I have given up. Regardless of how much tinkering you do at the OS level - hardened kernel, firewalls, VPNs, jailed apps whatever, the moment you want to make good use of your device doing common things we have come to expect - maps with turn-by-turn navigation that doesn’t suck, ability to write messages to other people where they are, without asking them to install some app first so that we can talk, we are bound to make a deal with the same devil we are fighting - Google, Facebook and other ad tracking machines. There is no point in keeping a hardened OS with Google Maps and WhatsApp installed.
I made my deal with the devil that is Apple that atleast publicly pretends to care about privacy(of course, I have no way to verify that they do).
They only support pixels because Google follows their own standards and doesn't make up shit on the go, so they can lock the bootloader and sign the OS correctly.
It's very usable and far better than an iPhone.
The other part of my argument still stands... Do you use WhatsApp, Instagram etc for communication with friends?
What Google services do you use on your phone? Google Maps, Youtube?
Is there a way to use GrapheneOS on a Pixel device without sacrificing modern life social needs too much?
Update: I thought about my need from phone a little more. I drive a VW Golf. The default infotainment stuff in the car is useless. I use Google Maps via Apple CarPlay to get driving directions in my car. Is there any way to satisfy this need with GrapheneOS without downloading the Playstore (which I consider as Game over and a submission stand to Google) given all the permissions the Playstore needs from the OS.
And don't worry, google services are treated as normal user level apps (1), and are sandboxed like any other user app, so you get perfect compatibility with better privacy and security than your average phone.
Even Android Auto works now, issues only arise when dealing with safety net, googles hardware attestation (2). It mostly only affects bank apps, but in my experience most of them work without issues, however Gpay won't work at all no matter what.
Personally the only worry I have with GrapheneOS is its crazy dev, he said he will step down (3), but he still does a lot (4).
1. https://grapheneos.org/usage#sandboxed-google-play
2. https://grapheneos.org/usage#banking-apps
3. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36089104
4. Just check the commit logs in any of the grapheneOS repos.
For example https://github.com/GrapheneOS/hardened_malloc
I’ll ask a colleague who posted his Pixel 6a for sale to loan it for a few days and try it out.
And that you install Google services through the "apps" app, to get a usable phone. If gps isn't as fast as you expect, you may have to enable Google location services, I had to do that otherwise it almost never works indoors due to lack of support for local wifi scanning.
The Google apps, if you use them, get sandboxed and prevented from having full access to the phone.
It would be great if some sort of libre Pixel clone could be made so that Google is not needed at that level, but that simply doesn't exist yet. Otherwise, all you're doing is trading the devil of Google for some other devil like Samsung.
> There is no point in keeping a hardened OS with Google Maps and WhatsApp installed.
Sandboxed Google Maps using sandboxed non-system Play Services or MicroG on an OS with hardened memory allocation is better than Google Maps on a stock ROM.
Also, the easiest phones to de-google are the google branded ones. I don't use graphene, but all my android phones have been google branded, so they could run a de-googled aosp build.
which model is it? maybe it is already supported. then all you need to do is back up your data and flash it it with an alternative android.
fossify SMS will import your existing messages. Then you can uninstall/disable the Google one in your app settings.
Edit: Damnit, I'm fucked. I can't reinstall through APKMirror because it calls the Google Play Store to finish the installation, and it won't install because I'm not signed into a Google account.
Edit edit: Got Google Messages working again by installing the most recent beta version with APKMirror. I think APKMirror wasn't installing the prior download because it was an earlier version than the one I had disabled. I'll try to keep Fossify set as the default for receipt of texts and only use Google for sending texts and images to email addresses.
The very few 4G/5G keyboard equipped phones are way too expensive for my purposes. And almost all of them are Android smartphones anyway.
I also enjoy relatively high-fidelity images and videos of wildlife (and occasionally things at work that I need to email to others). That's the only bonus from the modern smartphones for me. But even then I would have kept a keyboard feature phone if they had still made them or if 3G hadn't gone away.
If they had made a feature phone with a chiclet keyboard that works on 4G LTE or better I would have bought it instead of the Moto E6 with its replaceable battery. Now that I've bought the Moto E6 I'm keeping it until it breaks or 4G LTE goes away.
I'm a little paranoid on this, sure, but moreso I just actively don't want to be socially connected, and am a bit of a personal AI Luddite. ML is great in the sciences that I work in, but I don't want notifications or recommendations annoyances unless I actively search for them.
I keep my phone unconnected except for cell service, so only get automatic updates every half a year or more whenever I purposefully or accidentally enable the wifi for some purpose. This last happened a week or so ago accidentally and I worried then that my data would be sent to Google despite not having a Google account (the Play Services still automatically updated Messages anyway). I deleted the saved home WiFi connection to prevent access from happening accidentally again, but there will likely come a time when I need to manually connect anyway. Is there a way to shut off these annoying automatic updates and prevent this, or should I just figure out how to switch the messaging app to another SMS/MMS app and say goodbye to my messaging history?