> Authoritarianism is a direct contradiction with progressiveness.
Ever heard about this Lenin guy?
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria
by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @02:12PM
(#39306174)
Revolutionary `neq` progressive, especially not in our time.
If your read up on Lenin and the Revolution no serious human rights advocate today would vouch for that.
But the early USSR was both authoritarian and progressive, with the suppression of nobility privileges, strong improvements to women's rights, legalization of homosexuality, etc.
> no serious human rights advocate today would vouch for that.
This is close to a no true Scotsman argument; virtually no older-than-30y.o. political movement would check all the boxes to be qualified as such.
Re:Surely You're Joking, Comrade Beria
by exceptione on Thursday February 08, 2024 @03:58PM
(#39307602)
You are right it had progressive elements and some regressive elements, sure!
'Human progress' would appear to be the most seductive end to justify any means, judging by 20th century.
Hardly. Authoritarianism is what happens when ‘the right things don’t happen’ on their own based on ideology, so they need to be forced.
Like seizing farmland from landowners and forming collectives to farm them instead (USSR).
Or forcing affirmative action despite no identifiable discriminatory actions. Which is literally openly happening right now in the West in tech and other areas.
It’s about forcing reality to confirm to an idealized ‘right’ way, despite objections or resistance - including often ignoring if the final situation/state even works. Example: Chinese Great Leap Forward and rural steel ‘mills’, USSR and collectivism, etc.
With progressiveness we are talking about progress in human and civil rights towards a more free society.
It does not mean you have to agree with all policies of them. Authoritarianism is a direct contradiction with progressiveness.