News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TeMPOraL on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:42AM (#39300088)
They are not misguided. They are not there yet, but progressing steadily.

There is nothing misguided in switching out a human for a machine that can do a job better, while keeping the job unchanged. Iterative improvement is the only thing anything ever gets done, and yes, that means we might first need to get drivers out of the streets before we're able to make more substantial redesign of the transportation fabric.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by tpoacher on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:18AM (#39300301)
"[...] that can to the job better" is the key phrase here though.

It's probably a bit misguided in the sense that, if the end-result further down the line is the "more machines than humans driving in the streets" (let alone zero humans), then it might have made more sense to iteratively change the infrastructure instead, rather than have machines try to work under infrastructure that is designed to be good for humans but bad for machines, and then try to "iteratively improve" under conditions that carry significant risk of injury.

Brings Ford's quote on "faster horses" to mind. Imagine if we still required roads to be horse friendly, and expected our cars to go through mud and jump fences.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by actionfromafar on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:23AM (#39300338)
But the roads and cars were iteratively improved in a co-evolving way. Early cars with huge wheels could traverse cow-paths and mud and weren't very fast. (And you opened fences. :-)
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by Draiken on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:59AM (#39300550)
Maybe it partially explains why cars hurt/kill so many people every single day?

I agree with GP: automating everything and removing humans from the equation would be a much better solution. Unfortunately it's not practical because it's not profitable.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by idiotsecant on Thursday February 08, 2024 @04:29PM (#39307977)
Yes, its definitely a conspiracy and not because we can barely manage the non-intelligent infrastructure we have now.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by TeMPOraL on Friday February 09, 2024 @03:23AM (#39312661)
We can barely manage the non-intelligent infrastructure because it's not profitable.

Getting humans to agree on something at scale larger than half a dozen is like herding cats. Money is catnip - it works well at aligning masses towards common goal.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by idopmstuff on Thursday February 08, 2024 @11:20AM (#39303785)
> it might have made more sense to iteratively change the infrastructure instead

Except iteratively changing the infrastructure requires political capital along with actual capital in the form of tax dollars. Self-driving cars can be built outside of existing infrastructure and paid for entirely with private funding.

Changing infrastructure is a nice idea in theory, but the practicality of getting anything done in SF means that if you want progress, you should look to other options.

Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by snthd on Thursday February 08, 2024 @06:30AM (#39300726)
We've somehow skipped the itteration where we switch out humans for machines on the job of limiting maximum speed.
Re:Waymo Hits Cyclist in SF by mnky9800n on Thursday February 08, 2024 @05:49AM (#39300497)
I think they meant that cars are bad and public transit is good and solves the problem of wanting to do something else while in transit as opposed to driving.