For example in E = 1/2mv^2, a particle has kinetic energy in virtue of being matter in motion -- it is motion and matter which are basic. Energy is just a system of accounting which tracks motion in the aggregate over time (with kinetic/potential just being the future/past in the accounting) hence why energy conservation is just a temporal invarience.
When making arguments about the physical properties reality has (eg., whether aspects are continuous) you need to be exceptionally clear what your terms mean, and terminology in physics isnt designed for this.
There are no "information saturated volumes", this is a series of abstractions piled on top of each other.
All the words in this area have quite complex formal definitions that are have quite difficult to unpack semantics, you cannot just go around saying "saturated volumes" -- it is this sort of language which breeds cranks, and pop sci does it with abandon.
This entire discussion is a matter of several PhDs, and to be done only well by people with PhDs in the matter (philosophy of physics), or equivalent research. It's not possible to scrap fragaments of what compusci bloggers say and derive much that's likely to be actually correct.
He's also written papers that are basically philosophy of physics. It would be interesting to go over what he has actually said on this topic.
Various Hawking-Bekenstein results about black holes relate to information density, especially, shockingly, that information is proportional to surface area, not volume. This makes perfect sense because a black hole has all its incoming matter and energy sprawled, flattened and red-shifted on its horizon (to a distant observer). It can never export its internal state to the outside world, so you might never expect a volume's-worth of states to be exposed.
The idea was generalized by 't Hooft to the Holographic Principle, for 2D screens encoding the state of 3D volumes on the other side.
However, the full AdS/CFT Correspondence only applies to a certain type of AdS space, not our actual dS space. At the moment, it seems half of theoretical physics doctoral students are trying to extend AdS/CFT to dS space (obviously - strings :) and half of observational astrophysics doctoral students are desperately hoping to show we live in AdS space - LOL
At first I was inclined to agree with you that this is an appeal to authority, with the caveat that such appeals do not always constitute a fallacy. For example, if we both agreed that such a Gisin is an expert whose opinion on this topic can be trusted, then his statements are valid evidence for one way or another.
But then I realised that the very claim being challenged is whether Gisin knows what he's talking about. Floating his credentials and experience feels like a valid contribution. For what it's worth, back in my PhD days I read several of his papers and saw a couple of his talks at conferences, and can confirm he's one of the leading researchers in the field and is particularly thoughtful and careful in his work.
There's a problem for people who think reality can be modelled by computable functions of finite inputs: this makes classical physics non-deterministic, because chaos requires infinite precision for determinism.
So either you go for "reality is deterministic and continuous, and not computable" or "reality is non-deterministic, and discrete, and not computable"
either option in this fork includes properties that offend the minds of the people who want everything to be discrete.
I lean towards a preference for determinism & continuity (via, in QM, superdeterminism) since that's trivial to justify on our best physics
> I argue that there is another theory, similar but different from classical mechanics, with precisely the same set of predictions, though this alternative theory is indeterministic
and in the footnote he describes indeterminism to mean:
> given the present and the laws of nature, there is more than one possible future
Out of curiosity, why do you lean towards superdeterminism and not other deterministic interpretations of QM such as Many-Worlds or Bohmian mechanics?
"Information" is not a physical quantity, and there cant be a "volume" of it. Nor does this have anything to do with real numbers.
It is impossible for there to be any system extended in space and time to "zoom infinitely" into a continuous range and hence record an infinite amount of information. No one claims this, and the formulation of physics (entirely on real numbers) does not require it.
Rather to say, eg., space is continuous, is to say its unbroken. There is no physical quantity which is becoming infinite.