News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by hresvelgr on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @03:43AM (#39355787)
Shell scripting in Elixir is like leaf-blowing your driveway with a helicopter.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by lionkor on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @04:24AM (#39355993)
You should, if you can?
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by adityaathalye on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @04:31AM (#39356021)
Absolutely. What is life without any fun?
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by diggan on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @03:51AM (#39355823)
Awesome, but too expensive to be within reach of the ordinary person and more harmful to the environment compared to alternative methods?
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @04:31AM (#39356022)
elevator leaf blowing might be harmful to the environment but whats the argument about elixir in this analogy?
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by diggan on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @06:01AM (#39356569)
I have no idea what parent is trying to say with their analogy, I'm trying to tease out some meaning from what they said. If anything, Elixir would be more energy efficient than bash as far as I can tell.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by fredrikholm on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @06:50AM (#39356806)
> Elixir would be more energy efficient than bash as far as I can tell

For long running scripts perhaps. BEAM idles at ~50Mb, and startup is often more than 500ms.

Eg:

  $ time ./hello
  hello world

  real    0m0,009s
  user    0m0,003s
  sys     0m0,007s
  
  $ time elixir hello.exs
  hello world
  
  real    0m0,755s
  user    0m0,992s
  sys     0m0,304s
Where the first example is a BASH script.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by throwawaymaths on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @09:52AM (#39358114)
Yes because when you load elixir you're loading the entire gOddamn Erlang VM. Which you might want for things like reliable parallel downloading, but you don't for hello world.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by toast0 on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @11:19AM (#39359185)
I don't know that you'll get it down to 10 ms, but you can get beam startup a lot faster if you adjust parameters.

The default startup does a lot of things you simply don't need in most shell scripts. Starting a bunch of threads, setting up dist, I can't remember what else off the top of my head.

Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by fredrikholm on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @01:20PM (#39360842)
Even without the shell and with epmd turned off we're still in the ball bark of 200-300ms:

  $ time erl -eval 'io:format("~s~n", [os:cmd("echo hello world")]), halt(0, [{flush, false}]).' -noshell -start_epmd false
hello world

  real    0m0,332s
  user    0m0,461s
  sys     0m0,092s
I spent some time last year trying to get those numbers down but this is as far as I made it. Do you know of any more flags that might help?
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by toast0 on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @03:53PM (#39362673)
Try -boot no_dot_erlang

A couple years ago that got me to 100 ms

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25243246

Today's measurements with FreeBSD 13.2 on the same Pentium G3470

time /bin/sh -c "echo hi"

   hi

   real    0m0.004s
   user    0m0.001s
   sys     0m0.002s
time /usr/local/bin/bash -c "echo hi" hi

   hi

   real    0m0.006s
   user    0m0.007s
   sys     0m0.000s
time /usr/local/lib/erlang26/bin/erl -eval 'io:format("hi~n"), halt(0, [{flush, false}])'

   Erlang/OTP 26 [erts-14.2.1] [source] [64-bit] [smp:2:2] [ds:2:2:10] [async-threads:1] [jit:ns] [dtrace] [sharing-preserving]

   hi

   real    0m0.197s
   user    0m0.178s
   sys     0m0.018s

time /usr/local/lib/erlang26/bin/erl -eval 'io:format("hi~n"), halt(0, [{flush, false}])' -noshell -start_epmd false -boot no_dot_erlang

   hi

   real    0m0.183s
   user    0m0.181s
   sys     0m0.011s
This doesn't look very good, actually! FreeBSD has OTP 21-26 available through pkg, I ran the same thing on each of them several times to warm up, and get (real time):

   21:  81ms
   22:  81ms
   23:  74ms
   24: 129ms
   25: 135ms
   26: 177ms
So maybe there's some new stuff that needs to be avoided now.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by fredrikholm on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @02:29AM (#39367421)
It was your original post that set me on course for experimenting with startup times, cheers!

Unfortunately, that final flag doesn't change much on 26 for me. IIRC I dropped a bunch of flags after concluding that no shell and no epmd were the only flags that I noticed improvements with.

Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by toast0 on Wednesday February 14, 2024 @06:18PM (#39376973)
Yeah, it looks like it got a lot worse. I don't think it's JIT, because I ran a test with a 32-bit version of OTP 26 (JIT is only available for 64-bit x86 and arm). But I'm not sure what it is.

Send me an email (in profile), and I'll try to find some time to look closer.

Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by thibaut_barrere on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @05:35AM (#39356380)
If your script needs to do things like reliable HTTP querying and JSON parsing, I would say using Elixir (once you get used to it) won’t be harmful in any way, quite the contrary.

Interestingly, what drove me to Ruby initially is exactly writing scripting tasks in a C#/C++ culture where Ruby would have been considered harmful.

Now Elixir can be used for the same type of tasks, but only better (eg: trivial parallelized downloads!)

Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by neonsunset on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @05:48AM (#39356470)
F# and C# are very different to C++ in this regard.

Parallel downloads in C# boil down to

    using var http = new HttpClient();

    var urls = new[]
    {
        "http://example.com/file1.jpg",
        "http://example.com/file2.jpg",
        /* ... */
    };
    var files = await Task.WhenAll(
        urls.Select(http.GetByteArrayAsync));
(you can replace '.GetByteArrayAsync' with .GetFromJsonAsync, .GetStreamAsync and more depending on your needs and e.g. forward the incoming data directly to files on the disk or another source)
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by thibaut_barrere on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @05:37AM (#39356389)
Ahaha, in a good way. Recently I have used Elixir scripts to mass-parallel-download numerous HTTP resources and do some stats on them, and it is exactly the feeling I had.
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by dtx1 on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @07:07AM (#39356884)
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by wturner on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @01:41PM (#39361121)
I envision the creation of a GenServer for each and every file on your system, using this to duplicate them by the thousands, then deleting them in a timed contraction over and over and over again. I call this, "the blowcopter".
Re:Shell Scripting with Elixir by Too on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @01:50PM (#39361239)
Still better than the inverse, that lots of scripters are doing; Building a helicopter out of a leaf-blower.