Is what you want really to make the cargo less valuable in comparison to the wealth of the people near its route?
I suspect that even with full employment, there will still be theft.
I think even in really decent societies like japan, there are still homeless people, and also the yakuza.
The same thing is happening in agriculture, though it’s really under reported.
I don't see any evidence of this.
The article did point out that only 5% of the arrests were organized criminals, but I would expect the organized ones to do more than their fair share of total thefts. I'd also expect them to get arrested less often than their amateur counterparts.
But more importantly, your proposal assumes that eliminating poverty would eliminate crime. That makes intuitive sense, but I don't think it's true. I've heard that many of the package thieves in my neighborhood are middle class people who just steal opportunistically.
> I've heard that [...]
This kinda sums the whole discussion really. We have an article that doesn't really go deep into the issue, and let's everyone come up with their own "all my homies say that XXXX" version of the root causes.
The best answer is probably that it's complicated, poverty plays a role, but so do many other critical factors (e.g. a decent summary of the studies in the field: https://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PA00XGJN.pdf )
It's definitely anecdotal. But I think it justifies my skepticism of the claim that eliminating poverty would "eliminate the vast majority of thefts..." The parent comment didn't provide any data to support that thesis, and it doesn't align with my experiences.
> The best answer is probably that it's complicated, poverty plays a role, but so do many other critical factors
Yes, exactly. But that's what I'm arguing: poverty isn't the only factor in property crime. And while it's nice to imagine a world in which poverty doesn't exist, I think that cultural factor combined with inequality and opportunism will cause theft to remain.
I think "give people something to lose" is an underused and underrated crime deterrent.
By fix you mean imprison those who happen to commit crimes? And treat them harshly enough while in prison to recondition their behaviour? Works pretty well in Japan. The stats speak for themselves, and I noticed people don't even lock their bikes when I visited Tokyo.
All of the above is far, far cheaper than any of the numerous, very costly, and abysmally failing social programs we have wasted our money on over the last decades, uselessly trying to rehabilitate mentally ill drug addicts. Can we accept that there is a group of people on whom the carrot is ineffective?
Also, there is no such thing as a society without margins, they're inherent to the normal distribution.
Life in Japanese prison is highly regimented, expectations of correct behaviour are high, and inmates are not allowed to freely interact and form a prison culture. This is in contrast to the US, where prison is effectively crime university. There are also effective post-correctional structures, eg. hiring discrimination against convicts isn't legal.
I'm arguing that Japan is a model of penal efficiency, getting a lot more bang for penal system buck, not that their system is most effective in absolute terms.
Edit: Japan spends ~14 USD per prisoner per day[1] and the US spends ~110 USD[2].
1. https://www.moj.go.jp/content/001409459.pdf
2. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/09/22/2023-20...
From what I hear, it might have a little bit to do with societal expectations (NOT resulting from fear of imprisonment, btw), underreporting, it being easier to keep things under control than get them under control, and near full employment, among other things.
We have systematically underfunded social programs and evaluated their costs and benefits based on everything but their actual holistic effectiveness. Rehabilitation? Do you have any idea how quaint the idea of real rehabilitation is, at an actual prison?
Sorry, but removing all the bad guys and thus leaving behind only good guys doesn't work. Never has, never will, not least because it's based on incorrect assumptions. (And I don't even disagree that time and effort get wasted on trying to change people who aren't going to change. Especially not with the situation we leave them in.)
This seems pretty easily and cheaply fixable. Information access is nearly free, and all that's required is sufficient discipline and structure provided by prison staff.
> removing all the bad guys and thus leaving behind only good guys doesn't work
Isn't that the entire idea of the penal model? The primary purpose of imprisoning people is to keep the rest of us safe from them (incapacitation). A tiny minority of people commit most crime (especially violent crime), and imprisoning them for long terms does in fact reduce the crime rate[1]. As we seem to agree (and research supports), other interventions are ineffective on many of these people.
Per my other comment[2], I think we can do this much more cheaply than we do, and with much better (or at least equivalent) outcomes. I also recommend this documentary[3], for a deeper look at the Japanese penal system. It tries to take a critical perspective, but my neck is just about sore from nodding along in agreement with Japanese practices.
1. F E Zimring, G Hawkins (1995). Incapacitation: Penal Confinement and the Restraint of Crime.
> your theory assumes that people are always at their 100% and thus can work to improve their lot
It's not obvious to me at all that a person needs to be at "100%" to improve their lot (and avoid criminality). I would never get out of bed if that was the case.
The biggest problem is of course, societal. One anecdote from an anti-theft taskforce in the article showed that less than 5% of the thefts were prepretrated by organized groups, and the other 95% were from "passers-by or unhoused people living near the tracks in R.V.s or makeshift structures".
People on the margins of society, who see an opportunity to make some money.
Ideally, we'd fix the problem of unhoused people on the margins of society and we'd eliminate the vast majority of thefts like this.
But of course, that's a much harder problem to solve.
Much easier, then, to respond with bigger locks, and more security cameras, and GPS trackers and more security guards in vulnerable hotspots.
While those measures might work (to an extent) to solve the immediate problem, they don't work to make the society that I'd like to live in. I'd much rather live in a more equitable society that works to eliminate homelessness, and the conditions that lead to this type of theft, then one that just prevents it with punatitive measures and thorough enforcement.