News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by crote on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:38PM (#39179296)
> The UK police is so massively underfunded

Is it, though? According to the government itself, funding has increased from 12B in 2015 to 17B in 2023[0]. In real terms, the UK police now has more funding than it had pre-austerity (16.5B in 2023 money).

If they don't have the manpower, it isn't due to a lack of money.

[0]: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-funding-for-...

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by switch007 on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:01PM (#39180769)
2015 is a curious date to use.

It just happens to be when about 7 years of funding cuts ended.

Funding in 2009 was £19.3bn, which is £32bn adjusted for inflation to today.

22/23 funding was £24bn (£27bn inflation adjusted)

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by crote on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:03PM (#39185536)
2015 was the earliest date my source used for detailed data. Keep in mind that the pre-austerity "16.5B" figure I gave was for 2010 instead - which is before the funding cuts. I should've probably made that more explicit, yeah, shame I can't edit it anymore.

I can't find the figures for 2009 (this is most likely due to significant changes in the funding structure in 2015, see [1]), but according to [0] the number of police officers was about the same in 2010 as in 2009 - so the austerity cuts clearly only hit in 2011.

Also, my numbers are for England & Wales - because that's what was easily available. I'm not sure where you numbers come from, but they definitely don't match up with the England & Wales ones the UK government provide.

[0]: https://ifs.org.uk/sites/default/files/output_url_files/bn20...

[1]: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by wulfeet on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:54PM (#39179558)
2015 is not pre-austerity.
Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by crote on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:54PM (#39185474)
No, but 2010 is - that's where the 16.5B is from.
Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by walthamstow on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:33PM (#39180285)
Conservatives laid off 20k experienced officers 2010-2017 then hired 20k inexperienced ones 2019-2023.

https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-are-the-co...

During this period the UK population has grown considerably, comparing officers or £ spent per capita is probably more appropriate.

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by doublerabbit on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:59PM (#39179682)
> Is it, though?

It is.

Police cuts here in Scotland are dire. If your house gets broken in to they won't even visit.

Squatting is on the uprise including violent behaviour.

The list is too long to even mention.

https://spf.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/police-budget-...

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by Scoundreller on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:34PM (#39180292)
> If your house gets broken in to they won't even visit

Did they ever accomplish much when they did visit?

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by LAC-Tech on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:15PM (#39179940)
Why do you equate this to police being underfunded?

They just care about other things way more. Like people writing mean things on the internet.

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by gadders on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:28PM (#39180177)
Exactly

https://archive.is/v1YwM

"..the teenager prosecuted for posting the lyrics of a rap song on her Instagram, because the music in question included the N-word. The 18-year-old girl, who has Asperger’s, was given an eight-week curfew and had to wear a tag, though the conviction was later overturned."

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by doublerabbit on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:40PM (#39181360)
I live in Scotland. Do you?

If you don't live here you have no say.

We have a collapsing healthcare, underfunded police force, rapid increase of homeless. Crime increasing.

Not only that I am on my local council so I get the local metrics from my local constabulary.

The police force is spared thin. And if you believe anything the tabloids say about "the police is fine" your a fool to believe so.

If your not from the UK get off your armchair, stop reporting he-say-she-says articles from bias tabloids and see for yourself if your going to argue.

Because I can post them too: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/jan/05/police-still...

This month with crisis in title too.

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by LAC-Tech on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:29PM (#39182051)
The same problems, with the same causes, are happening all over the western world. This idea that we all coincidentally face the same issues, but they're completely unrelated, is farcical. Our elites are globalised, so our response cannot be localised.

We have a collapsing healthcare, underfunded police force, rapid increase of homeless. Crime increasing.

Not unique to Scotland.

The police force is spared thin.

Not unique to Scotland.

If your not from the UK get off your armchair, stop reporting he-say-she-says articles from bias tabloids and see for yourself if your going to argue.

The police receive more funding than they used to. The numbers are there.

And again... this is not unique to Scotland.

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by doublerabbit on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:54PM (#39182434)
The money they received doesn't account for the inflation, system costs et cetera.

They may of got more money but monetary value is a lot less. So yes, an increase in sum, but less in value.

Scotland is more less off than the UK. Scotland is UKs dragging ground and always the first to get cuts, that and wales too.

Re:Viewing Illegal Streams: No Cautions, Fines or Arrests Sa... by jdietrich on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:51PM (#39185849)
Three key issues that I'd raise:

When austerity kicked in, most forces offered redundancy to long-serving officers on good contracts. At the depths of the austerity era, the police practically gave up on investigation - outside of CID and other specialist department, the sheer volume of work forced the police into a purely reactive posture, dealing only with the most urgent and visible problems in the quickest way possible. When funding started to pick back up, they brought new and inexperienced staff into a dysfunctional service. The number of officers isn't down that much compared to pre-austerity levels, but huge amounts of institutional learning was lost.

A lack of resourcing and policy failures in the mental health system meant that the police - the public service of last resort - had to pick up the slack. It's now quite normal for officers to spend a substantial proportion of their time dealing with mental health calls that fundamentally aren't a police matter, or to spend an entire shift waiting to hand over an s.135/s.136 patient to a place of safety.

A lack of funding in the Courts Service and the Criminal Prosecution Service has created a huge bottleneck in the criminal justice pipeline. Cases are taking years to get to court, hearings are being repeatedly re-scheduled and the CPS have tacitly set a much higher bar on the quality of case they're willing to prosecute, all of which has an obvious impact on police resources, recidivism and the wellbeing of victims.

Dysfunction in British policing is part of a much broader dysfunction of the British state as a whole. There's a consistent story across the whole of the public sector - under-resourced services are dealing with an increasingly complex and demanding workload, because vulnerable people are being failed by multiple parts of the state simultaneously. Teachers rarely see students who are [i]just[/i] struggling in school; those kids invariably have home lives that are marred with multiple socioeconomic problems. Doctors spend most of their time treating people who aren't [i]just[/i] ill, but who are also poor and lonely and living in inadequate housing. If you'll forgive the double entendre, it's a death by a thousand cuts - services that don't have the resources to cope with their own workload are having to pick up the pieces for other services, creating a vicious circle of rising demand.