News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bombcar on Monday February 12, 2024 @10:44AM (#39346133)
The main thing I've learned from this smarthome stuff is make sure your light switches also work when damn near everything but the power itself is off.

Really annoying not being able to turn the lights on or off because something (doesn't matter what) is not cooperating on a software level.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by WirelessGigabit on Monday February 12, 2024 @11:05AM (#39346429)
I have one place like this. There is no connection from the switch to the lightbulb. If the network is down, no lights.

I have some TP-link press-switches (so no on-off, just press to invert state), and they work amazing.

They work when the network is down. And you can read the state. Even if you turn off the network, flip the state, and turn it back on, it works correctly.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by doubled112 on Monday February 12, 2024 @02:38PM (#39349307)
> I have some TP-link press-switches (so no on-off, just press to invert state), and they work amazing.

I just bought a 2 plug smart plug and this was a major selling feature.

What happens if I'm standing there and I don't have a device on me? I just press the button like I would anyway.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by Avamander on Monday February 12, 2024 @10:51AM (#39346216)
Yea, the behaviour I want is always just to enhance not replace.

This is why I dislike smart bulbs with dumb switches and similar bad combos. Smart home appliances shouldn't hide any features behind an app either. But every manufacturer has perverse incentives to push their apps.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bombcar on Monday February 12, 2024 @10:53AM (#39346266)
Things have regressed - the older Hue stuff could have switches that had no batteries (pressing the button generated enough electricity to send the signal) and they could communicate directly with the gateway or even the bulbs.

Now everything is wifi or bluetooth and it sucks.

Five years ago I would have designed a new house entirely around these things; now it would be so old-fashioned it wouldn't look out of place in the 1950s.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by xrd on Monday February 12, 2024 @02:23PM (#39349085)
Yes, it is insane how these things work. We bought a 60s house which presumably had bad wiring. The sellers elected to use "smart bulbs" and "smart switches" for everything to probably save money on the rewiring cost.

The thing you never realize, is that for each extra communication protocol and endpoint you add, you need to then troubleshoot across all the permutations.

So, if you are only using a wire to connect to another wire, there is only one path that can fail, the wire between them. Electricians are good at troubleshooting that.

If you add a wifi access point, and a smart bulb router (or whatever the fuck it is) and then you add a wifi extender, when things fail, which path did it take when it failed, or when it worked? The permutations you need to troubleshoot are suddenly an N^4 problem. Get your graph theory textbooks out and study up on the traveling salesman problem.

That's why we have had electricians come by who cannot figure out why when we push the wifi light dimmer button in one bedroom, that the other bedroom lights turn off. It just started happening a few months back. It's absolutely maddening.

All these smart devices are awful. As a related aside, our Amazon Ring devices no longer allow you to connect to their wifi with the Amazon Ring app, and we have a bunch of cameras that are dead once the power goes off. Used to be you could just join their temp wifi connection, register the device on the home wifi, and go. They turned that off. Now, they all say you need to get the QR code, but we cannot find that on the devices, so they are bricked. I'm sure this is because probably someone found an open wifi Ring camera, added it using their phone when they walked by, and spied on the family. But, I don't really care, I just know cameras are sitting there unusable by me, until some hacker walks by and figures out how to register them. I won't be spending anymore money on Amazon cameras, but I'm sure Amazon would be happy to have me just buy new ones.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bradhanson on Monday February 12, 2024 @11:36AM (#39346898)
Check out the Shelly products. They use local control of a relay using standard switching hardware, so if your network is broken the lights still work as normal. Technically the switch isn't actually switching the power so there's _some_ element of electronics between you and mains power, but it's close enough for me.
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bombcar on Monday February 12, 2024 @12:02PM (#39347279)
I've started using these switches: https://assets.lutron.com/a/documents/369987_eng.pdf as they work fine with the network off.

Amusingly enough the failed Best Buy product line still work great with Apple HomeKit (and manually) - even though they discontinued the cloud service and refunded all purchases as gift cards.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by devnulll on Monday February 12, 2024 @11:06AM (#39346444)
The key engineering point here is about failure modes. If the failure mode is a brick, then the engineering and design team behind that switch has failed.

The failure mode for a smart switch needs to be a "classic" switch. This applies equally to garage door openers, showers, door locks, and the rest of the smart devices.

Note: I'll give a bit of a pass to smart window blinds as a selling point is lack of strings and cables and the therefore look cleaner.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bombcar on Monday February 12, 2024 @11:27AM (#39346778)
It's like the failure mode of elevators vs escalators - the elevator fails and it's useless, the escalator fails and it's just a flight of stairs.
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by AlexandrB on Monday February 12, 2024 @03:02PM (#39349653)
Not necessarily so. (Warning, video of a bunch of people getting injured): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qE2Lv-t9BHk
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by eddieroger on Monday February 12, 2024 @02:58PM (#39349597)
I went with Lutron Caseta switches (though they're not the only ones that do this) for that reason. When all else fails, they are just dimmers and remotes that talk to said dimmer. When I want them to be more than that, they work with HomeKit and Home Assistant just great. But Lutron is a switch company first and foremost, and that shows in these switches. They surpass the Partner Acceptance Factor.

I'd add to your advice and say "do as much as you can to keep the experience vanilla," which in this case means standard fixtures and bulbs, just replacing the switches. For the price of half of one Hue bulb, my whole fixture is smart now, and I can still use whatever bulb I want.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by ydant on Monday February 12, 2024 @04:17PM (#39350637)
Have you found LED bulbs that dim nicely with the Caseta?

It's been a few years since I've tried, but in the past I went through so many bulbs that whine when dimming that I gave up and put in smart bulbs where I can conceivably hear the bulb. Which means I've got switches that don't work properly if the hub is down.

I love the Caseta otherwise. We use it for recessed cans and the whine is just not quite noticeable. But, e.g. over my bed it's very noticeable. Maybe newer models of Caseta solved something and the bulbs aren't the solution?

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bombcar on Monday February 12, 2024 @05:18PM (#39351303)
Dimming is always the problem. I'm so fed up with bulbs in general that I may next time just wire multiple bulb-holders instead of one in each area.

The dimmable room that is working "best" is the one where everything is Hue and controlled "together" but it has issues when the Internet is down. The push-button switch they no longer make works decently well even then (sometimes): https://meethue.co/products/philips-hue-tap/

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by amluto on Monday February 12, 2024 @10:39PM (#39354043)
I haven’t tested Caseta, but the current generation of Philips LED bulbs dim quite nicely with other Lutron dimmers.
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by WorldMaker on Monday February 12, 2024 @03:22PM (#39349942)
Related to this, I still think think the original version of the Hue Tap switch was clever and I'm still surprised didn't have more clones and didn't entirely survive the internal revision wars/external protocol wars: the original didn't use a disposable "button" battery and instead used mechanical energy of pushing the button to power sending the Zigbee signal. It takes more force than a regular light switch to hit it with enough physical power, but it's also kind of satisfying in the way a mechanical keyboard button can be or a big chonky "snooze button" that you kind of want to smack with some force anyway.

I've heard it said that sort of mechanical powered switch with Thread/Matter is much harder, except with these old existing ones in bridges with old Zigbee compatibility, and more's the pity. It still seems such a good idea to me, one less battery to waste/go bad at exactly the wrong time.

Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by bombcar on Monday February 12, 2024 @05:23PM (#39351354)
It was a phenomenally amazing idea, and I'm really sad it was discontinued. When I realized how it did the magic, it almost singly-handedly sold me on Hue (their stupid upcoming app account requirement unsold me, let me tell you).
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by WorldMaker on Monday February 12, 2024 @05:34PM (#39351468)
Yeah, I'm not thrilled about that account "requirement change" either. To be fair, for various different reasons over the years, I've used third party apps a lot more than the main Hue apps, so this may just be a push to switch back to third party apps again and/or finally upgrade from a Hue-only bridge to something like Apple Home Hub, which I'd been considering lately anyway because Apple HomeKey sounds like something useful to me (I'm less likely to forget my watch than my keys these days).
Re:I was wrong to ignore Zigbee and Z-Wave. They're the best... by codingminds on Tuesday February 13, 2024 @03:18AM (#39355652)
That's the reason why I've chosen KNX. As long as there's power, it's working. Just keep a spare power supply and you'll be fine.

Also no mesh and network fiddling, just a bus wire.