News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by lIl-IIIl on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:07PM (#39375381)
What does it mean for a company to be employee owned?

What is the benefit to the employee?

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by jjtheblunt on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:14PM (#39375475)
extra compensation floats with profits and plausibly creates a positive feedback ?
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by HWR_14 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:27PM (#39375664)
It avoids the issue of dividing profits between employees and shareholders, which means the employees keep it.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by EasyMark on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @07:34PM (#39377608)
and dividends!
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by ensignavenger on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:29PM (#39375707)
Ability to vote on how the business operates and things like compensation and benefits. Different employee owned businesses are governed differently, but in general, the employees have more control.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by astura on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @07:26PM (#39377542)
I elaborated in a sibling comment, but this is just not necessarily true. Both employee owned companies I've worked for were effectively dictatorships where employees got exactly zero say in anything.

Employee-owned just means that employees are the shareholders.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by mixmastamyk on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @10:45PM (#39378868)
Shareholders have some rights to affect policy.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by quickthrowman on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:05PM (#39378989)
I work for a 100% ESOP and the only things we are able to vote on are mergers, ownership structure changes, liquidation, and dissolution. There are no other voting rights or board member nominations/votes.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by ensignavenger on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:47AM (#39382613)
How is the Board of Directors chosen?
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by CptFribble on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:35PM (#39375801)
think of how shareholders drive a company's behavior, and how much of most public corporations bad behavior is generating dividends or increased share price for large institutional shareholders, because the leadership (board) is voted for by those same shareholders

now imagine if a company's only shareholders are the employees who work there. how much different would a company act if the people to whom the leadership are responsible are the employees themselves?

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by dhc02 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:43PM (#39375920)
All of this is true, and on top of that, at least in the case of ESOP plans like the one at Bob's Red Mill, the outstanding stock of the company is held in a trust and distributed to employees as part of a benefits package over time, sort of like a 401k they don't have to pay anything to contribute to.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by oooyay on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @05:24PM (#39376426)
Employees have a say in the direction of the company. It depends on the bylaws, but employees will vote on certain things. There's a lot of talking it up here, but it can also suck. I worked for one that was very blue collar as a systems engineer and watched as our IT infrastructure decayed and our contractual promises would not be met because employees voted for bonuses rather than refreshed infrastructure.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by bruce511 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @05:39PM (#39376563)
With any sufficiently large group there will be a variety of opinions when making any decision.

Voting is one way to get a majority opinion, but of course that doesn't make it right. Since everyone is in a different place in life what may be good for one (maximising income before retirement) may conflict with another (ensuring job stability and sustainability for the next 20 years.)

This is all true regardless of the decision making group - board of directors, c-suite, or employees.

So sure, some employee groups would make decisions not aligned with my goals. But equally other decision making groups do that all the time too.

This is a hard problem because, as a decision group you "can't make everyone happy." So it helps if the employee group are mostly on the same goals page, and if there are leaders who understand the decisions in terms of the agreed goals.

Meaning, that regardless of profit share, its a good thing if you work at a place where your goals, and the leadership goals are aligned.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by astura on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @06:51PM (#39377235)
>Employees have a say in the direction of the company. It depends on the bylaws, but employees will vote on certain things.

No, this is not necessarily true - what you're describing is more akin to a co-op, not an employee owned company.

An employee owned company just means there is an ESOP (Employee Stock Ownership Plan). So employees own some or all of the company's stock. That's it, it's an ownership structure, not a management structure. It says absolutely nothing about day-to-day operations or how decisions are made. The vast majority of employee owned companies are still run like a dictatorship.

Source: I've worked for multiple employees owned companies. Both were effectively dictatorships. Literally zero voting whatsoever.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by ensignavenger on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:01PM (#39377821)
It is true that there is no single definition of "employee owned". However, in most contexts having a small monority of company stock owned by employees doesn't really count, if only a small percent of the company is actually owned by the employees.

I understood the context of the question to be cases where employees own the majority of the company. Maybe that is not what the questioner was meaning though.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by astura on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @10:33PM (#39378805)
I'm speaking of 100% employee-owned companies here. That's my experience.

In general, once a company established an ESOP[1], they eventually become 100% employee-owned. Usually when an owner establishes and ESOP that's the end goal.

It just takes many years to get to 100% because the company has to purchase shares from the owner and distribute them to the employees. It's not something that can happen overnight because the company has to fund those share purchases. Yes, the owner is paid, they don't actually "give away" the company.

[1] I should mention, in case it's not clear, that ESOP is not a general concept - it's a specific type of retirement plan in US law that's got a bunch of requirements associated with it.

Here's a bit more info - https://www.esoppartners.com/how-esop-works it's directed at company owners and actually touts staying in control as an advantage of an ESOP -

>An ESOP is also a flexible, tax-advantaged business transition and corporate finance tool that enables stakeholders in closely held companies to access their equity without giving up management control of the company, which enables an owner to carefully plan leadership succession and a smooth transition

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by oooyay on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @07:17PM (#39377479)
It was maybe a bit of both based on the corporate bylaws, but it was and is an employee owned company. What I described (bonuses over reinvestment) is a decision shareholders (employees) get to make.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by astura on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @07:35PM (#39377613)
That's why I said "necessarily."

>What I described (bonuses over reinvestment) is a decision shareholders (employees) get to make.

Sure, My only point is there's nothing about being employee-owned that requires or even encourages allowing employees to vote on how money is spent, or anything at all for that matter. A privately owned company is just as likely to consider input from employees as an employee-owned company is.

Both employee owned companies I worked for the board made those sorts of decisions without any say from employees.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by eep_social on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:00PM (#39378245)
An ESOP requires that employees certain voting rights but they’re narrow and if I am reading right, may also vary with state law.

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/epchd804.pdf

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by pbourke on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @09:22PM (#39378390)
> A privately owned company is just as likely to consider input from employees as an employee-owned company is.

> Both employee owned companies I worked for the board made those sorts of decisions without any say from employees.

If there was 100% (or majority) employee ownership, would the employees not have the ability to use the general meeting process to eject board members they didn’t like? Aren’t employees voting for nominees to the board, allowing them to use a write-in process to bypass a hostile board?

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by astura on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @10:12PM (#39378666)
Both were 100% employee owned.

>would the employees not have the ability to use the general meeting process to eject board members they didn’t like?

Lol, no.

Trust me, it would have happened if it were possible at one, the board was public enemy #1 among rank-and-file employees.

>Aren’t employees voting for nominees to the board, allowing them to use a write-in process to bypass a hostile board?

Lol, no. The board itself selects board members.

I'm not exaggerating, we literally had zero input on anything.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by cowsandmilk on Thursday February 15, 2024 @02:56AM (#39380188)
> there's nothing about being employee-owned that requires or even encourages allowing employees to vote on how money is spent, or anything at all for that matter.

I.R.C. § 409(e) requires voting rights for the employee shareholders in an ESOP on certain matters, so your “anything at all” is not true.

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by wavefunction on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @05:42PM (#39376596)
Sounds like white collar IT other than the bonuses
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by MichaelMoser123 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @11:45PM (#39379206)
Interesting. Wikipedia has a list of employee owned companies - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_employee-owned_compani...

Some of the US based companies in this list have something to do with tech and exist for quite some time. Interesting how these are run (i mean they would probably have closed shop if they were to hand out bonuses instead of investing)

/i am just asking, as I don't know much about the subject/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torch_Technologies a defense contractor with 519$ million revenue

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematica_Inc. (the last dot is part of the link, HN doesn't handle these)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graybar

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynetics they have 293$ m revenue

Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by spydum on Thursday February 15, 2024 @08:57AM (#39382741)
It's curious to note just how many of the US-based employee owned companies are in the grocery/food/bev industry
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by MichaelMoser123 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:07AM (#39416379)
maybe because some of them grew from a family business, but somehow managed to keep a similar ownership structure.
Re:Bob Moore, Who Founded Bob's Red Mill, Is Dead at 94 by pcthrowaway on Thursday February 15, 2024 @03:17AM (#39380282)
It gives employees a path to benefit from their labor directly rather than capitalized investors who aren't actually doing the work.

Normally companies seek to find the balance of "saving money" by paying lower wages that are just enough to entice mostly productive employees, and profiting from the employees labor.

To put it in the terms of Marx, the burgeouise pocketing the difference between the cost of their employees' labor and the value extracted from it is "surplus value", and is a manifestation of class warfare in capitalism that harms the working class. See also, "rent-seeking"