Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf]
by hnfong on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:28AM
(#39178226)
> My point was that these things are a small subset of cognition, and most of cognition we have no particular reason to think depends on discreteness, which I think is the same point you're making.
How do you convince yourself that you have thoughts that cannot be accurately written down no matter how many words you use?
> Personally I strongly suspect that the "discrete" aspects of cognition are things that have evolved on top of / within a system that is fundamentally continuous (analogue) in nature.
How do you tell whether things are really fundamentally continuous, or a really high definition pixel art?
Re:Why is Maxwell's theory so hard to understand? (2007) [pdf]
by omnicognate on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:37AM
(#39178358)
I can't. That's why said "I personally strongly suspect" rather than presenting my partially-informed intuitions as facts.
There are aspects of cognition that are discrete: a language contains a finite set of phonemes and words, a human mind is capable of (painfully slowly) carrying out purely symbolic algorithms like those a computer performs, etc. My point was that these things are a small subset of cognition, and most of cognition we have no particular reason to think depends on discreteness, which I think is the same point you're making.
Personally I strongly suspect that the "discrete" aspects of cognition are things that have evolved on top of / within a system that is fundamentally continuous (analogue) in nature.