News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by tnuc on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:12AM (#3943980)
Given that the US spends over half its budget on "defence" I really don't know where you are getting your ideas from.

Maybe some numbers and a source?

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by tomjen3 on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:35AM (#3944124)
Did you even read what you are replying to?

He wasn't talking about the sum of money, just that it had gone up -- and he wasn't talking about how to finance it, just that it had caused more people to become dependent on assistance _even as more people are getting a job_. Meaning that it is not because there is no jobs.

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by batista on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @01:42PM (#3944883)
>He wasn't talking about the sum of money, just that it had gone up -- and he wasn't talking about how to finance it, just that it had caused more people to become dependent on assistance

Yes, we was talking BS.

It makes one feel very superior and active, to believe that poor people, black, hispanic, etc choose to live on food stamps (as "dependents") ignoring all those fabulous job opportunities available to them.

That self-worth-boost is one of the main reasons people perpetuate this crap. Go talk to actual persons living on food stamps to get a real idea of what it's like and what chances the have to escape it.

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by dlokshin on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:36AM (#3944127)
Perhaps you should be checking your numbers? Defense this year is 24%, which is half of 50%. Welfare + Social Security + Medicare = 54%.

http://cl.ly/1x3D1W3Z2c3Z2G1w400g

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by vsmatck on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:33AM (#3944118)
Half is incorrect. It's about 20%. Still a large amount.

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_federal_budget (look at first graph)

I really don't know where you are getting your ideas from. (you were asking for this :)

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by jbooth on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:37AM (#3944137)
Over half of the discretionary budget, which is the pot of money that things like food stamps come out of (way less than 1%, if anyone's counting).

The entitlement programs are run off of their own separate taxes and are legally "off-budget" compared to discretionary spending. Their budget isn't voted on, it's basically "automatic", coming from the legislation that created them. Same with debt repayment (which, coincidentally, represents defense spending in previous years, neat that it doesn't count that way on your pie chart though).

So that's where he's getting his ideas from. The federal budget that gets voted on by congress every year (in a good year) is over 50% defense, and more like 65% defense if you include Homeland Security, Dept of State, Veteran Affairs, etc in the defense column instead of domestic.

Here's a more useful graphic: http://www.deathandtaxesposter.com/

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by nwj on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:43AM (#3944180)
Don't know where you are getting the idea that half the US budget is spent on defense.

Estimates I've seen range from 20-40% depending on what you count as "defense". See for example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_S...

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by jstalin on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:18AM (#3944017)
Where did I support current or additional defense spending?

Frankly, it's just another welfare scheme. Defense spending is largely a waste.

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by rhizome on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:41AM (#3944161)
Maybe, but it's telling that you didn't mention it at all and instead focussed on blaming people on food stamps.
Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by jstalin on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:49AM (#3944214)
It's telling of what exactly? That I didn't connect defense spending and dependence on handouts? You are reading more into what I'm saying than is there. Check your pre-conceived notions.

And, AGAIN, where do I blame the people on food stamps? The system is the problem, not the people who take advantage of it.

Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by jbooth on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @11:55AM (#3944257)
Food stamps are a drop in the bucket compared to defense spending. If you're just a nonpartisan who's concerned about the budget, rather than a limbaughbeckbot, one would expect you'd be approximately 1,000x as outraged about defense (in numerical terms) as you are about food stamps.
Re:Chomsky - Jobs aren't coming back by rhizome on Tuesday May 08, 2012 @12:18PM (#3944371)
It's telling that you choose to focus on moral issues, such as what you interpret as dependence, rather than the hard-numbers "this is what consumes the most tax dollars for the least benefit" of defense spending.

Of course, "least benefit" is a value judgement, but the system, as you describe it, is actually concerned with maintaining the military and the financial industries much more than any idea of the country having its legs knocked out from under it by poor people. This is a fact, and is supportable by actual numbers, unlike your kicking of people while they're down.