News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:04AM (#39316185)
EDIT: I want to add that man made climate change needs to be addressed and the defendant is objectively opposing this. That said, the great HL Menchin once said “The trouble with fighting for human freedom is that one spends most of one’s time defending scoundrels.”

Concluding that scientific research is fraudulent because you have you own reasons to believe its conclusions are false can’t be defamation without compromising free scientific inquiry. Even if your reason for concluding its fraudulent is because you believe in a flat Earth, courts are not the venue to resolve questions of scientific debate. That is a can of worms that should never be opened lest we find ourselves in a new Lysenkoism.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by dysfunction on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:10AM (#39316252)
There's a difference between concluding that scientific research is wrong and concluding that it is fraudulent. The latter is a claim about the character of the scientist involved, alleging them to have taken unethical if not illegal action. If that is provably false then it can certainly rise to the level of defamation.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by graphe on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:20AM (#39316383)
What's illegal about torturing data?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by mjhay on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:25AM (#39316473)
It may or may not be illegal (it probably would be in the case of fraudulently obtained grant funding), but academic fraud is career-ending. It is a very serious accusation. Besides, you are completely misunderstanding how defamation works. Defamation does not require that an allegation of a crime. Heck, there's even a term for this kind of thing: defamation of character.

https://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/civil-litigation/defama...

Another term you might want to look up is "Dunning-Kruger."

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by graphe on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:30AM (#39316551)
Really? What about Francesca Gino who is at Harvard https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/profile.aspx?facId=271812 and has even fraud and retractions on her Wikipedia? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Francesca_Gino Still a teacher at Harvard and filed a frivolous suit of defamation to the detriment of data conda.

I see no evidence that data fraud is "career ending" and the snark about dunning Kruger is fitting for your comment.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by linuxftw on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:57AM (#39317056)
Indeed. It seems fraud is table stakes at this point.

Typically however, climate 'scientists' abstract their fraud. They take raw data, fit it to their 'model', and then produce a conclusion. Sometimes they get over zealous, and manipulate the raw data, like the NOAA was caught doing.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bluish29 on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:26AM (#39316500)
There is two problems here :

1- there is a difference between being wrong and being fraud. Einstein was wrong in a paper claiming that gravitational waves are not real (he was convinced later it is). He did not fabricate anything in this work. He did not invent equations, made up observation data ...etc.

2- You are talking about conclusions and belief. Here is the problem, there is a scientific method. If you want to draw conclusions, then you have to follow that. You provide evidence. If you think this is fraud because the conclusion doesn't fit then you need to argue with better models/data or interpretation but not just based on final result that you don't like.

If you believe that everything contradicts flat earth is fraudulent then you are basically making up stuff and you don't have proof and this is defamation not science.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:36AM (#39316675)
If you criminalize people’s incorrect beliefs then you are doing politics and not science.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bluish29 on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:50AM (#39316927)
You can have a belief that this is wrong result based on nothing. If you want to say that this is fraudulent then you have to prove that this is fraud. There is a difference as I said in my comment.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:00PM (#39317097)
Thats not how anything in science works. You should be able to express your beliefs without having absolute proof and get fined if a court doesn't agree with you.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bluish29 on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:06PM (#39317206)
Actually if we are talking about science and not freedom of speech. Technically you are wrong, to work in science you have to follow scientific method and publish your conclusions with your methods, data and models.. etc. You can say whatever you want within this framework. A significant portion of the publications in any field is found wrong later sometimes by the authors themselves. But claiming that a work is fraud is not ab opinion. Actually even disagreeing between actual scientists usually comes in form of other work proving the other work is wrong.

Welcome to the scientific community.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by arrrg on Friday February 23, 2024 @09:36AM (#39481034)
Saying “this is wrong” is very different from saying “this is fraud”. Why is it so hard for you to tell the difference?

You never even need to engage with the question of whether something is fraud when disputing something.

If you say that there are 75 million people living in Germany I don’t need to call you a lier or a fraud to say that you are wrong and dispute your statement. That‘s just not necessary. I can just point at this website https://www.destatis.de/EN/Themes/Society-Environment/Popula... and say you are wrong. What do I care whether you simply misremembered, go wrong information from someone else and believed them or are actively lying.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by add-sub-mul-div on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:06PM (#39317207)
Are you unaware/pretending to be unaware that words are tools that can be used to commit crimes, or do you sincerely believe that any words that can be possibly strung together are or should be protected free speech that supersedes all other rights of others and legal responsibilities of yours? What is it about saying the word "politics" that erases all of that?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by thinkingtoilet on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:40AM (#39316728)
Correct. And 99% of climate change denial is politics and not science.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:45AM (#39316838)
Right, as is fining them millions of dollars for disagreeing with you. I’m honestly fine with that, my complaint is the hypocrisy of conflating political actions with science.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bluish29 on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:58AM (#39317073)
I really wonder if you read the article or not. This is not about disagreement or opinions. This is about fraud claims

> with skeptics claiming Mann manipulated data. Investigations by Penn State and others found no misuse of data by Mann, but his work continued to draw attacks, particularly from conservatives.

As an example. You solved a problem and I see that you solution is wrong (whether I am correct or not ia irrelevant) I would say you are wrong because you did this and that. I will not say that you are wrong because you have cheated unless I have a proof that you actually cheated (i.e data manipulation)

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:23PM (#39318328)
Don’t be coy. This isn’t about one academic falsely accusing another of faking a specific measurement. This is a political activist calling an entire field of research fraudulent because its conclusions don’t conform to his political beliefs. Its outrageous and indefensible but living in a free country means people are allowed to believe and express outrageous and indefensible things.