We know the rules they play by thoroughly - we made those ourselves(the math/model structure). But the outputs we are getting in many cases were never explicitly outlined in the rule set. We can follow the prompts step-by-step but quickly end up on seemingly non-nonsensical paths that explode into a web of what appears to be completely unrelated concepts. It could be that our meat brains simply don't have the working memory necessary to track these meta and meta-meta emergent systems at play that arrive at an output.
>“If we open up ChatGPT or a system like it and look inside, you just see millions of numbers flipping around a few hundred times a second,” says AI scientist Sam Bowman. “And we just have no idea what any of it means.”
>To me as an engineer, that is just incredibly unsatisfying. Without understanding how something works, we are doomed to be just users.
AI aren't complicated. They aren't sophisticated math that you can poke at and understand.
They're fucking million dollar spaghetti code that happen to work (for values of 'work').
Those videos are teaching people "This is an if statement! This is a CPU!" And then you can look at 5.8 billion lines of spaghetti code and say "Gee! I understand how this works now! Yay!"
LLMs don't have anywhere near that much code. The algorithms for training and inference are not that complicated; the "intelligent" behavior is entirely due to the weights.
Aside from annoying people who want to understand how things work, it also means you can't ever know if you have a fully optimal or correct solution, all you can do is keep throwing money into the training furnace and hope a better solution falls out next time. The whole nature of it gatekeeps out anyone who doesn't have enormous amounts of money to burn.
Totally agreed that the process of generating and evaluating weights is opaque and not very accessible.
You don't see any meaningful, understandable code. For example, if prompt begins with draw me a picture then jump to layer X.
I'm no expert but I can imagine that to be the problem when one attempts to debug an Algorithmic Intelligence black box.
But your last paragraph resonates with me pretty deeply, and suggests to me that there might be a way forward for me when this becomes unavoidable, which it will.
Frankly I would rather direct my energies away from the accelerating face of dehumanising technologies and towards rehumanising technology through education, but I do recognise I'll eventually have to engage with this just to educate.
I would strongly strongly strongly recommend starting with karpathy's from 0 to hero neural networks youtube course - it starts with building a tensor library and back propagation, explaining it in a way that finally clicked for me https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLAqhIrjkxbuWI23v9cThs...
jeremy howard also has a fantastic video that is more around how to use LLMs and such called a hacker's guide to language models - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jkrNMKz9pWU&t=607s
as i've dove more and more into it, i would strongly recommend trying to run things on your local machine too (llama.cpp, ollama, LM studio). that has helped me fight that feeling of like "are we all just going to be open AI developers in the end" and made me feel like you _can_ integrate these things into stuff you build by your self. I can't imagine how fucked we'd all be if llama was never opensourced. being old does not mean that you can't continue to grow, and remember that it's okay to feel overwhelmed about all this - many people are.