News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by throwaway4good on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:18AM (#39213501)
All the big blocks: EU, US, South Korea, Taiwan, and China assume that their subsidy policies will expand their market share.

Obviously they cannot all be right.

The only that I think is given that will expand its global market share is China. Paradoxically because of the US sanctions and the fact that it relies so much on imports presently.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by onion2k on Thursday February 01, 2024 @03:51AM (#39213961)
Obviously they cannot all be right.

As a percentage of the market, that's true, but if the subsidies grow the whole market then every block's dollar value of market share can all go up.

Every startup learns this lesson quite early on. It's a heck of a lot easier to grow a market by 5% than it is to take 5% of the market from a competitor, mostly because competitors do things to try to stop you.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by jdietrich on Thursday February 01, 2024 @04:03AM (#39214015)
Sure, but the semiconductor market is mature bordering on stagnant. There's a high-risk/high-reward competition for the leading edge that is currently dominated by TSMC, but there's just not much money to be made from the older nodes that the automotive, aviation and military segments care about. Building out capacity to secure your supply chains is potentially a very sensible strategic decision, but I'll eat my hat if it ever turns a real profit.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by mejutoco on Thursday February 01, 2024 @04:11AM (#39214053)
After, if we assume from Apple sales, everybody got a mobile phone, AI could be what makes it non-stagnant again. Just companies ordering GPUs and servers, plus more and more similar features being shipped to consumer hardware could make a difference.

I do not have any data though, just thinking out loud.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by FrustratedMonky on Thursday February 01, 2024 @07:07AM (#39215105)
Yes. Think this is it. Even if some sectors appear stagnant now, everyone is expecting some huge growth spurt with AI. Lots of new data centers, GPUs, etc...

and of course, for national defense, to have homegrown supply chains.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by junipertea on Thursday February 01, 2024 @01:21PM (#39219278)
I would assume all those companies want cutting edge (higher performance at lower energy cost), not chips that are 5-10 years behind. Those can barely run current android.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by throwaway2037 on Thursday February 01, 2024 @07:12AM (#39215132)
> the semiconductor market is mature bordering on stagnant

Is this true? And by what measure? I see nothing but incredible growth driven by cloud, mobile, and AI/ML.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by pas on Thursday February 01, 2024 @07:27AM (#39215260)
barriers to entry are getting higher by the minute, there are no new entrants, most of them are state-sponsored, and it's true for the whole supply chain.

sure, there's technological progress and demand, but the market is in a near pathological state. (very short lifecycles, huge investments required even for fabs to keep up, etc. sure, it's unlikely that it will collapse, as demand is very strong, but market participants are very exposed to external factors. there is a huge discontinuity due to the dilemma of staying put and trying to beat the competition on price, or going all-in and building a new fab or at least upgrading one to be able to offer a newer/better process node. which leads to even more consolidation.)

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by FirmwareBurner on Thursday February 01, 2024 @07:23AM (#39215221)
But that's only a small part of semiconductors localized in a couple of hubs. The vast majority of semi work isn't working on that.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by paulmd on Thursday February 01, 2024 @08:09AM (#39215550)
Do you mean the market is stagnant or the tech is stagnant, because those are different things imo.

If we have finally reached the final boss of silicon lithography, then the market will figure out whatever nodes make sense (best efficiency, best performance, best value) and presumably we will need ever increasing amounts of them… especially if future solutions just stack tons of dies together etc. it’s fundamentally a pivot from growing through the tech to growing through packaging and putting more silicon into a product… at higher power and cost. But as that market model matures you will very much continue to need more and more capacity to replace the growth that used to come from Moores law.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by jacquesm on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:20AM (#39213516)
Having the largest internal market which is still on the rise probably also helps, but China has enough problems that it may all come to nothing in the end.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by kramerger on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:32AM (#39213575)
But after the trade war with Huawei and zte they don't really have a choice, do they?

A multi billion dollar company will not just lay down and die when its shut out from the open market, it will use its muscles to create its own.

Hisense is not the market leader, but they have done a significant leap in the last 5 years (Not all of it through legal means thought)

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by jacquesm on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:43AM (#39213637)
Agreed they don't have a choice, I'm just not so sure about the positive outcome. Xi has built a house of cards and has too much of a cult of personality to create a stable environment.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by throwaway4good on Thursday February 01, 2024 @03:23AM (#39213821)
Wrt. this I don't Xi matters a lot. There is consensus in the broader Chinese leadership that China needs to move up the value chain to the point where it has leadership, and potential self-sufficiency, in all key industries and at the same time stimulate internal demand.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by davedx on Thursday February 01, 2024 @04:47AM (#39214259)
He's cemented his position as dictator-for-life, and also shown that he will actively interfere in publicly traded companies. That matters a hell of a lot.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by jacquesm on Thursday February 01, 2024 @05:42AM (#39214574)
Xi isn't going anywhere as long as he's got a pulse.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by maxglute on Thursday February 01, 2024 @03:05PM (#39220630)
This is opposite of reality. House of cards (RE overinvestiment) of past leadership was inherited by Xi, who has been actively dismantling it for years, which he started early - RE square footage stagnated a few years after he started office. Meanwhile, almost every PRC strategic improvement that US is panicking over from PRC military modernization to MIC2025 to PRC moving up science/innovation, capturing higher value supply chains, PRC expanding trade influence was driven by Xi. He also inherited inertia from past efforts still it's been down to his guidance. Which is not to say he did "best" job, but good enough job that PRC strength on trend to grow under his trajectory, which we have 10+ years of data on.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by ChadNauseam on Thursday February 01, 2024 @03:50AM (#39213952)
> Obviously they cannot all be right.

They could all be right that their market share will be higher if they adopt this policy than if they don’t.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by close04 on Thursday February 01, 2024 @08:29AM (#39215697)
The market share is the percentage of the market, up to 100%. The market might grow due to the different measures adopted but percentage wise it will always be limited to the whole being 100%, split between however many players. Everyone's share increasing means the market going above 100%.

What OP means is that it's a mathematical impossibility for everyone's market share to increase. It's a zero sum game, for any player's market share to increase, someone else's must decrease.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by danaris on Thursday February 01, 2024 @09:27AM (#39216267)
I think that what the GP is saying is that they could each be correct, individually, but not all collectively.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by close04 on Thursday February 01, 2024 @11:03AM (#39217365)
> they could each be correct, individually

In that case "They could all be right that their market share might be higher". Because they never operate individually, in isolation. Two people can predict opposite outcomes that could be correct for a coin flip but only one is correct.

More on the point, I think they all invest in the same strategy not because they know they'll win but because they know without it they'll lose. Even so it's guaranteed that some of them will lose.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by RGamma on Thursday February 01, 2024 @01:54PM (#39219680)
The collective case is called https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_competition btw.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by croes on Thursday February 01, 2024 @03:59AM (#39213999)
But without subsidies they could lose market share
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by sbierwagen on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:22AM (#39213530)
>Obviously they cannot all be right.

Sure they can, just ban imports. Each country/trade bloc ends up with their own chip.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by dragonelite on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:38AM (#39213615)
But then you will shrink your global market share. Semi conducting fabrication on a sub 7nm can only work if you have big market share to keep the factories running 24/7..
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by throwaway4good on Thursday February 01, 2024 @02:30AM (#39213568)
They don't have to. The US is doing the banning.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by davedx on Thursday February 01, 2024 @04:46AM (#39214252)
Saying something is a "given", without providing any evidence, is a pretty silly argument
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by dataking on Thursday February 01, 2024 @06:29AM (#39214834)
> The only that I think is given that will expand its global market share is China.

That doesn't make sense given that all the other big blocks are cooperating across borders while China is subject to stiff export controls in an area with real technological chokepoints.

Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by maxglute on Thursday February 01, 2024 @03:04PM (#39220609)
PRC is entrant, west is incumbant with majority of global shares to lose. PRC building up mature nodes, which is still plurarity of chips, which they can soon with indigenous supply chains. As since they are huge export source, and intermediate good source, they get to inject their own chips into everything on global markets. Of which they now trade more with global south than they do western bloc. West can consolidate within bloc, but they'll start to lose large segements of global share, which is where future growth will be. Loss of global revenue, will in turn impact west ability to R&D without large subsidies, which drives down commercial viability. There was study analysing result of PRC domestic overcapacity turn into exports in various sectors like solar, display etc, and their effects on incumbant leaders (predominantly western firms) operating profits, and the effect was like 50-100% loss. The TLDR is west already has dominant global share, any share PRC gains on global market is share lost by west, and west is going to lose big if they retreat/consolidate around only monopolizing western shares .
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by throwaway2037 on Thursday February 01, 2024 @07:11AM (#39215129)
Why did you exclude Japan?
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by throwaway4good on Thursday February 01, 2024 @10:06AM (#39216750)
It would be fair to include Japan on the list of major semiconductor producers.
Re:EU chip goal 'unrealistic' says ASML CEO by coryfklein on Thursday February 01, 2024 @11:31AM (#39217745)
Yes, but most of them could be right. Given that Taiwan has cornered the market for so long, now that other countries are at least trying you could see a shift like this hypothetical market share change:

Taiwan 80% -> 50%

EU 1% -> 10%

US 1% -> 10%

South Korea 9% -> 15%

China 9% -> 15%

And if 4/5 of them ended up "being right" would indicate that subsidy policies are effective, right?