News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bdw5204 on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:33AM (#39315791)
It seems like the main issue in the case was the completely uncalled for comparison of the climate scientist to a convicted child molester not disagreement with the results of his research. You have a 1st Amendment right to say that the earth is flat if you want to but you don't have the right to equate a scientist who says it isn't flat to Jerry Sandusky.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by burkaman on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:38AM (#39315852)
Is that true? At least based on the verdict, it seems like the factually incorrect claim that his work was "fraudulent" was punished more harshly than the child molester comparison.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bdw5204 on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:25PM (#39317551)
I see the "fraudulent" thing as a hyperbolic way of saying "I strongly disagree" but I'd say that is a debatable point that reasonable people could disagree over.

In American political debate, it is common to throw around names like "communist" and "fascist" to refer to your political opponents but that doesn't mean most people actually think the Democrats and Republicans really are the Communists and the Fascists. I think it's dangerous rhetoric because some people might believe it and act accordingly while others might genuinely be totalitarians and stay under the radar but it's the political culture we have.

The child molester comparison does provide additional context in this case that makes it much easier to interpret "fraudulent" literally rather than as hyperbole.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bcrosby95 on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:16AM (#39316323)
Calling someone or something a fraud is different from simple disagreement.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by barbazoo on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:40AM (#39315881)
Is the 1st amendment relevant here? I thought that was only about the state limiting your speech through law etc.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by marchingkazoo on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:45AM (#39316837)
This was a civil case, not a criminal case. Steyn and Simberg were not prosecuted for their speech. They were asked to be held accountable for a tort. Different standard. That said, Steyn and Simberg would almost surely not be in the position that they find themselves now if they had simply refrained from using three words: Jerry, Sandusky, molested.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by mikeyouse on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:07AM (#39316225)
This is the state enforcing a penalty against a citizen - so yes, still relevant.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by denton-scratch on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:03PM (#39318104)
I'm not USAian, so I may be wrong; but I believe the 1st is about the state restricting speech, not about the courts enforcing penalties for civil damages.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by mikeyouse on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:24PM (#39321235)
Yeah that’s not right - the most prominent examples are about the state restricting speech, but the first amendment provides really broad protections to all manner of speech that would have to be refereed by ‘the state’.

Ken White (Popehat) is a prominent 1st amendment attorney and has written about this - the second bullet point applies;

https://web.archive.org/web/20240116140758/https://www.popeh...

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:55AM (#39316079)
Freedom of speech is not a constitutional amendment. It’s an American cultural value.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by BobaFloutist on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:03AM (#39316180)
Freedom of speech is literally a constitutional amendment. It might also be an American cultural value, but it's absurd to say it's not a constitutional amendment.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by barbazoo on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:27PM (#39317574)
Non-US person here so please excuse my ignorance. What amendment covers speech that doesn't involve the government. This is what I found on wikipedia about the 1st:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amendment_to_the_United_...

> Although the First Amendment applies only to state actors, there is a common misconception that it prohibits anyone from limiting free speech, including private, non-governmental entities.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:27PM (#39318380)
If you personally believe in freedom of speech, then you will give your political opponents a platform to disagree with you and debate them on the merits (if any) of their arguments. This principle of honor is what motivated the first amendment and so people confuse the principle with the amendment.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:17AM (#39316344)
The amendment is just one minor manifestation of a very fundamental cultural value. People who do not believe in freedom of speech will often excuse curtailment of it when such curtailment is not prohibited by the amendment, as freedom of speech is just that one law. So no, the amendment LITERALLY is not what freedom of speech is.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by TheCleric on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:56AM (#39317032)
Yeah but one of those we have encoded into law, and the other is just vibes. What you define as a freedom of speech and what I do may be different. How should we adjudicate which one is correct in terms of how our laws are enforced?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:01PM (#39317127)
Where do you think laws come from?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by TheCleric on Friday February 09, 2024 @01:50PM (#39318719)
Where they come from is irrelevant. What they are right now is.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Friday February 09, 2024 @02:38PM (#39319437)
Why?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by TheCleric on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:20PM (#39321197)
Why not?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by goodSteveramos on Sunday February 11, 2024 @10:42AM (#39335722)
Because we can change the law based on our feelings of fairness so talking about where laws came from is not irrelevant as you bluntly asserted.
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by johndevor on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:36AM (#39315826)
I thought you did have the right to say anything about any public figure?
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by hacknewslogin on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:43AM (#39315917)
You can, and you won't get arrested. But if you are intentionally trying to cause harm by what you say, that's defamation. https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/first_amendment
Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by lolinder on Friday February 09, 2024 @12:30PM (#39317621)
If you are intentionally trying to cause harm by saying something that is provably false and succeed at causing harm, that's defamation. There are four tests and you have to prove all of them:

> To prove prima facie defamation, a plaintiff must show four things: 1) a false statement purporting to be fact; 2) publication or communication of that statement to a third person; 3) fault amounting to at least negligence; and 4) damages, or some harm caused to the reputation of the person or entity who is the subject of the statement.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/defamation

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by thaumasiotes on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:22AM (#39316427)
> But if you are intentionally trying to cause harm by what you say, that's defamation.

Absolutely not. It can't be defamation unless it's untrue, and it also can't be defamation unless it's injurious to your target's reputation.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by bombcar on Friday February 09, 2024 @10:38AM (#39315848)
The bar for a defamation lawsuit is higher for a public figure, but it still exists.

There's some precise way to say the same thing without falling afoul of it, even then.

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by Karellen on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:12AM (#39316279)
There's an interesting bit of complexity here though because a fair amount of Mann's status as a public figure is because of the climate-conspiracy community's singling him and his work out as a target to be attacked.

If a group elevates someone to be a public figure, and uses the fact that they're a public figure to defame them in ways that would not be permitted for non-public figures, should the group really be allowed the same protections that random members of the public have talking crap about people who are incidentally famous?

(I suppose it gets a bit complicated that Mann didn't retreat from the attacks, and used the notoriety thrust upon him to become a fairly prominent science communicator. Even so, giving his attackers any benefit of the doubt doesn't seem right somehow...)

Re:Jury awards climate scientist Michael Mann $1M in defamat... by mandevil on Friday February 09, 2024 @11:05AM (#39316195)
Public figures have to prove "actual malice" (a technical legal term- don't use the casual conversation definition for those words) in order to get libel, which is a much higher bar than us regular schmoe's have to clear. But it still exists.