Then do the sales tax as well. I’m not exaggerating anything. This is why my family and so many others moved from the state during COVID.
Have fun buying tiny $2-3 million dollar homes paying 40%.
I didn't know everyone on this site met their spouses at work. Statistics say that's been dwindling for 15 years or so. Then you account for the 20-30% of women in tech (and the fact that not every woman wants to marry a techie)...
Still, congrats on your situation.
>Have fun buying tiny $2-3 million dollar homes paying 40%.
Well, I'm single (with worse rates) and CA is 9.3% for my bracket + 24% federal. Doesn't seem too unreasonable. Sounds more like a housing issue than a tax issue.
It's also why I live out in a suburb. I know people online these days glamorize walkable cities, but California right now isn't very "walkable", even if we could redesign everything tomorrow. Lot of other deep seeded issues to solve first.
California 13.3% Hawaii 11% New York 10.9% New Jersey 10.75% District of Columbia 10.75% Oregon 9.9% Minnesota 9.85% Massachusetts 9% Vermont 8.75% Wisconsin 7.65%
Tax burden is a different measurement including property. Parent poster has no property.
https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/state/tax-burden-by-state...
Ah, I see that was copied from the list of top tax rates rather than what most people actually pay:
https://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tips/fun-facts/states-with-t...
So, yes, if you’re making millions per year in taxable income, California’s top rate is higher. That is not a concern for anyone outside of the 99.5th percentile, which is uncommon even in FAANG circles.
Tax burden is also the best metric to use because the money has to come from somewhere. If you’re trying to decide where to live, looking at state income tax only is as foolish as only looking at housing purchase prices without also considering your commute, utility, and maintenance expenses.
But isn't that what "top rate" meant in the first place? It doesn't mean "median".
Seems like you're moving the goal posts over a few percentage points. Whether it's 12% or 14.4%[0], it's very high.
And at some point those very wealthy and highly mobile people start thinking, "maybe we should crunch the data and do what other wealthy people are doing: find a state with a more reasonable tax bite."
0. https://www.wsj.com/articles/gavin-newsoms-stealth-tax-incre...
If you want to accuse anyone of shifting goalposts, start with the people trying to portray the concerns of the top .1% as employee issues.
That's nonsensical. You need to compare the effective tax rate that people pay.
When I was making bank at tech, sure, I was in CA's top tax bracket. But I never paid that rate across all my income. My effective tax rate was quite a bit lower.
This seems to be a strangely common cognitive pitfall - I’ve seen so many people talk about progressive tax rates that way, even claiming that a raise would cost them money, and it’s not like this is a secret or requires advanced math skills.
https://www.ftb.ca.gov/forms/2023/2023-540-tax-rate-schedule...
This means that in practice, California isn’t even in the top 10:
https://www.npr.org/2023/03/30/1166970506/tax-burden-by-stat...
Now, the housing market is not great but again, greatly overstating your case is not an effective strategy, and it isn’t a uniquely California problem even though prop 13 makes it worse there than many other places.