News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by sackfield on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:01PM (#39263475)
I am looking forward to the stressors this places upon identity in the online world so we can develop something better than showing a picture of an ID card. Some sort of public/private key repository kept by licensing authorities would be a more preferable solution to me at an initial glance.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by yellow_lead on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:14PM (#39263641)
As far as I know Estonia has had something like this for years
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by boeingUH60 on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:12PM (#39263610)
Until that licensing authority gets hacked, then RIP to online security..
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:46PM (#39264096)
That's a good reason to not use HTTP, because hey, the keys can be hacked! The CA can be hacked, let's just use plain text and pray.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by jerf on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:18PM (#39264634)
The CAs have been hacked. Multiple times, in several different ways. And that's just the public ones we know about, which I have no reason to suppose are all of them or even necessarily a significant fraction of what we would consider compromises. At the scale of "everything done on the internet" or "all the money" you can't wave this issue away. It is difficult, if not impossible, to build a security system that is more expensive to break than "all the money and value in the world".

A government identity to do business with the government might just about be possible. A government identity to cover everything done by everyone everywhere is not. The value of cracking that system is just too high.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:26PM (#39264769)
> A government identity to cover everything done by everyone everywhere is not. The value of cracking that system is just too high.

So the value of the system being broken is too high, yet we live in a world where it's broken, as anybody can make a photoshop of your driving license? I'm sorry I don't get the argument.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by jerf on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:32PM (#39264895)
Basic principle of security: A security system should be more expensive to break for the attacker than the value of the thing it is securing to the owner.

This is generally a counter to people using binary thinking and believing that a security system is broken if there is any way in at all, thus thinking things are either in the categories "secure" or "insecure" without any further qualification. In fact those categories don't exist. It is intrinsically at a bare minimum a spectrum of security, and one can slice & dice more finely if one likes based on what sort of attacks various different types of attackers can mount, e.g., defending against whole-internet scans is one thing, nation-state attackers specifically targeting you quite another.

I'm using it in a different way: When what you want to lock behind your security system is essentially "all economic value in the world", such as "we'll solve all identity problems on the internet by just having the government provide identities", that means you need to create a security system that is more expensive to break than "all economic value in the world". However, you can't. Any conceivable security system is easier to break than that.

There is a sense in which it is simply necessary that there be a wide variety of independent identification systems, each individually covering sufficiently small amounts of value that they are possible to exist at all, and with a diversity of costs and strengths to cover the various cases.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:35PM (#39264966)
>When what you want to lock behind your security system is essentially "all economic value in the world"

Do I really?

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by jerf on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:52PM (#39265242)
Perhaps you are not a native English speaker, this may help you: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_you
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:59PM (#39265374)
I think the fault of arguing with obnoxious people on the internet to learn that they are also rude is totally on me.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Spivak on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:39PM (#39265041)
And because of that a photo of your driver's license is at best a low-pass filter. A central identity system where you get strong identity verification will be relied on for real security and authentication making it a properly juicy target the level of Gmail for account compromises but the real life security of Verizon issuing phone numbers and sim cards.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by sgift on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:50PM (#39268834)
It's a classic fallacy of "the old one may be extremely bad, but it's already there, so it's okay, but the new one needs to be perfect against anything any scenario someone can think about, no matter how far fetched". We have this pretty often here in Germany. The requirements for anything digital are so incredibly high compared to the non-digital version we have currently/had before (depending on whether we finally managed to introduce a digital version), it's just sad.

Let me send you that totally secure fax with my totally secure signature drawn by hand. Far more secure than a digital document signed by this scary, newfangled electronic signature, which could have been hacked and is therefore totally insecure.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by c22 on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:18PM (#39263690)
Sure, but this is like saying you shouldn't replace your cardboard box with a safe because it could get cracked.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by maxwell on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:24PM (#39263771)
Cardboard boxes aren't subject to leaked electronic keypad codes.

https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/liberty-safe-changes-its-p...

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by stefs on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:30PM (#39263842)
still, card board boxes have no security at all; doesn't matter whether the codes were leaked or not.

there's a point to be made for expections of strong security where it's actually weak, but is no security at all really better than bad security?

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by maxwell on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:40PM (#39265997)
Cardboard boxes can be acquired without a record of their purchase and are easy to hide among other cardboard boxes, like a book in a library. Also can be used to hide from enemies while moving around under the box.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:40PM (#39265057)
It can be. If my bicycle has no lock at all, I will not leave on a outdoor parking near the central railway station, because I know for sure it will be stolen. The value here comes not from imperfect security per se, but from my ability to predict the outcome. Now if my bicycle has a meh lock, the chance of it being snatched suddenly increases.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by fluoridation on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:32PM (#39265865)
So what are you saying? That the solution is to never prove your identity to anyone in any way?
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:45PM (#39266072)
I'm saying that maybe people who chose to accept the id scan knowingly accept the risk, have a second line of checks somewhere, evaluate amount lost to fraud or fines against the cost of having full-fledged PKI and also knowingly make it your problem if their evaluation proves to be wrong.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Spivak on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:31PM (#39264874)
I think the argument against is that right now people know how terrible an authentication system this is and don't build actual security on top of it -- "we only have cardboard boxes so we installed cameras and encrypted the contents."

Once it's good people will outsource the work to what is essentially a CA system where every BMV in America is an issuer and I expect it to hold up at best as well as SMS verification.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by c22 on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:59PM (#39265373)
I think the problem is that people are relying on this for actual security. The article demonstrates how easy it is to get companies to accept this form of fraudulent authentication (and the demand for this service speaks to its efficacy as well).

Why not let notaries or an authoritative agency issue cryptographically signed one time codes upon inspection of your physical ID? Frankly, it sounds like a superior system to me.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mormegil on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:24PM (#39263772)
EU is working on an "EU Digital Identity Wallet". Which might be a good step in that direction. Even though it remains to be seen whether it won't be piggy-backed on some current weak authentication/identification methods in practical implementations.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:45PM (#39264088)
Even US had it solved two decades ago on a peak of post 9/11 paranoia. Federal agencies use smartcards internally, there is federal root and the copy-cat of that was successfully rolled out in different flavors in several countries in Europe as well.

On the other side of the spectrum, there is Dutch digi Id, which is the only way to use any government service online and works either with pure and simple username+password or a second factor through the app. There is no rocket since involved -- government agency sends you an activation code to your registered address and you activate the app.

Then there is Ukrainian Diia, which is kinda both and also bundles government services themsevles and a digital id generator into the same app. But it's all built on top of existing PKI infrastructure that is used for decades before to tackle the problem of district tax office doing shenanigans with your tax reports.

Add:

And of course the most no brainer way to roll it out in a fragmented landscape of US is to let banks be Oauth2 providers, as they are already tasked with KYC stuff and have a license to lose. See https://www.bankid.com/en/

refs:

https://www.concretecms.com/about/blog/devops/how-make-us-go...

https://diia.gov.ua/

https://www.digid.nl/en/security

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mormegil on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:09PM (#39267220)
> And of course the most no brainer way to roll it out in a fragmented landscape of US is to let banks be Oauth2 providers, as they are already tasked with KYC stuff and have a license to lose.

Yeah, the same works in the Czech Republic, the banks provide an OIDC service, including document signing, see https://www.bankid.cz/en

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mschuster91 on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:41PM (#39265070)
> And of course the most no brainer way to roll it out in a fragmented landscape of US is to let banks be Oauth2 providers, as they are already tasked with KYC stuff and have a license to lose.

That doesn't stop banks from pulling all kinds of shit with their customers' identity or what they believe to be that. The amount of credit scams possible in the US is mind-boggling for me as an European.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:56PM (#39265303)
I feel like the tolerance to fraud is just higher in US or something, as the alternative is being sent to GULAG right after having your federal id issued.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by marwis on Monday February 05, 2024 @03:47PM (#39266934)
> That doesn't stop banks from pulling all kinds of shit with their customers' identity

Such as?

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mschuster91 on Monday February 05, 2024 @06:11PM (#39268505)
Wells Fargo employees for example got caught creating millions of accounts without the consent of the customers to meet unrealistic quota by their managers [1], and not just once, but at least three times (2016, 2018, 2023).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wells_Fargo_cross-selling_scan...

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by nickrubin on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:47PM (#39264111)
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by smeej on Monday February 05, 2024 @12:50PM (#39264160)
People are already selling their Worldcoin identities. It has already failed.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by intotheabyss on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:47PM (#39265171)
The actual blockchain usecase here is far less sexy than a dystopian eyeball scanning device: https://attest.sh/
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by jamiek88 on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:01PM (#39265404)
Those immutable world ID’s are great! I have twelve different ones I like them so much.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by aidog on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:27PM (#39264783)
Japan has done this with the mynumbercard. It's an ID with a chip on it. The problem is they used to tell people that the Number was private.

It hasn't caught on for verification outside of government yet.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mschuster91 on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:40PM (#39265050)
> Some sort of public/private key repository kept by licensing authorities would be a more preferable solution to me at an initial glance.

Everyone in possession of an ICAO 9303-compliant ID card / password (so, at least everyone in Europe) already has such a thing. These cards can be read by any NFC enabled smartphone that can act as a reader, and the chips themselves can act as a a secure element capable of a range of cryptography functions.

The problem is that while ICAO 9303 is a standard to retrieve and verify the data, it's fundamentally based on the assumption that it is just used to retrieve the data written in cleartext on the card as well as the biometric data so that you can build a staff-less boarding solution for air and sea ports. It's just a read-only dump of the data, signed with a certificate from the card issuer.

We'd additionally need a standard similar to what Germany and Croatia have done that allows a person to use their computer or phone as an NFC reader "proxy" to create a digital signature against a service-provided challenge that can then be traced back to the government's PKI.

Or, to put it in SSL terms, each government has a root CA, that issues a sub-CA certificate to the card producers ("can issue certificates for #.de"), who in turn have the card provision its own public/private keypair, and then sign the card's public key to use as a sub-CA ("can issue certificates for #.person-identifier.de").

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:08PM (#39265510)
>We'd additionally need a standard similar to what Germany and Croatia have done that allows a person to use their computer or phone as an NFC reader "proxy" to create a digital signature against a service-provided challenge that can then be traced back to the government's PKI.

Why bother with NFC if the phone itself has secure enclave and a biometry check to lock it down too?

And the best part of course, the federal government of US doesn't just have a standard, but actively uses all that for quite some time, just explicitly without NFC.

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mschuster91 on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:13PM (#39265596)
> Why bother with NFC if the phone itself has secure enclave and a biometry check to lock it down too?

There have been a lot secure-enclave exploits against both Apple [1] and everyone else [2], and fingerprint readers can also be bypassed. The Secure Enclave itself has a giant attack surface and is highly complex. (That however does not stop dreams of "digital driver's licenses" and whatnot, though, but that's another question)

In contrast to that, ISO 7816 smartcard stuff has been in use for decades, and (unless it's Javacard...) a very limited complexity. It's rare to see something else other than sidechannel attacks.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24025502

[2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/manual-code-review-finds-35-vu...

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:24PM (#39265751)
Fair enough. So the attack scenario is having a rogue state-sponsored app installed on everybody's device (think tik-tok), which steals everybody's private keys ... and does what? Registers an account on coinbase to launder money? Applies for a childcare subsidy and wires the money to insert country here?
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mschuster91 on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:31PM (#39265845)
> Fair enough. So the attack scenario is having a rogue state-sponsored app installed on everybody's device (think tik-tok), which steals everybody's private keys

The German AusweisApp2 is fully open-source (to protect against the first scenario), and it might be possible to do it in a web app assuming Web NFC gets more widely supported [1].

The second scenario is protected against by the keys being provisioned on the smartcard during manufacture (or, if the user so desires, at the touchpoint where they get handed over the ID card) and being unable to be exposed, at least not without either destructive methods or side-channel attacks.

[1] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Web_NFC_API

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by Muromec on Monday February 05, 2024 @02:40PM (#39265985)
Yeah I get how smartcards work, I'm talking about what can practically go wrong if the keys are kept in a secure enclave instead.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by mschuster91 on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:59PM (#39267838)
Malware can go and dump the keys from the Secure Enclave. It's just the same mechanism that pirates use to crack the Widevine decryption, just that it's the strong digital identity of a person towards a government at stake here.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by amarant on Monday February 05, 2024 @01:53PM (#39265255)
Here in Sweden we have a solution called BankID that is pretty much that. To get the key the first time you need to go physically to a location to identify yourself, after that you can use your BankID to get a new one when your first is about to expire(this is basically rolling your private cert)

Never heard of any successful identity thefts in this system, except where someone has been tricked into signing something with their BankID that they shouldn't have. That's pretty hard to defend against on a systematic level though, at least in a way that's fool-proof.

https://www.bankid.com/

Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by sackfield on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:07PM (#39267180)
I've used BankID, I think its a fantastic system.
Re:The Underground Site Where 'Neural Networks' Churn Out Fa... by lxgr on Monday February 05, 2024 @04:00PM (#39267103)
Simple public/private keys are neither private nor usable enough, but a federated, interoperable ID system is indeed desperately needed.