News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by billiam on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @06:56PM (#39377278)
For all you founders and YC aspirants who build companies to get rich as quickly as possible: think of what this man achieved and the lives that have been changed by creating something built to last. By not extracting maximum labor from employees and maximum cash for yourselves but by recognizing you matter less than you think to your company's success and your employees matter more. I buy Bob's Red Mills flour a few times a year and probably will for the rest of my life. TextPayMe, Loopt, Infogami, Memamp, Simmery- do we even remember what those first YC companies tried to do? Think about making things people will remember in a decade, or even 4.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cj on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @07:01PM (#39377324)
Longevity is one of many benchmarks of success, and definitely not the only.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by advael on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:22PM (#39378007)
Indeed, we can choose any metric we like really, as evidenced by the current reality where most people can't afford a house but we still claim that "the economy" is "doing well"
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by smegger001 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:38PM (#39378106)
Doing well relative to the previous financial period. Well compared to my parents generation or their parents generation not so much. better than my greatgrandparents generation though as the great depression makes now look like utopia. It all a matter of what your scale for comparison is.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by advael on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:58PM (#39378230)
Again, the answer you get out of the exercise of delineating "financial periods" depends a lot on how you choose to define them. I'd say for example that good candidates for "previous financial periods" could be pre-covid, pre-2008, pre-dotcom, pre-neoliberalism, or pre-ww2. Some political commentators may prefer to use presidential administration changeovers to make their various points. Since you mention it, it's worth noting that economic conditions immediately preceding the great depression have some key similarities to some of the problems we're having now (a lot of investor fuckery, monopolies, and just outright scams, a lot of adults in a condition of economic precarity, rising global geopolitical instability, etc) though obviously there are also differences.

There are many quality-of-life metrics we could choose too. For example, if you value going out on the town, the decline of so-called "third places" may be a major drop in quality of life, and if you value watching TV, the proliferation of streaming services could be the best thing that's ever happened

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by PeterisP on Thursday February 15, 2024 @03:40AM (#39380409)
People can afford "more house" than ever - if we look at things like square foot of housing per capita, then people in USA currently can afford almost twice as much housing space as 50 years ago in 1970s.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by advael on Thursday February 15, 2024 @12:46PM (#39385761)
Yes, this is another great demonstration of how we can tell any story we want with choice of metric. I'm referring to the binary variable of home ownership, whereas your measure probably either excludes non-homeowners entirely, is only referring to the total amount of extant housing with no reference to who owns it, or counts renters the same as homeowners, painting a very different picture.

For example, I would rather live in a country where every adult can afford 1000 sqft than one where just Jeff Bezos can afford 300000000000000000 sqft and no one else can afford any (neither of these are the current world, obviously), but the latter does better on mean square-footage affordance

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by PeterisP on Thursday February 15, 2024 @01:49PM (#39386696)
I'd argue is that the key aspect of housing is how much living space do people actually get to use, as that is the thing which impacts their quality of life and lifestyle; the second slightly less important aspect is how much people are paying for that (e.g. share of income left for other things), but after those two things are accounted for, the aspect of rent vs mortgage is more of a technical nuance of how that "barter of work hours for living space" is arranged.

Of course, the mean does ignore equality and variance - but while it's hard for me to find good statistics on that (perhaps census data has that analysis?), I'm quite convinced that if we'd look at the metrics of "mean square foot per capita for the x-th income quintile", we would also see that it has significantly increased since 1970s for the lowest income groups as well.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by advael on Thursday February 15, 2024 @01:58PM (#39386837)
In practice the so-called "technical nuance" has huge impacts on what spaces can be used for and what guarantees can be made about the permanence of these arrangements. These factors matter considerably more to most people than the marginal value of a few hundred square feet
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by TrueGrits101 on Friday February 16, 2024 @02:11AM (#39394124)
I have read most of these comments and found them useless. By way of background, I have lived in 16 towns, five states and two countries. Early in the Russian-Ukraine war, I watched a video about housing in rural Ukraine. It was a learning experience. If you draw a rectangle horizontally on a piece of paper, you have the basic first floor. Draw another horizontal line down a bit from the top line and about 60% of the horizontal distance. This is the kitchen counter. Above it are open shelves for dishes, pots and pans etc. In the space left of the counter was a large cabinet for storing food stuff. Coming down the left wall were coat hooks a shelf for hats and a bench for sitting on and storing boots underneath. In the middle of the room was a Stamtisch or as my family described it - a Trible table - just a plank table and in our case it could seat 20 people. In the Ukraine what I saw were benches, not chairs. At the right most part of the room was THE bathroom and space for a washing machine and dryer. In the main part of the room behind one row of benches w on a cushioned surface was a cleverly built place to sit - but not exactly. The seat slid forward toward the Stammtisch and the back would come with it - anchored at several positions by a pin. Come night and the whole thing slid forward to form a bed for four people with two at one end and two at the other end. Beneath this room (which had a 6" concrete floor) was the storage room. And below that room was the root cellar where perishables like potatoes, eggs, fruit, and sausage hanging from the ceiling and urns for pickles and sauerkraut or other foodstuff that could be preserved in brine. This room also served as a bomb shelter. There was a very large cookstove on the main floor with closable gates in the ceiling to the attic. The children slept there and the space was accessed by a metal staircase. From the videographer's work you could hear the laughter. The heat was provided (on the first floor) by what I have seen in the Northeast Kingdom of Vermont was a Russian stove fed by any manner of fuels. They still make these stoves in the US and Finland. They are very efficient. The walls of these houses that I saw, after the bombing in Ukraine were of brick and mortar with the outside/inside plastered and for the most part roofs gone but much of the walls and horizontal surfaces heavily damaged but still standing.

I oft think about what my ancestors lived in when they arrived on these shores in the first quarter of the 16th century. I don't think they were unhappy. The house I grew up in, when we moved in, had gas lighting, a coal fired furnace, cooking stove and huge (to me) a coal fired round tub of some 48" for washing clothes. The five of us children washed dishes and removed the ash from the furnace, stove and wash tub. The house had a 48" thick stone foundation tapering to 18" at the second floor. In subsequent years, owners have made some nice changes. But kept the original design of the house.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by yxwvut on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:05PM (#39378277)
I think the broader point is that improving societal utility is rarely the north star of a startup, not that every business needs to last a century.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by nimbius on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:51PM (#39378188)
In the defense of YC by modern neoliberalist definition bob was a terrible businessman. The company's only worth 50 million, he ran up debts so large it required a partner to bail him out, the company never went public or sold to large agricultural interests to maximize shareholder value, and he committed the cardinal sin of making the employees owners instead of fully capturing the excess capital of his means of production and offshoring production entirely to focus on branding. he focused on an unprofitable cadre of niche markets.

Bob was a great guy though and a sterling example of a leader who really cared about his product and his customers.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by dotBen on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:10PM (#39379017)
"to maximize shareholder value"

You know, philosophically speaking, not every company has to do that. And before someone steps in and quotes 'fiduciary responsibility for shareholder returns', I'm a VC and I run a VC fund so I'm acutely aware.

Now, if you take venture funding then that's a different story. But there are countless businesses - from small mom+pop to larger ones like Bob's Red Mills - which are operating for higher purposes than just shareholder returns. See B Corps generally. And the world is better place for it. I tuck into a bowl of Bob's oatmeal every morning and I'll be fucked if I'm buying Great Mills or PepsiCo (Quaker Oats) big company shit.

"he committed the cardinal sin of making the employees owners instead of fully capturing the excess capital of his means of production and offshoring production entirely to focus on branding"

Many would say this was anything but a cardinal sin. Try reading fewer Ayn Rand books.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cultofmetatron on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:49PM (#39379231)
> Try reading fewer Ayn Rand books.

in ops's defense, he's specifically stating that his statement is from a neoliberal classical view. which would be entirely accurate. It not necessarily HIS personal opinion.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by dotBen on Thursday February 15, 2024 @12:47AM (#39379556)
I guess I could read you a statement from Mein Kampf if you want. Not necessarily MY opinion... and it certainly wouldn't be.

But my point is, why would I do that? In both of these examples I can only assume one writes out an opinion because it's close to the one they hold themselves. I don't go around advocating opinions I don't actually hold myself.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cultofmetatron on Thursday February 15, 2024 @01:23AM (#39379705)
> I guess I could read you a statement from Mein Kampf if you want. Not necessarily MY opinion... and it certainly wouldn't be.

with all due respect, being able to take a assertion or make a reasoned argument within the context of a logical framework outside your personal beliefs is a prerequisite to be a judge or lawyer or engineer.

beyond mere "devils argument", it is valuable to be able to evaluate an idea in its context. one could argue for all sorts of things from the context of Mein Kampf and not personally believe it. it could be used a rhetorical device for framing a narrative in a way that lets others view it objectively.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by palmfacehn on Thursday February 15, 2024 @04:56AM (#39380842)
>being able to take a assertion or make a reasoned argument within the context of a logical framework outside your personal beliefs is a prerequisite to be a judge or lawyer or engineer.

Add analyzing the incentives and actions of 3rd parties generally. An important skill all-around.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by catchnear4321 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @03:10AM (#39380255)
> I guess I could read you a statement from Mein Kampf if you want. Not necessarily MY opinion... and it certainly wouldn't be.

the difference is that you use it knowingly as a threat, and have seemingly decided that anything you deem threatening must have been done on purpose to hurt you.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by shiroiushi on Thursday February 15, 2024 @05:08AM (#39380931)
>But my point is, why would I do that?

Simple. You wouldn't read a statement from Mein Kampf, because no one in their right mind except for some neo-Nazis believes that trash. However, if you lived in a society full of and run by neo-Nazis, then yes, it would be entirely relevant to read a statement from that book even if you don't personally believe it.

In our case, our society really is full of and run by neoliberal classical believers, so it makes perfect sense to state that point of view, and then counter at the end. And it's not just modern society; I'd say that HN, in particular, has even more believers in that kind of philosophy than mainstream society (where it's mainly the people at the top who believe and practice it).

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by pcthrowaway on Thursday February 15, 2024 @03:07AM (#39380234)
It was pretty clear to me that the above poster was "defending YC" by explaining that YC is doing the right thing for their value system; Bob's Red Mill instead pushed against the capitalist narrative rather than seek to maximize profits and grow at all costs.

I think the implicit suggestion which you seem to have missed, in referring to valuing humans above profits as "the cardinal sin", is that it's only a sin from within this framework, which is usually at odds with the opposing framework which values human welfare above company health.

Perhaps my own bias is showing, but this specific application of irony (making light of the harms of capitalism by singing its praises while using highly sensationalized rhetoric) is something I do as well.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by palmfacehn on Thursday February 15, 2024 @03:55AM (#39380496)
Not a fan of Ayn Rand, but it is a bit tiresome to see her name dropped to illustrate a caricature.

Value is subjective. Bob valued employee ownership. He realized profits within his own value framework. Nothing here violates the principles of private property or voluntary association. If anything, Bob's success is a testament to the validity of the core libertarian premises.

Perhaps careful reading of opposing viewpoints is the solution here?

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by lo_zamoyski on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:04AM (#39383491)
Value is not subjective. It is objective. A foodstuff is valuable as nourishment, because it has the objective potential to nourish a human person. The value of a strawberry may not be accessible to someone with a strawberry allergy, but it maintains that value.

Where the organization of labor and ownership are concerned, there may very well exist various legitimate ways to do so, conditioned by circumstance and constrained by basic objective moral principles (like justice). The value such arrangements provide to various parties may differ.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by gottorf on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:15AM (#39383647)
> The value of a strawberry may not be accessible to someone with a strawberry allergy, but it maintains that value.

> Value is not subjective. It is objective.

I'm having trouble reconciling these two statements. The value of a strawberry not being "accessible" may as well not be there for that person who is allergic to strawberries, and in that way it is subjective. One person may prefer to drink beer over wine and another vice versa; it would be strange to claim that beer and wine are objectively equally valuable to both of those people.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by vlowther on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:55AM (#39384221)
Charge, mass, velocity, and spin are objective. Value exists only in the eye of the beholder.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by mingyeow on Thursday February 15, 2024 @04:14AM (#39380604)
Dude, he’s being sarcastic
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by UniverseHacker on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:09AM (#39382876)
In all of Ayn Rands books her heroes refuse to compromise their integrity and product quality despite external pressures, and lose out on making a profit as a result. Randian heroes do what Bob did, not what modern wall street capitalists do.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by CatWChainsaw on Saturday February 17, 2024 @12:54PM (#39411673)
Which makes Ayn Rand's heroes better than the douchebags we have IRL.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by TheGeminon on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:28PM (#39378427)
Where are you getting that the company is worth $50m? The article says it’s a “$100 million-a-year” business
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by bigtunacan on Thursday February 15, 2024 @12:20AM (#39379393)
To oversimplify a company with $100MM revenues annually and costs of $120MM annually is still losing money and has a real current value of $0.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by AceJohnny2 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:47PM (#39378535)
That’s revenue, which is different from company value.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by mydriasis on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:58PM (#39378598)
Oh boy, if his 100MM/year in revenue business is only worth 50 million, most startups are _really_ in trouble.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by AceJohnny2 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @10:22PM (#39378726)
Why yes, company valuation is uncorrelated from revenue.

By the way, this is why VCs love software startups, and drive so hard for an IPO exit.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cscurmudgeon on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @10:28PM (#39378762)
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by c0pium on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:41PM (#39379182)
That’s pretty clearly what they’re talking about, yes.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cscurmudgeon on Thursday February 15, 2024 @09:43PM (#39392511)
Not really. They and others here seem clueless about multipliers less than 1.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by c0pium on Friday February 16, 2024 @12:55AM (#39393683)
They described a fractional multiplier. That’s their whole point.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cscurmudgeon on Saturday February 17, 2024 @10:51PM (#39416015)
They were posting in disbelief. You should read their comment again.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by c0pium on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @10:44AM (#39442637)
That is obviously incorrect, is English not your first language?
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by missedthecue on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:46AM (#39382606)
Most startups are growing faster than a literal grain mill, and they have good unit economics. Another customer costs little for a software company. Another customer can cost a lot for a grain mill.

These contribute to valuation.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by _heimdall on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:32PM (#39379134)
I guess this explains Nvidia's valuation.

Revenue and company value are completely disconnected.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by AceJohnny2 on Thursday February 15, 2024 @02:32AM (#39380053)
Yes, see "P/E Ratio" aka "Price to Earnings Ratio", which is a basic measure of how overvalued a company is.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by gottorf on Thursday February 15, 2024 @10:17AM (#39383673)
I believe the preferred Wall Street parlance now is the "price to innovation ratio" ;-)
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by diputsmonro on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:11PM (#39378318)
I think you're making the same point, but just to make it more obvious - all of that is more an indictment of modern neoliberal business practices than it is of Bob's Red Mill. Sustainability, efficiency (in terms of doing things right, rather than doing them quickly) and overall most benefit for the most humans is better than the get-rich-quick schemes that most startups have become.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by nerdponx on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:57PM (#39378221)
Other than running up too much debt and getting bailed out (is that functionally different from getting outside funding?), I don't see any reason why these things are bad business.

Even if you're a steely-eyed capitalist, you have to admit that these were wildly successful long-term investments in developing loyal lifelong customer base.

The only difference is that the time horizon on those investments are much longer than your typical VC or PE firm cares for.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by devb on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:36PM (#39378475)
> the company never went public or sold to large agricultural interests to maximize shareholder value

Wow, shame on Bob :eyeroll:

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by matteoraso on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:52PM (#39378564)
Yeah, I can't believe that loser only managed to found a single company worth $50,000,000.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by mixmastamyk on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @10:24PM (#39378738)
Gordon Gecko is that you?

Sounds like a parody but you should make it clear to avoid downvotes.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by shiroiushi on Thursday February 15, 2024 @05:11AM (#39380953)
I think the clause starting with "cardinal sin" was the real tip-off.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by asveikau on Thursday February 15, 2024 @02:31AM (#39380045)
> In the defense of YC by modern neoliberalist definition bob was a terrible businessman

This sentence doesn't read as a defense of YC or "modern neoliberalist definition" but as a criticism of it.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by insane_dreamer on Thursday February 15, 2024 @01:03PM (#39386019)
> he committed the cardinal sin of making the employees owners instead of fully capturing the excess capital of his means of production and offshoring production

Ayn Rand is turning in her grave