News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by hughesjj on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:41PM (#39233177)
If you look around, basically every company Elon took over or started relies heavily on government handouts (or at least did during the primary r&d phase)

Those handouts were intentional incentives to invent tech the government saw a need for.

Regrettably for the government (and society), the guy who ended up taking advantage of those incentives the most ended up being a complete nitwit. So, we're kind of stuck with him until the government actually grows a pair and gives the SEC actual teeth, but too many nitwits are influential and would also be hurt by an SEC that does more than slap them on the wrist, so it's never going to happen

/Rant /personal opionions

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by thevillagechief on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:51PM (#39233303)
It looks to me like the government has gotten it's money's worth and then some from their transactions with his companies. Whatever his personal antics, I can't think of any instance his companies haven't delivered whatever the government has asked of them. Perhaps we should separate the services his companies provide from the man himself. If he stops delivering, the government can look elsewhere.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by hughesjj on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:29PM (#39233872)
Yup. I still think on the whole Elon has done more good than harm in the long term, but man is he trying hard to make it zero sum.

I think the ideal for society would be for him to lose leadership over those companies and just disconnect from the internet/enjoy life, but I don't see him ever doing that

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by elevatedastalt on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:47PM (#39233254)
The government didn't hand over that money for free, they paid it in return of goods / services (such as NASA launches).

If you have a company that makes bridges and the government hires you to make a bridge is that also a handout?

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by hughesjj on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:27PM (#39233852)
.... I think you're agreeing with me?
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by justrealist on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:48PM (#39233266)
Yeah Tesla paid back their loans fully.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by jsight on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:52PM (#39233307)
You don't understand. The people that SpaceX beat out for launch contracts because they were too expensive were not grifters!

Only the company that did better work for less is guilty of being a grifter. /s

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by elevatedastalt on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:08PM (#39233569)
The whole thing is honestly insane. I feel people just regurgitate talking points they hear from other Musk-haters without any critical thinking themselves.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by AstralStorm on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:01PM (#39233452)
Until it started doing this Starship thing and literally blowing up money regularly.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by ggreer on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:10PM (#39233607)
That's part of the reason for their success. They iterate rapidly and learn from their mistakes. SpaceX destroyed nine Falcon 9 boosters and one test booster (Grasshopper) before managing to land one. Now they have more successful consecutive booster landings than any other rocket family has had successful consecutive launches.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by jwells89 on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:10PM (#39233600)
That isn’t really a problem so long as as it delivers a more capable product more quickly and cheaply than the old method of rockets remaining mostly paper for the better part of two decades.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by boeingUH60 on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:08PM (#39233558)
You mean rapidly experimenting and innovating to cut costs, unlike the competitors who don’t have the guts to do that and constantly rob the taxpayer blind?
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by jdminhbg on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:44PM (#39233217)
> the guy who ended up taking advantage of those incentives the most ended up being a complete nitwit

Wow, what terrible luck for that to keep happening!

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by philangist on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:54PM (#39233348)
This nitwit brought EVs to the mass market! And build a re-usable spaceflight platform that even the most powerful nation states can't rival! And helped found the world's leading AI lab!

I pray to god to be a nitwit like that.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by s1artibartfast on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:54PM (#39233351)
Yeah, complete and absolute moron. His only skill is running successful companies and dominating the competition.

Now, if were as smart as someone like me, he would agree with my politics and sensibilities.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by gruez on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:48PM (#39233260)
>Regrettably for the government (and society), the guy who ended up taking advantage of those incentives the most ended up being a complete nitwit. So, we're kind of stuck with him until the government actually grows a pair and gives the SEC actual teeth, but too many nitwits are influential and would also be hurt by an SEC that does more than slap them on the wrist, so it's never going to happen

What do you what the SEC to do about spacex?

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by mensetmanusman on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:49PM (#39233283)
investments aren't handouts.

the ROI for govt investment in spacex has been more than 10x which is a crazy number considering the amount vnc/hedge funds spend on trying to reach a fraction of those returns.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by hx8 on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:04PM (#39233510)
Pretty sure VCs are looking for closer to 100x than 10x.

Additionally, this is survivorship bias. You can find lots of very risky investments that will pay 10x if they mature.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by s1artibartfast on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:39PM (#39234015)
>Additionally, this is survivorship bias.

The applicability of survialship bias depends on of you are assessing government investment success in general, or SpaceX success.

Time has shown that a few research contracts for spaceX were objectively a good bet.

>You can find lots of very risky investments that will pay 10x if they mature.

yes, but it is harder to find investments that do mature and pay 10X.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by robocat on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:50PM (#39235535)
VC funds themselves are poor investments: "VC returns haven’t significantly outperformed the public market since the late 1990s, and, since 1997, less cash has been returned to investors than has been invested in VC".

They want 100x returns from their one winning investment, but most VC funds fail to find their unicorn.

Yes, selection bias, but also conflating funds with unicorns!

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by tomjakubowski on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:14PM (#39233655)
Measuring ROI on electric car tax rebates is not so straightforward
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by s1artibartfast on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:21PM (#39233768)
Sure, same for solar. I dont think anyone even tried to make an economic ROI argument for either.

There was a moral environmental argument for government establish the rebates, so presumably the government wants the purchases made and rebates claimed.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by adventured on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:55PM (#39233363)
> If you look around, basically every company Elon took over or started relies heavily on government handouts (or at least did during the primary r&d phase)

Entirely false. That's just a cheap hit on Musk.

His first company did not. X (which became part of PayPal of course) did not. Neuralink did not. His funding of OpenAI did not.

So what are you going to say? You can start a successful rocket company that delivers a lot of payload to space, people to the Moon or Mars, and you plan to not involve the US Government / NASA? Ha! Sure. Please research what the launch sector looked like before SpaceX, what were the options?

You're going to start or take over an energy company (SolarCity) and it's not going to cross paths with the government? Solar shouldn't be subsidized? Yeah ok.

You're going to deploy utility scale energy storage (Tesla), and it's not going to involve dealing with governments? Hmmm.

You're going to attempt the Boring Company, digging long stretches underground, and you're not going to involve the government. Right.

You're going to take on a bunch of the largest companies on earth in terms of sales (car companies), including some of the most politically connected (GM, Ford; both of which have rather notorious histories of killing competition using politics), and you're not going to help your customers save money by making sure they qualify for EV subsidies? Un huh.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by kiba on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:08PM (#39233567)
He could be doing all of that without making a fool and a general ass of himself, as opposed to being consistently a master class act.

Whatever accomplishment you want to make in the world, it's no excuse to be an ass.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by adventured on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:46PM (#39234112)
The issue isn't whether he's making an ass of himself, he certainly does that anytime he gets a platform to speak on regarding general topics. I think everybody knows he does that at this point. So what.

Why should I care if Musk makes a fool of himself when trying to talk about anything outside his competency? Why would I become emotionally charged about such a meaningless topic? His detractors do, they can't control themselves. It's because they now view him as someone to fight with in the forever culture war; they previously viewed him overwhelmingly as an ally, prior to the Trump years.

At issue is whether people can be rational enough to control their emotions and separate out Musk's obnoxious personality, the way he broadcasts it often, from the factual reality of his accomplishments.

The need of his detractors to strip him of all accomplishment, is plainly pathetic. It's easy to recognize both good and bad in regards to the life of a person, without lying and pretending someone like Musk is just all bad/negatives (terrible person, zero accomplishments - that's the detractor position).

They view him as a political and cultural opponent (to one degree or another). If you're their opponent, you must be entirely destroyed (not partially, entirely). Since we live in a culture of extremes in terms of politics / partisanship. Their opponents can have no good qualities, no positives, they're all nazis across the board.

George W Bush garners a lot more sympathy/ respect from the same exact people than Musk does. The guy that launched a war with Iraq that got hundreds of thousands of people killed in the following civil war, he's more likable than Musk per their views. That's the insanity we're dealing with. Because Michelle Obama likes Bush, and Ellen Degeneres likes Bush, the Clintons built a rapport with the Bush family, so golly gee he can't be all bad, tee hee, it's so cute how he paints and stuff. The same people called Bush a nazi while he was in office. It's because he's no longer viewed as part of the culture war, they called off the attack.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by hughesjj on Friday February 02, 2024 @07:43PM (#39236486)
Not everyone who hates musk Hates him because of the 'cultural war'. Personally my turning point was the pedophile comments levied against the diver who rescued those kids trapped in that cave combined with him repeatedly lying to pump TSLA stock and ever thinking the boring company was an idea he could execute on.

That said, I've seen no evidence that he's contributed more than funding and hype for his companies. Perhaps that's enough for some people to call him a genius, and I suppose in those domains he is, but everything I've seen w.r.t his engineering indicates to me that he's an idiot. That wouldn't be a problem we're it not for him giving out bad engineering takes everywhere, but I digress.

@ George Bush, I'd definitely want to include his pushing common core, banning government funds for stem cell research, tax cuts, financial deregulation, waterboarding, and making Dick Cheney his VP on his list of failures

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by kiba on Friday February 02, 2024 @10:22PM (#39237263)
If all Musk is good for is for hype and funding, there's a dime a dozen entrepreneurs who would have done the same thing as him and be equally as successful and make himself less of an ass.

I evaluated him as a person who inserted himself and made engineering decisions for good or ill and the result speaks for themselves.

Now, whether or not we agree if Musk is good at engineering is beside my point. We should hold our entrepreneurs to higher standard, and not excuse their shitty behaviors.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by robocat on Friday February 02, 2024 @06:00PM (#39235620)
Why do you think that?

The things I like most in a friend often come with a price.

From what I can tell, many successful people are asses and their is a linkage between those two issues.

Media tends to warp how much we can understand about a public person, so it is hard to judge.

Even the successful asses I have personally met, I usually can't imagine removing the ass without removing what made them successful. It's not just a crazy artist stereotype.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by kiba on Friday February 02, 2024 @10:24PM (#39237274)
Even the successful asses I have personally met, I usually can't imagine removing the ass without removing what made them successful. It's not just a crazy artist stereotype.

We can do better. Why not?

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by robocat on Saturday February 03, 2024 @03:05PM (#39244212)
One key trait of arseholes is that they usually have zero interest in changing their behaviour, and tend to strongly dislike others trying to change them.

You and I can do better because we care to improve ourselves.

Your answer is unrealistic. Have you ever successfully changed a narcissistic arsehole? I certainly don't know how to. I have heard some arseholes talk the talk about how they will change their destructive behaviours (although more usually just denial and excuses), but I have rarely seen them actually succeed in changing.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by jsight on Friday February 02, 2024 @05:49PM (#39235517)
> You're going to start or take over an energy company (SolarCity) and it's not going to cross paths with the government? Solar shouldn't be subsidized? Yeah ok.

I think there are reasonable arguments that solar subsidies shouldn't exist. But if you want to start a solar company what are you going to do? Not take them and also somehow contractually bar your customers from taking them?

These are weird arguments to make against a company.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by justrealist on Friday February 02, 2024 @02:48PM (#39233259)
> Regrettably for the government (and society)

It's not regrettable for the US that we have the world's leading rocket launch company and the largest EV company (outside China). It's actually pretty great for us.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by kiba on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:02PM (#39233470)
He can be both a nitwit and a genius.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by colechristensen on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:11PM (#39233611)
Eh, I think Elon is just more public about himself than other industrialists who, if you got to know them, would be equally as dislikable on average.
Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by s1artibartfast on Friday February 02, 2024 @03:27PM (#39233853)
I think the public would hate the vast majority of other humans, if behavior was transparent and they focused attention on the negative.

Ghandi was a pedophile, MLK was a wifebeater, Mother Teresa was a homophobe, Jefferson was slave owner, ect.

Re:Owning SpaceX's Starship Rockets Could Be in Department o... by snapplebobapple on Saturday February 03, 2024 @09:32PM (#39246974)
Its more he is the guy who actually did it after taking the money. Look at rural broadband funding for a glaring example of the more common version of this where the government spends tens of billions and gets nothing.