News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @08:56AM (#39301932)
Indeed. And Kiril (patriarch) is just a "former" KGB-agent. Here you can see some Soviet-style photoshopping a $30,000 watch away.

https://archive.nytimes.com/thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/0...

Conservatism is traditionally a great vector for propagating an extreme agenda. That's also why you nowadays can see the GOP being co opted by the Kremlin, while simultaneously Evangelicals are up in arms behind Trump. Some of these people really think Russia stands for traditional values and demand UA to surrender.

Same occured here before WWII, where Hitler was seen as law&order and would finally do something against undesirable elements from society.

The playbook of strong-men and their servants are boringly predictable. Lhbti-free zones (Orban, Hungary), racial rage, women needs to embrace traditional role, forbidding books, you name it. None of it contributes to society in any meaningful way, but you can get 50% of the USA behind it.

"Nah, he is not really going to do what he says". Yup.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by DiggyJohnson on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:00AM (#39303493)
> Conservatism is traditionally a great vector for propagating an extreme agenda.

Is there any ideology not prone to this? Seems like a needlessly divisive point to include in this analysis. There is also common patterns in the devolution of progressives and revolutionaries. But that's obvious.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:25PM (#39306356)
I didn't know it is such a divisive point. You can be perfectly very traditionally religious, but be aware that today's authoritarianism tries to appeal to you. I know first hand.

-------

I will add something. Religious tradition can be a great source and motivator to uphold human values. Let's focus on that.

I propose we move away from the concept of conservatism, as I get the feeling that for the US audience this is too political. Rather, let us answer the question whether we want to do good for our neighbour.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by lazide on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:39PM (#39306567)
This whole line of discussion is weird - Stalinism and the USSR was the definition of anti-conservative and authoritarian. Literally ideologically leftist to a polar extreme in many ways.

Authoritarians come in all ‘colors’.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:23PM (#39307160)
I think the confusion stems from mislabeling and the cultural associations that some people have with it. In the US, the term socialist usually means something bad, while in Europe all modern states are build around some concept of democratic socialism.

If I say progressive, some people here might identify that with some mouth foaming marxist that will apologize any non free-market dictator.

Label progressive = human rights , not economic policy.

Any suggestion for a term that works better in your habitat is welcome!

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by lazide on Thursday February 08, 2024 @07:22PM (#39309721)
Progressive means things like ‘buy fair trade’ and ‘carbon offsets’ too. And ‘sanction countries with bad human rights’.

It’s also economic policy.

None of that addresses my points either.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by tomohawk on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:10AM (#39302090)
Propagandists do like to co-opt narratives. It's a natural vector for sympathy. In terms of US politics, this has affected both of the main parties over the years. Singling out the GOP here is itself a false narrative. There are surely people in that party who are co-opted, but that is only part of what's going on. The Dems also have their useful idiots.

Speaking of WWII, Joe Kennedy (John's father) was quite useful to the Nazis.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @09:53AM (#39302587)
I hope you will agree that we should not distract ourselves by, I believe not intended, false equivalency and whatabouttisms. The situation is too serious.

- We were talking about how conservatism has the weakness that it is particularly prone to siren songs of authoritarians.

- There are more bad things happening in the GOP with respect to the democratic constitutional state, but that is hardly a relief. The Dems might have their own idiots, sure, but there is no equivalency here.

- Perhaps I should not take the bait, but John Kennedy, the president, was not an anti-semite, unlike his father indeed, who was not president.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by nradov on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:19AM (#39302910)
Leftist and progressive movements are equally prone to authoritarianism. We should be on guard against extremists on both sides of the political spectrum.
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:37AM (#39304070)
It is good to be on guard. Extremism is bad for society, be it left or right leaning. But we shouldn't confuse things.

With progressiveness we are talking about progress in human and civil rights towards a more free society.

It does not mean you have to agree with all policies of them. Authoritarianism is a direct contradiction with progressiveness.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by shakow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:12PM (#39305399)
> Authoritarianism is a direct contradiction with progressiveness.

Ever heard about this Lenin guy?

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:12PM (#39306174)
Revolutionary `neq` progressive, especially not in our time. If your read up on Lenin and the Revolution no serious human rights advocate today would vouch for that.
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by shakow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:27PM (#39307223)
But the early USSR was both authoritarian and progressive, with the suppression of nobility privileges, strong improvements to women's rights, legalization of homosexuality, etc.

> no serious human rights advocate today would vouch for that.

This is close to a no true Scotsman argument; virtually no older-than-30y.o. political movement would check all the boxes to be qualified as such.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:58PM (#39307602)
You are right it had progressive elements and some regressive elements, sure!
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by tbihl on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:40PM (#39306575)
'Human progress' would appear to be the most seductive end to justify any means, judging by 20th century.
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by lazide on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:42PM (#39306611)
Hardly. Authoritarianism is what happens when ‘the right things don’t happen’ on their own based on ideology, so they need to be forced.

Like seizing farmland from landowners and forming collectives to farm them instead (USSR).

Or forcing affirmative action despite no identifiable discriminatory actions. Which is literally openly happening right now in the West in tech and other areas.

It’s about forcing reality to confirm to an idealized ‘right’ way, despite objections or resistance - including often ignoring if the final situation/state even works. Example: Chinese Great Leap Forward and rural steel ‘mills’, USSR and collectivism, etc.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by shakow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @01:11PM (#39305390)
> Conservatism is traditionally a great vector for propagating an extreme agenda.

Empirically, a lot of ideologies are a great vector for propagating an extreme agenda, from Nazism through conservantism to the Big Leap Forward through progressism and many others in the middle.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:38PM (#39306557)
You can't sweep liberalism on the same heap as Nazism. I think that each ideology has it's own weaknesses, but they are not the same.

What I learned from this general discussion though is that politics made a honest civil discourse difficult about these kinds of things.

Instead, we should talk about personally held values rather than sociological phenomena, as these have turned into political shibboleths.

Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria by shakow on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:16PM (#39307058)
I'm absolutely not sweeping liberalism with nazism, sorry if it came out this way. My point is that I don't see extremism being more characteristic of conservatism than some other ideologies.