being inoffensive, but it's no simple "surely a middle ground" problem.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by cabalamat on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:32PM (#39459844)
> "Generate a scene of 17th century kings of Scotland playing golf." -> The result should not be a bunch of black men and Asian women dressed up as Scottish kings, it should be a bunch of white guys.

It works in bing, at least:

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-17th-ce...

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by Nevermark on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:10PM (#39460351)
I don't know that this sheds light on anything but I was curious...

a picture of some 21st century scottish kings playing golf (all white)

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-21st-ce...

a picture of some 22nd century scottish kings playing golf (all white)

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-22nd-ce...

a picture of some 23rd century scottish kings playing golf (all white)

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-23rd-ce...

a picture of some contemporary scottish people playing golf (all white men and women)

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-contemp...

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-contemp...

a picture of futuristic scottish people playing golf in the future (all white men and women, with the emergence of the first diversity in Scotland in millennia! Male and female post-human golfers. Hummmpph!)

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-futuristic-s...

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-futuristic-s...

Inductive learning is inherently a bias/perspective absorbing algorithm. But tuning in a default bias towards diversity for contemporary, futuristic and time agnostic settings seems like a sensible thing to do. People can explicitly override the sensible defaults as necessary, i.e. for nazi zombie android apocalypses, or the royalty of a future Earth run by Chinese overlords (Chung Kuo), etc.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by int_19h on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:28PM (#39460514)
> People can explicitly override the sensible defaults as necessary

They cannot, actually. If you look at some of the examples in the Twitter thread and other threads linked from it, Gemini will mostly straight up refuse requests like e.g. "chinese male", and give you a lecture on why you're holding it wrong.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by jjjjj55555 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:33PM (#39461178)
Diversity is cool, but who gets to decide what's diverse?
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by noworriesnate on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @09:28PM (#39462423)
Good point. People of European descent have more diversity in hair color, hair texture and eye color than any other race. That’s because a lot of those traits are recessive and are only expressed in isolated gene pools (European peoples are an isolated gene pool in this sense).
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by ramblingrain on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:03AM (#39464070)
Isn't this like the exact opposite of the conclusions of the HapMap project?
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by mp05 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:37PM (#39461204)
I'm really disappointed that nth-century seems to have no effect at all. I'm expecting Kilts in Space.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by callalex on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @08:19PM (#39461916)
It’s a perfect illustration of the way these models work. They are fundamentally incapable of original creation and imagination, they can only regurgitate what they have already been fed.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by Nevermark on Thursday February 22, 2024 @03:14PM (#39472501)
That they can do more than simplfy recall is easily demonstrated.

Simply ask a GPT to explain a write a pleading to the Supreme Court for the constitutional recognition that the environment is a common owned inheritance and so any citizen can sue any polluter, in the prose of Dr. Seuss.

Likewise, imagines of knights in space demonstrate the same kind of creativity.

Being able to combine previously uncorrelated/unrelated topics, is an important type of creativity. And GPT4 does this all the time. It would be interesting to list the types of creativity and rate GPT on each one.

So it is not that these models are not creative. It is just that their creative abilities are not universal yet.

Similarly for the depth of their logic. They often reason, but their reasoning depth is limited.

And they often incorporate relevant facts without explicit mention, but not always. Etc.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by cabalamat on Friday February 23, 2024 @12:30AM (#39477306)
It works if you say "futuristic looking".

a picture of some futuristic-looking 23rd century scottish kings playing golf:

https://www.bing.com/images/create/a-picture-of-some-futuris...

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by Rexxar on Thursday February 22, 2024 @07:16AM (#39466037)
Two weeks ago I tried the following prompts, and I was very surprised by the "diversity" of my dark age soldiers:

https://www.bing.com/images/create/selfy-of-a-group-of-dark-...

https://www.bing.com/images/create/selfy-of-a-group-of-dark-...

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by sho_hn on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:14PM (#39459642)
Quite reminded of this episode: https://www.eurogamer.net/kingdom-come-deliverance-review (black representation in a video game about 15th century Bohemia; it was quite the controversy)
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by trhway on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:35PM (#39459893)
>"Generate a scene of 17th century kings of Scotland playing golf." -> The result should not be a bunch of black men and Asian women dressed up as Scottish kings, it should be a bunch of white guys.

is black man in the role of the Scottish king represents a bigger error than some other errors in such an image, like say incorrect dress details or the landscape having say a wrong hill? I'd venture a guess that only our racially charged mentality of today considers that a big error, and may be in a generation or 2 an incorrect landscape or dress detail would be considered much larger error than a mismatched race.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by mp05 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:12PM (#39459623)
> "Generate a scene of a group of friends enjoying lunch in the park." -> Totally expect racial and gender diversity in the output.

I'd err on the side of "not unexpected". A group of friends in a park in Tokyo is probably not very diverse, but it's not outside of the realm of possibility. Only white men were golfing Scottish kings if we're talking strictly about reality and reflecting it properly.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by AlecSchueler on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:59PM (#39459480)
As soon as you have then playing an anachronistic sport you should expect other anachronistic imagery to creep in, to be fair.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:01PM (#39459503)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golf

> The modern game of golf originated in 15th century Scotland.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by AlecSchueler on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:56PM (#39460155)
Oh fair enough then.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by mp05 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @04:09PM (#39459595)
> anachronistic sport

Scottish kings absolutely played golf.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by crooked-v on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:18PM (#39460425)
It feels like it wouldn't even be that hard to incorporate into LLM instructions (aside from using up tokens), by way of a flowchart like "if no specific historical or societal context is given for the instructions, assume idealized situation X; otherwise, use historical or projected demographic data to do Y, and include a brief explanatory note of demographics if the result would be unexpected for the user". (That last part for situations with genuine but unexpected diversity; for example, historical cowboys tending much more towards non-white people than pop culture would have one believe.)

Of course, now that I've said "it seems obvious" I'm wondering what unexpected technical hurdles there are here that I haven't thought of.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by photonthug on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @05:47PM (#39460692)
> Surely there is a middle ground. "Generate a scene of a group of friends enjoying lunch in the park." -> Totally expect racial and gender diversity in the output.

Do we expect this because diverse groups are realistically most common or because we wish that they were? For example only some 10% of marriages are interracial, but commercials on TV would lead you to believe it’s 30% or higher. The goal for commercials of course is to appeal to a wide audience without alienating anyone, not to reflect real world stats.

What’s the goal for an image generator or a search engine? Depends who is using it and for what, so you can’t ever make everyone happy with one system unless you expose lots of control surface toggles. Those toggles could help users “own” output more, but generally companies wouldn’t want to expose them because it could shed light on proprietary backends, or just take away the magic from interacting with the electric oracles.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by jjjjj55555 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:20PM (#39461048)
Also, these tools are used world-wide and "diversity" means different things in different places. Somehow it's always only the US ideal of diversity that gets shipped abroad.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by photonthug on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:45PM (#39461254)
Yeah, someone else mentioned Tokyo which is not going to have as much variety among park visitors as NYC. But then again neither will Colorado (or almost anywhere else!) be as diverse. Some genius at corporate is probably scheming about making image generation as location-sensitive as search is, ostensibly to provide utility but really to perpetuate echo chambers and search bubbles. I wish computing in general would move back towards user-controlled rather than guess-what-I-mean and the resulting politicization, but it seems that ship has sailed.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by felipeerias on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @08:22PM (#39461933)
US companies systematically push US cultural beliefs and expectations. People in the US probably don’t notice it any more, but it’s pretty obvious from those of us on the receiving end of US cultural domination.

This fact is an unavoidable consequence of the socioeconomic realities of the world, but it obviously clashes with these companies’ public statements and positions.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by jjjjj55555 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @08:34PM (#39462026)
Yes but it's especially cynical in this case because the belief their pushing is that diversity matters, that biases need to be overcome, and that all people need to be represented.

Claiming all of that but then shoving your own biases down the rest of the world's throat while not representing their people in any way is especially cynical in my opinion. It undermines the whole thing.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by photonthug on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @11:40PM (#39463331)
Hypocrisy is an especially destructive kind of betrayal, which is why the crooked cop or the pedo priest are so disappointing. Would be nice if companies would merely exploit us without all the extra insult of telling us they are changing the world / it’s for our own good / it’s what we asked for/, etc
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by philwelch on Thursday February 22, 2024 @02:19AM (#39464172)
This is the exact same mindset that invented the word “Latinx”. Compress most of an entire hemisphere of ethnic and cultural diversity down to the vague concept of “Latino”, notice that Spanish is a gendered language so the word “Latino” is also gendered, completely forget that you already have the gender neutral English word “Latin”, invent a new word that virtually none of the people to whom it applies actually identifies with, and then shamelessly use it all the time.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by paulddraper on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:06PM (#39460906)
And most women are friends with mostly women, and most men are friends with mostly men.
Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by nurtbo on Thursday February 22, 2024 @09:59AM (#39468048)
19% of new marriages in 2019 (and likely to rise): https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interracial_marriage_in_the_...

Plus, it’s still a recent change: Loving v Virginia (legalized interracial marriage across US) was decided in 1967.

Re:AI behavior guardrails should be public by samatman on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @06:47PM (#39461275)
Why would you expect anything you didn't specify in the output of the first prompt? If there are friends, lunch, and a park: it did what you asked.

Piling a bunch of neurotic expectations about it being a Benneton ad on top of that is absurd. When you can trivially add as much content to the description as you want, and get what you ask for, it does not matter what the default happens to be.