Getting around San Francisco is, uh, grid-like: I think in terms of "corner of X and Y", and then the relationship between myself and my destination on a coordinate plane. Getting there becomes a series of maneuvers - some of them indirect, for route-efficiency reasons (like, this street has timed lights, or this one permits left turns) - which carry with them very few (street-level, at least) visual images of the route.
London is all about pathways, a choice between more and less direct connections between my location and where I'm going. Just about every landmark and decision-point triggers a visual memory of that specific location and choice.
In San Francisco I can point fairly confidently towards a given destination, drive that direction, and find it by "feel" - eg, by intersecting one of the two cross streets on the coordinate plane. In London, I couldn't do that on a more granular than borough / neighborhood level - like, I'd know how to get to, say, Camberwell from a given location, but not in precisely which cardinal direction it lies, and once I get there I'd need to rely on landmark-based directions (or nowadays, GPS).
Navigation in London is more complex, I suppose (San Francisco has its quirks!), but the conceptual framework it requires leaves me with a more detailed and enjoyable sense of the city itself.
That's one person's experience. I'd be curious to know the extent to which it generalizes.
I love driving in London. It demands complete attention, like an action-oriented video game, and the culture (if you will) of drivers is a wonderful blend of courtesy and aggression. Like, if you sit waiting to make a turn onto a busy street you'll never find a gap, but if you assert yourself into traffic someone will always let you in; or, if you and someone else simultaneously arrive at opposite ends of a street with only one traffic lane you're immediately in a race with them to get to the pullout to let the other one by. It's great fun, and made everywhere else I've driven feel like easy-mode.
Also I've learned people don't give directions using cardinal directions: there's no such thing as "walk North on Seorae-ro" (or at least I was told). Which I guess makes sense since the streets on which this would be a useful mean of communicating directions are very few.
The only exception is the city I went to uni in - when I moved, I bought a map and studied it quite a lot. It’s a city I have a much stronger perception of north in, and I don’t really have the angles problem above, but I still have the distance problem.
The net effect was that my brain considered the Theatre District to exist in another — largely inaccessible — dimension.
The effect is that you can walk along a canal, not really notice the curving of it, and be surprised that you're facing 90° or more away from where you expected.
The closest thing to grid around here is southern Helsinki, and it's also my least favorite area to navigate in. I'm always off by a block or two, and it feels like it's all the same, no landmarks or character or sense of scale.
But when I'm just a few km to the north, with diagonal streets etc, I can locate myself much easier.
The article and linked paper talks about "legible cities" and people struggling to navigate a non-legible city because they don't know which way they are facing if there is not a grid.
Do people who grew up in a rigid grid system have a different way of viewing the world compared to those who are used to more chaotic and organic layouts? If folks don't know where they are going or which way they are facing without relying on the roads being a grid, what other aspects of their lives are impacted by under-developed spatial reasoning?