News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:18AM (#39394480)
I recently stopped using Kagi after using them for a long time. For whatever reason, their results became pretty bad compared to before, often almost mirroring Google.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by sph on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:54AM (#39394719)
I am still a user because Google is worse than ever, but I wish Kagi would stop interpreting my queries and randomly decide to ignore or assign a random weights to my words.

If I search for `foo bar baz`, I want pages with `foo`, `bar` and `baz`, please. No, verbatim doesn't cut it because it somehow is far too strict and even common queries return half a dozen results at most. Google started sucking in the 2010s when they decided they know better than me, and the more Kagi improves, the more they follow down Google's path of trying to be outsmart me, and falling short.

I just want a 2003 Google experience. A computer is not smarter than me, stop trying to interpret and make assumptions.

---

Aside, is it so hard to make a search engine with a query interface like any trigram-based SQL full-text engine? With quotes, AND, OR and -word. I still believe any AI-powered solution of the past 20 years to be a mockery of this gold standard of precision and simplicity, except maybe Google 1.0.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by __alexs on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:23AM (#39395248)
> I just want a 2003 Google experience.

Google in 2003 was good because the web wasn't quite so full of utter garbage. There must be 100x more content at least now.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by eitland on Friday February 16, 2024 @06:50AM (#39395727)
Everyone says this.

But Kagi often being as good as Google used to be proves this isn't the only reason.

Lately I have felt Kagi also sometimes stray down this "knows better than me what I want" path.

I recommend using the forums to let them know. They actually read the forums and act on it.

I've reported both ux improvements and search quality issues and more and they have always taken it seriously.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by dspillett on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:47AM (#39395364)
That is only going to get worse, with the direct copies of StackOverflow and other popular sites (which are easy enough for search engines to filter out because the body content is practically identical) that exist only to fool less careful clickers into getting their adverts & such, being joined by a multitude of LLM generated rewordings of the same which will be harder to automatically drop (or de-prioritise).
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:12AM (#39398922)
I’ve used browser addons to help with filtering the search spam too. I think uBlacklist? It has lists of sites that are often helpful
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by al_borland on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:47AM (#39394685)
I haven’t had an issue. I recently started getting GPT results, in addition to the normal search results, and they have been very helpful for quick answers to questions.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by Sakos on Friday February 16, 2024 @04:22AM (#39394903)
Haven't experienced any decline in search quality. Been using them for over a year now.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by mdekkers on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:57AM (#39394731)
Can you be more specific? I exclusively use Kagi, and I am a heavy search user. I have not noticed anything like what you are mentioning.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:07AM (#39398832)
I noticed that search queries required more thought and perusal to get desired results than normal. Kagi previously would give good enough results that I could figure it out without having to think about Kagi itself. More recently I noticed that I wasn’t able to find answers like this anymore, and compared the query to Google. The results were pretty much identical. I kept using Kagi for another month but it persisted so I stopped my sub. I was an early adopted with Kagi and initially was very happy.

Since Kagi became Google for my purposes, I started using Google again. I don’t have much motivation to curate the customization features personally.

I would imagine that it could depend on the general type of query. As a developer I definitely noticed a decline in quality.

I’m quite privacy focused but for whatever reason don’t care if Google knows that I want to know how to write a helm chart or eat pasta later

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by freediver on Friday February 16, 2024 @01:12PM (#39400789)
Can you report examples to kagifeedback.org so that we can take a look?
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by mrmlz on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:21AM (#39394503)
Damnit I was on the narrow path of convincing myself to start paying for Kagi. I've been using QWANT but the search results are a bit off tbh. And they've started doing full-screen ads to turn of my adblock (which well to be fair thats the way they earn their keep).
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by Sebb767 on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:41AM (#39394645)
For what it's worth, whenever I've switched to DuckDuckGo, I've found myself adding a !g to nearly every search. Since I've switched to Kagi a few months ago, I've hardly ever had to go to another search engine. If you can spare it, I'd suggest you invest the 5$ for a small account and just test it out for a month.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by Erratic6576 on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:25AM (#39394525)
For me, it’s not only the price you pay. Having a username attached to each your searches is the opposite of privacy, no matter how much you trust their legalese wording
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by tensor on Friday February 16, 2024 @04:27AM (#39394930)
99% of people are probably signed into a google account when they search google. If you want the sort of privacy you seem to want, stick to the dark web and similarly inconvenient tools.

To maintain your level of privacy requires a drastically different lifestyle than most of us have or want.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by daveoc64 on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:18AM (#39396578)
A fresh incognito window on any other search engine isn't going to be linked to an account.

That is for me one of the downsides of Kagi.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by Sebb767 on Friday February 16, 2024 @08:55AM (#39397030)
You can easily set your search engine in private windows to DuckDuckGo, MetaGer or whatever you prefer.

Also, you probably are aware of this, but an incognito window won't magically stop trackers.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by ziddoap on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:58AM (#39397875)
>To maintain your level of privacy

They didn't state anything about their desired level of privacy other than not wanting a username attached to every search. That's not equivalent to needing to use TOR for every search.

>99% of people are probably signed into a google account when they search google

What is the relevance of this statement? Obviously this wouldn't apply to the parent poster, it doesn't refute anything the parent said, and at least anecdotally it's not true at all.

>If you want the sort of privacy you seem to want, stick to the dark web and similarly inconvenient tools.

Privacy is a spectrum, not some binary choice between having a username (and often real name) attached to every search vs. using the dark web for every search. You can land somewhere in the middle, for example: "I don't want a username attached to every search".

There is no technical reason Kagi needs usernames, but they choose to require them. For some people, that points to the company not being as privacy-friendly as other people seem to think/claim.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by Erratic6576 on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:34AM (#39398384)
I dont browse signed in to my Google account, which I barely use. But Google has an open account on each of us, even if we block their servers at the firewall level
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by viraptor on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:32AM (#39394581)
I go the opposite way. I trust a company that takes my money to pay its costs to keep my privacy. As opposed to a company who "doesn't know who I am". (Apart from unique fingerprint https://amiunique.org/ over many queries over many months)
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by spiderice on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:28AM (#39399176)
I thought modern browsers were supposed to resist finger printing? This website is slightly horrifying.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by kristofferR on Friday February 16, 2024 @05:16PM (#39403688)
You thought wrong, fingerprinting is impossible to resist.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by viraptor on Friday February 16, 2024 @09:30PM (#39405764)
They try to. But every time a browser gets better at existing methods, it also gains new features which become new methods of identification. The web browser environment is broken. And if you get to fight it by using something with better protection, you're only exposing yourself more because no other users do the same thing.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by hackideiomat on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:34AM (#39394606)
Go look at MetaGer, they solved that issue
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by mrmlz on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:31AM (#39394574)
Oh well I don't assume I'm in anyway "anonymous" no matter if I got a username/ipadress/cookie/deep-state-monitoring attached to my searches. Things I html-POST to the web is no longer private.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by Erratic6576 on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:11AM (#39398899)
That’s another reason not to pay for privacy
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by smcleod on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:32AM (#39394580)
I haven’t notice any degradation in quality with Kagi, haven’t heard of it being a problem either?
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by viraptor on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:25AM (#39394531)
Check it out for your use case. (Have you used up the free searches?) I've not noticed any degradation for my searches. It's going to be different for everyone.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by mrmlz on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:34AM (#39394607)
I used them when they first announced their service. Was a nice experience afaik. QWANT is more like internet on hard-mode.. They don't really give you what you're looking for but close enough.. But I've become more dissatisfied with the results of late.

I'll mull the decision for a while but I'm probably going to give Kagi another try.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:10AM (#39398877)
It could very well be different for everyone. Maybe I’m a generic bastard and Kagi doesn’t think I’m very interesting, so my results are also generic.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:08AM (#39398856)
It’s worth giving a try. You get a good amount of free queries to evaluate the product first.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by mrweasel on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:29AM (#39398319)
Kagi is partly powered by Google, so I can imagine specific searches resulting in results pretty similar to Googles, if none of their other source have any matches.

I noticed something similar with Ecosia, they apparently switched to using both Bing and Google, and the results, while still pretty good seems a little worse. That's all anecdotal and may be completely random, but I think one issue could be that Google is getting worse.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:02AM (#39398771)
I tried a few searches side-by-side and they were pretty much identical. I get that Kagi offers customization etc but that’s not worth the money for me personally. I just went back to Google because the results were the same.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by SyneRyder on Friday February 16, 2024 @10:55AM (#39398647)
I'm still using & paying for Kagi, but I have noticed a sudden drop in search results quality in the last month or two. Unfortunately I didn't take note of the specific searches, but I jumped over to Brave Search and everything I was looking for was right on the top, instead of down around page 2 of Kagi.

There's more blatantly obvious spam results seeping into Kagi as well, though at least I can block those domains when I come across them. A few of them were hacked websites, notably government websites in South Asia that had been thoroughly compromised.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by nusl on Friday February 16, 2024 @11:03AM (#39398781)
Okay. Seems our experiences are similar. The timeline is roughly within the last two months that I noticed the same.
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by freediver on Friday February 16, 2024 @01:11PM (#39400783)
That would be unusual. Did you turn on verbatim search option in kagi and forgot to turn it off?
Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by SyneRyder on Friday February 16, 2024 @03:35PM (#39402602)
Nope, I don't think so? I'm going through my settings now, and I have Safe Search and Image Safe Search both enabled. Which makes it even more surprising that it was returning hacked government sites mentioning porn in the search snippet.

(Just found what you meant by Verbatim search - nope, I would have always had Personalized turned on instead. Seeing those results would be the first time I even encountered those domains, so I didn't know to block the domain until then. Since the domain is still in my blocklist, I can confirm it was a government website in Mumbai. I don't have any reason to be visiting Indian government sites.)

I'm not saying every Kagi search is infected with hacked results, it's only common at times when I'm really researching something and need to get to a second page of results.

I also note that some Warez sites rank highly in Kagi too. Knowing that Kagi's customer base is largely from HN, that's less surprising to me, and I'm thankful that I can block those domains from my own personal results.

Re:Kagi Changelog 2/13: Faster and more accurate instant ans... by elxx on Friday February 16, 2024 @04:52PM (#39403463)
Did you start to notice things getting worse around the new year when they added Brave to their search results? That was the turning point for me, I was a huge advocate but then quality went downhill and then a few weeks later they proudly announced that they had spent a third of their funding on...t-shirts. Between that and this huge push towards being just like Google and Bing with LLM hallucinated nonsense, I'm not sure what their aim is anymore.