Not all the facts provided, just a one sided view that is parroted repeatedly in online forums with the intention of claiming a moral high ground when the facts are far more complex and intricate.
Exactly.
2. Ethno-nationalist state: what ethnicity are we talking about here? BJP loses often in elections locally, and majority of their opponents are Hindus.
What India has always been is illiberal. You are weakening your point by exaggerating the current conditions.
Moreover this prosed ban is because we have an overzealous bureaucracy that doesn’t understand technology and does not care to. It’s got nothing to do with what India has become.
Indian administrations have always have had an authoritarian bent regardless of who has been in power.
2. The previously mentioned 2002 Gujarat pogrom[5], come to mind, supported by complacent ministers such as the now Prime Minister Modi, who was banned from the USA and several other nations due to his role in the incident (until recently)[6]. The Prime Minister and his party have been silent on ensuing regional ethnic conflict that has killed more than 200 people thus far.[7] The term 'Bulldozer Justice' was coined from the practice of BJP ruled states demolishing Muslim people's homes using bulldozer machines with public support, under the pretext of "illegal constructions" [8]
The BJP party is the political wing of the Hindutva outfit RSS (whose claim to fame is one of their members having assassinated Mahatma Gandhi. [9]) Throughout the decade of their governance, they, their regional sub-parties and their corporate partners have systematically enacted policies of aforementioned media suppression, public communications suppression in the face of mass protest/mobilization[10][11], arbitrary arrest of protesters under British colonial era sedition laws without bail[12][13] mass internet traffic surveillance via Deep Packet Inspection[14]. They have suspended around 150 opposition MPs as of a few months ago[15].
All the above which I've listed are bad enough but there are many more skeletons in the proverbial closet which I don't have the energy to recall and cite at the moment. None of the above points to India as being a free and secular nation. To engage in semantic handwaving is a frankly pathetic attempt of apologism. I wish I had more time to elaborate but I'm horrified that I even need to.
[1] https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/govt-orders-magazine-... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2023/01/25/india-bbc-na... [3] https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/it-raids-at-premises-... [4] https://www.newslaundry.com/2023/05/05/at-least-44-times-ove... [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2002_Gujarat_riots [6] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/oct/22/uk-ends-boycot... [7] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-natio... [8] https://time.com/6303571/how-bulldozers-became-a-symbol-of-a... [9] https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/pm-modi-continues-to-... [10] https://www.deccanherald.com/india/haryana/farmers-protest-m... [11] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/sep/25/a-tool-of-poli... [12] https://www.livelaw.in/articles/father-stan-swamy-uapa-marty... [13] https://main.sci.gov.in/supremecourt/2023/29067/29067_2023_1... [14] https://cis-india.org/internet-governance/blog/reliance-jio-... [15] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-natio...
Please respect hacker news guidelines https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
* Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That tramples curiosity.*
If your only argument is about a so called "western bias", forgive me for laughing. I'm under no obligation to kowtow to the delusions of an authoritarian country and it's supporters.
Thankfully, religion as a whole is becoming increasingly irrelevant among new generations as Western individualism takes over. This incident will hopefully be remembered just as an appeasement tactic for old to middle-aged people and not an escalation.
Many would say that doesn't change anything because they think that Indian supreme court is just another tool in the hand of Modi's government [1] [2] [3].
[1] https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2023/12/27/i...
[2] https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2024/02/wh...
[3] https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/india-s-justice-system-...
Whether or not Modi's government has undue influence over the judiciary is still up for debate, but in this particular case, I fail to see how it could have made a difference either way.
Give a judgenent that offends least number of people, be it right or wrong.
You know how that sounds like? A corrupt judiciary that's at the whims of satisfying the ego of masses.
Btw
>The incident, which resulted in heavy casualties, had shaken the entire nation and the collective conscience of the society will only be satisfied if the capital punishment is awarded to the offender.
This quote from an actual judgment made by supreme court of India literally says so. To satisfy collective consciousness of masses, a man must die
Part of the factors they have to consider is for the people to be sufficiently satisfied that justice was done. After all, the system relies on the people having confidence that the system works. The perpetrator of a brutal rape and murder not being given the death penalty when the entire country is out on the streets demanding his blood, would be a grave miscarriage of justice (as long as he was indeed the perpetrator).
Especially with the case of the masjid, there wasn't going to be a right answer either way, as Hindus also made a historical claim to the land.
Arguably the most diverse country in the world is an ethno-national state?
I don't understand, some people here just really have a beef with India/Hindus.
You realize you're talking about a community which has essentially been subject to apartheid-like conditions by these "minorities" during each of the periods of what, if you see the primary sources, sounds absolutely horrible. Literally like living through a slow-holocaust for centuries!
Academics cover it up for PC-ness, but you could say the same thing about the Jewish suffering. Worse, there are academics/politicians actively calling for Hindu-genocide (calls "Brahmin-genocide" is far more common) to this day.
Even the so-called secularism only "secularizes" the deep and visceral hate India's ruling elite have for her past. Indeed, the legal status of Hindus in India, given Art 25-30, and numerous legal precedents mean that they can't even manage or run their own temples, nor even to decide the language of prayer[1], or often even the 'mathas' that carry forward the dozens of traditions.
The sad part is that Hindus in the Modi-age have begun to trust a state that is so deeply and viciously colonial that any unbiased observer will see that its only real goal is the destruction of India's civilizational continuity.
Little wonder, it ensures that Hindu-culture is stomped out, not just by destroying temples, but also by making damn sure that only those who speak English (< 5%) get access to higher education. Obviously, a counter elite is bad for a colonial state.
You represent this thought-stream of people who've tried to wipe us off the face of the earth for a 1000y, and are still at the task. Chips are down; but we're still here bud.
[1]. The Indian state has decided that the "language of prayer" is a "secular" affair which ergo apparently gives rando state-babus the power to dictate what it should be in. Or what priest can be appointed to maintain what tradition.
Lol
Plus, India has a long record of kneejerk censorship. There was the incident with GitHub back in 2014, and even before then there have been many cases of the national or state governments censoring material that could be construed as criticizing them or material they could construe as supporting a terrorist movement.
I grew up in India when it was a relatively secular state. For example, when the Babri Masjid (mosque) was destroyed by Hindus in the early 90s, the national magazine, India Today and major newspapers led with the headline, "India's Shame" and acknowledge how bad that was for Indian secularism.
Less than a month ago the same mosque was now converted into a Hindu temple and the press and government led the cheerleading.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/1/22/why-is-indias-ram-t...