News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by happytiger on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:31PM (#39379131)
This is hugely important. What’s happened here is the first time I’ve seen a major corporation do this and the law was only changed to allow it to happen in 2022. Does this mean Delaware corporations are going to move in larger numbers? This could extract a lot of companies into other states and cause a real big split among corporations and their tax bases. It could cause states to start competing for this incorporation too.
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by huytersd on Thursday February 15, 2024 @12:42AM (#39379523)
States incorporate in Delaware for a reason. Isn’t Elon’s move just because his pay ask was rejected in Delaware? It wasn’t a move based on fundamentals. I don’t see why other companies would do this.
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by dreamcompiler on Thursday February 15, 2024 @01:02AM (#39379615)
His Tesla pay ask was rejected. He wants to move Tesla too but that's going to be much tougher: Tesla is a public company and some of its shareholders will probably object and sue. SpaceX is a private company with many fewer investors who are presumed to be sophisticated, so they can pretty much do whatever they want with very little oversight.

Moving Tesla will be much harder.

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by DoesntMatter22 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @05:38AM (#39381101)
It's not really going to be much harder. They are going to put it to a vote at the annual meeting and if the vote passes then they will move it.
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by f0e4c2f7 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @06:46AM (#39381573)
For context, Elon's comp was also put to a vote in an annual meeting, passed, a minor shareholder (9 shares) filed a lawsuit and here we are.

In the case of Tesla in Delaware at least, the court did not optimize for shareholders wishes. This is what has Elon wanting to move out of Delaware as much as the comp.

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by cma on Thursday February 15, 2024 @06:03AM (#39381299)
I wonder if Elon recused himself from the shareholder vote to move SpaceX since it was from personal stuff affecting him at another company?
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by grecy on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:35AM (#39383163)
> His Tesla pay ask was rejected

It wasn’t an ask. It was a payout agreed to by the board and shareholders if and only if he added a trillion dollars of value to the company. He did that, and now a court denied the deal.

If my company signed a deal where I would get an astronomical bonus for pulling off the impossible then reneged when I did it I would be pretty pissed.

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by TheCoelacanth on Thursday February 15, 2024 @02:16PM (#39387112)
That's why you don't negotiate your pay package "against" someone who was also your personal lawyer. If it wasn't for massive conflicts of interest in the process of him getting that deal, it never would have been overturned.
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 15, 2024 @12:45AM (#39379538)
Companies and investors want stability and consistency. Elon moved SpaceX because he's upset about accountability and governance of corporate structures. It likely won't impact investment from "friends and family" or other individuals who don't mind the volatility for the potential returns and lack of liquidity if private Elon companies stay private to avoid said governance and accountability, but Fidelity might think twice at the next raise.

Matt Levin's take is top notch as always: https://archive.today/XMmoF

> Of course, this is the reason to incorporate in Delaware: Someone is keeping an eye on managers and boards of directors to make sure that they’re running the company in the best interests of all of the shareholders, not just those of the idiosyncratic controlling founders. You can raise capital from investors more easily, because the investors trust that there are rules to protect them, that they are not subject to the whims of self-interested entrepreneurs.

> And yet there is something awkward about a judge second-guessing the CEO compensation decisions of the board of directors of a $600 billion company, even if, yes, it’s the board of Tesla. Musk wanted this pay package, Tesla’s board thought it was a good idea to give it to him, and a majority of Tesla’s shareholders voted to approve it. And then Musk did in fact create a trillion dollars of shareholder value, earning his big pay package and making the shareholders happy. Most of them. But one complained, and that’s enough for a judge to reverse the board’s decision.

> This is not a Delaware thing, really, though it is possible that business courts in Texas or wherever might be more sympathetic to CEOs generally, or to Musk specifically. (Bloomberg reports that “Musk also asked X devotees Tuesday to vote on whether he should shift Tesla’s incorporation papers to Texas,” sure.) It is a public company thing: If you run a public company, not only do you have corporate-law fiduciary duties to your shareholders, but you also have genuinely outside shareholders, index funds and activists and gadflies and anyone else who wants to buy stock. If you run a private company, even one incorporated in Delaware (as, for instance, SpaceX is), you can have a lot of control over who your shareholders are, and you can run the company the way they want, which is usually also the way you want. If you run a public company, you have no control over who gets to be a shareholder, or what they can complain about, or what a court will make of their complaints.

> You know what’s really awkward? A few weeks ago, even as this decision was pending, Musk was out publicly demanding another giant stock grant from Tesla’s board. The threat that was implicit in the 2018 pay deal — if the board didn’t shower Musk with options, he’d take his attention to SpaceX or elsewhere — is explicit today; Musk posted that he’s “uncomfortable growing Tesla to be a leader in AI & robotics without having ~25% voting control,” and that “unless that is the case, I would prefer to build products outside of Tesla.”

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by ralfd on Thursday February 15, 2024 @03:56AM (#39380506)
Levine also explained that Delaware is such a popular place for companies because the law there is predictable and there is a (non-jury) fast track for company disputes. Losing $50 billion in a court case is not predictable. But moving to a politically friendly (republican) state likely could be?

https://archive.is/LsUy9#selection-5105.0-5109.27

> Still, I mean, the bet here for Elon Musk is reasonable: If he moves Tesla to Texas, and then demands that Tesla’s board pay him $100 billion to keep a reasonable fraction of his time and attention on Tesla, and Tesla’s extremely accommodating board says “sure whatever you want,” and a majority of shareholders approve the pay package, and one disgruntled shareholder sues, and the case goes to Texas business court, and the complaining shareholder comes into court citing conflicts of interest and the board’s lack of independence and the Delaware cases on “entire fairness,” and Elon Musk comes into court saying “well that may all be true but what you are missing is that I am Elon Musk,” and Texas Governor Greg Abbott is in the first row of spectators with a big sign saying “TX <3 U ELON,” is the Texas business court, in its first real high-profile case, going to say “actually it’s illegal to pay Elon Musk that much”? It absolutely is not. That much is pretty predictable.

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by viraptor on Thursday February 15, 2024 @05:48AM (#39381187)
> Losing $50 billion in a court case is not predictable.

Having your $50 billion payment case heard is not predictable. This whole situation is so unique, I'm not sure anything here generalises past Elon and Bezos.

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by cma on Thursday February 15, 2024 @06:04AM (#39381310)
> Losing $50 billion in a court case is not predictable.

Shareholders, a different group of whom are supposed to be benefited by this new move, gained $50 billion in the court case. About 10% of the value of the company. Even Musk, in his role as shareholder, not employee, benefited with a massive win.

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by ralfd on Thursday February 22, 2024 @04:33AM (#39465001)
In the Reuters report of the ruling:

"Shares of Tesla dropped about 2% in premarket trade"

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by happytiger on Thursday February 15, 2024 @04:22AM (#39380648)
That was a great read. Thank you.
Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday February 15, 2024 @07:33AM (#39381915)
> And then Musk did in fact create a trillion dollars of shareholder value, earning his big pay package and making the shareholders happy.

Apart from the usual CEO worship, isn't the fact of the case that the rewards were assigned for targets that internally were already assumed to be met?

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by s1artibartfast on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:58AM (#39393696)
no, It was a mutlti tier bonus. The very lowest had a high chance, and the highest were understood to be very unlikely.

That said, the case didnt turn on the question if they were likely. It was based on: 1) incomplete disclosure that the compensation team may have conflicts of interests, which opens the door for arguments that the comp wasnt fair, and then 2) an argument that it wasnt a fair deal because 50B provided no extra motivation because Musk already had enough stock to motivate performance

Re:SpaceX has moved its state of incorporation from Delaware... by tzs on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:48AM (#39384130)
The law in question was one that required unanimous shareholder approval for moves. Now it just requires majority approval.

I can find plenty of articles talking about the repeal of that law in 2022, but I haven't found one that tells me when it was enacted. Does anyone happen to know?

In 1993 Microsoft moved from Delaware to Washington. Microsoft went public in 1986 and so I'm having a hard time imagining that they could have gotten unanimous shareholder approval for anything in 1993 and so infer that the unanimous requirement law came sometime after that.