I really wish that everyone that plagues C++ library fragmentation with disabled this, disabled that, just stick to C and leave C++ community alone, so that we can fully enjoy the language as designed.
I guess we need something else everyone can agree upon.
Until then, the computing foundations will kept be being written in C++, until some big name decides to rewrite LLVM, GCC and VC++ into something else.
It is trivial to “guarantee” the underlying memory and is idiomatic for a lot of software that cares about performance or reliability. That is code anyone can write if they care. There isn’t much that can go wrong with memory allocation if you are not allocating memory from the system. No one is requiring C++ developers to poorly duct tape a bunch of rubbish STL together and call it an app. That simply isn’t something you see much in the hardcore systems domains where C++ is the tool of choice.
Somehow, mission-critical software is routinely written in C++ without exceptions and it works just fine. Error states are a normal part of all code, no exceptions required since obviously many languages don’t have them. And no, the alternative is not a segfault. C++ is designed to work just fine without exceptions. The language allows you to bring your own error/exception handling models with minimal overhead, same way you can import alternative ownership/safety models.
An error and an exception are the same concept. Yes, it’s true that not using the std::exception class or any template named “exception” is exception free code. But you’re just lying to yourself. An error check or an assert or verify not <condition> is a “catch”.
In some vanilla app code exceptions are fine, but they introduce nasty edge cases in the kinds of systems code architectures C++ is mostly used for these days. Additionally, they don’t solve an urgent problem in practice that would strongly incentive someone to use them, so it the price of admission is rather steep for minimal benefit.