That's like climate denialism. There is a documented 30-year history of ISPs not expanding their network while claiming subsidies for exactly that: https://newnetworks.com/bookofbrokenpromises.htm .
...even if it doesn’t make economic sense
You're conveniently ignoring the "not justified by genuine issues of technical or economic feasibility" in your own goddamn quote.
You are conflating two things.
I haven't read the book but does the data show they did it in a discriminatory manner, that is they didn't expand to minority areas even when it made business sense?
Then why grant them monopoly rights in the first place? Why not remove monopoly rights instead of adding more regulations/bandaids?
Does a free market have monopoly rights?
Because it is in society's interest that utilities be available to all. We don't have a post office for only the areas profitable to deliver to.
Yeah, which has nothing to do with race at all, and everything to do with population density. ISP’s don’t want to invest to expand to rural areas with few customers for obvious reasons, none of which have anything to do with discrimination of any kind.
Those proposed changes are not racist, they are simply and blindly anti-poor.
GP is saying that white non-economically-profitable neighbourhoods get no protection from that rule.
Also not if, for example, an ISP decides to expand to a minority area instead of a white area because of DEI policies.
In theory that should also be forbidden by the rule against racial discrimination, but in practice it's often not enforced that way.
I ask because those are diametrically opposed positions, and your second sentence illustrates why the first sometimes doesn't happen.
That is often the case because that's what "antiracists" admit and encourage:
"The only remedy to past discrimination is present discrimination. The only remedy to present discrimination is future discrimination."
To that, I say, no, adding more discrimination to the world does not remedy discrimination.
Then presumably the law will have no effect.
Your conclusion is assuming bad intentions, but frankly the effect of most anti-discrimination provisions tends to be rather minor. It's extremely difficult to prove, unless people are blatant about it.
A US law required the FCC to issue rules "preventing digital discrimination of access based on income level, race, ethnicity, color, religion, or national origin," and gave the FCC some leeway in how to implement them. The resulting FCC rules let consumers file complaints about alleged discrimination and define the elements the FCC would examine when investigating whether an Internet service provider should be punished for discrimination.
The FCC defined digital discrimination of access as "policies or practices, not justified by genuine issues of technical or economic feasibility, that differentially impact consumers' access to broadband Internet access service based on their income level, race, ethnicity, color, religion, or national origin or are intended to have such differential impact."
I very much doubt ISPs are in the habit to turn down expansion in any area (and therefore more money/maintain their regional monopoly) because of the race of people living there. It seems like a way to force them to build out in non-white neighborhoods over other places even if it doesn’t make economic sense.
For one, that’s racism against white people by another name. We see that a lot now but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t fight it.
For two, it’s just an incredible waste of resources at the FCC. There are better ways to guarantee good internet for everyone instead.