News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by blueflow on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @02:38PM (#39374167)
> It is possible that this could be done efficiently during the day using solar, thus minimizing the impact of the energy requirement.

No! It is not possible. It will always be more efficient to use the solar power directly to reduce CO2 emitters (like coal plants), because that skips the losses the CO2-emitting and CO2-capturing mechanisms will have.

Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @03:11PM (#39374629)
> No! It is not possible.

That's really aggressive.

> It will always be more efficient to use the solar power directly to reduce CO2 emitters (like coal plants)

Until you run out of coal plants. Then it stops being "always".

There are uses where it's very hard to switch to batteries, to the extent that it's easier to make biofuel or synthetic fuel.

Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by blueflow on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @03:21PM (#39374773)
> Until you run out of coal plants. Then it stops being "always".

Then you continue with, as i called them, other "CO2 emitters". Like cars or concrete production.

Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by zug_zug on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @04:04PM (#39375318)
It may turn out that it's cheaper and easier to just pull it out of the air than rebuild every single chemical reaction that produces CO2 (such as heating limestone in the creation of concrete).
Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @08:20PM (#39377997)
You should capture the carbon at the source for concrete production.

But airplanes are an example where producing fuel seems like a pretty good option.

Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by nradov on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @03:16PM (#39374701)
We're going to need significant amounts of storable liquid hydrocarbon fuels to operate long-range transportation. Most of aviation, shipping, and military activities can never be fully electrified. We'll have to figure out how to manufacture those fuels with minimal net CO2 emissions.
Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by refulgentis on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @02:48PM (#39374313)
Sure, but we've reached the limit of arguing in absolutes once we're there.

Due to the enormity of the physical work involved, we don't expect to have solar/wind/nuclear/hydrogen/whatever at 100% of the energy grid for many years to come.

In the meantime, cracking open limestone to make it absorb carbon is a good idea.*

We cannot redeploy literally everyone into making solar panels and building nuclear plants, therefore there is a relative gain to be made by switching at least some people from $UNRELATED_JOB_X to carbon capture.

* Worth mentioning: carbon capture doesn't require enormous amounts of electricity or really any significant amount of energy at all AFAIK - crack rocks, when rocks full, put somewhere.

Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by bluGill on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @03:51PM (#39375156)
> Due to the enormity of the physical work involved, we don't expect to have solar/wind/nuclear/hydrogen/whatever at 100% of the energy grid for many years to come.

My local utility sent me a message last year: they generated more power from wind than all customers total used. All it took was building windfarms all across Iowa, and they are still building more (I assume to sell to Chicago or Minneapolis, but I don't know how the grid is connected)

Sure there are times when the wind isn't blowing. However there is a lot of time when it is blowing, and most of the world isn't even 100% wind during those time. Get busy building instead of being defeatists or pointing out the times wind doesn't blow - those times are why you keep the old power plants operational. (though battery storage should be investigated)

Just getting todays low hanging fruit: Wind powered grid, and replacing cars with EVs would make a massive difference. Then we can start talking about other uses of energy, but between electric and cars we have covered most energy uses and those are ready to be fixed today, with today's technology.

Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by blueflow on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @03:26PM (#39374826)
How much cracked limestone do you need to offset a coal plant?
Re:Carbon capture tech a 'complete falsehood', says Fortescu... by refulgentis on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @03:36PM (#39374958)
Given in terms of mass of substance to mass of carbon

Limestone needs 2.3

Basalt 6

nothing on seaweed, unfortch

(source: https://www.economist.com/special-report/2023/11/20/carbon-d..., stick archive.is in front if you need to, I feel bad doing that directly as a customer)