News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by mjburgess on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:42AM (#39174144)
It is discrete insofar as we're talking about sequences of thoughts, ie., reasoning.

What offends the minds of some people is the world might not be like their mind at all. They want always to analogise everything to Reason.

Everything should be countable, everything should be knowable, etc.

Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by omnicognate on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:50AM (#39174185)
That's the "trivial sense" I'm talking about. If we restrict "cognition" to the stuff we know is discrete then trivially it's discrete. But cognition is a hell of a lot more than that.
Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by lupire on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:15AM (#39175837)
I don't see how what we know is discrete.

A word doesn't even have a discrete meaning, except locally in relation to other words.

Saying A = B + C looks discrete, just by hiding any potential non-discreteness inside B and C.

Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by simiones on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:01AM (#39176312)
Discrete here means "non-continuous" - i.e. there is no smooth transition function between ideas/thoughts/rationalizations.

For example, a formal proof is a discrete process: it follows step-wise rules that you can assign natural numbers to (this is the first step, this is the second step, this is the third step). A non-discrete process, a continuous one, would have a smooth transition between these steps, which is hard to even imagine.

While I am not convinced it is correct to say that "human reasoning is discrete", human language is definitely discrete. Words don't blend smoothly into each other. If you don't believe me, try to define a function f:[0,1] -> Words, such that f(0) = "red" and f(1) = "blue" and tell me what is f(sqrt(2)/2), or what is df/dx.

Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by omnicognate on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:40AM (#39176742)
I entirely agree. I wasn't making a statement that "what we know is discrete". I was referring to a particular subset of cognition as "what [i.e. the things that] we know are discrete".

There are aspects of cognition that are discrete: a language contains a finite set of phonemes and words, a human mind is capable of (painfully slowly) carrying out purely symbolic algorithms like those a computer performs, etc. My point was that these things are a small subset of cognition, and most of cognition we have no particular reason to think depends on discreteness, which I think is the same point you're making.

Personally I strongly suspect that the "discrete" aspects of cognition are things that have evolved on top of / within a system that is fundamentally continuous (analogue) in nature.

Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by hnfong on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:28AM (#39178226)
> My point was that these things are a small subset of cognition, and most of cognition we have no particular reason to think depends on discreteness, which I think is the same point you're making.

How do you convince yourself that you have thoughts that cannot be accurately written down no matter how many words you use?

> Personally I strongly suspect that the "discrete" aspects of cognition are things that have evolved on top of / within a system that is fundamentally continuous (analogue) in nature.

How do you tell whether things are really fundamentally continuous, or a really high definition pixel art?

Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by omnicognate on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:37AM (#39178358)
I can't. That's why said "I personally strongly suspect" rather than presenting my partially-informed intuitions as facts.
Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by Almondsetat on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:00AM (#39174233)
what's a sequence of thoughts?
Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by Sardtok on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:56AM (#39175288)
What are thoughts, anyway?
Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf] by lupire on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:06AM (#39175747)
And everything should be... "quantizable"?

https://www.energy.gov/science/doe-explainsquantum-mechanics