News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by jmcqk6 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:12AM (#39105274)
Check out the work of Ilya Prigogine - he won a Nobel prize in the 70's for his work on self-organizing complexity. There is a selection force in the universe for increasing complexity, being driven by the dissipation of energy. When you have systems in non-equilibrium, there is a strong pressure to explore the possibility space to find ever more efficient ways to dissipate energy.

A bacteria the size of a grain of sand dissipates much, much more energy than the grain of sand, and so there is a very strong "preference" for bacteria in this regard.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by forinti on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:00PM (#39106060)
The Sun outputs 3.9 x 10^26W, but it weighs ~10^30kg, so that would mean 10^-4W/kg.

Human beings are closer to 1W/kg at rest.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by jmcqk6 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:22PM (#39106371)
Wow, that's a great way of describing this! Definitely noted for future use.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by epistasis on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:45PM (#39108675)
Really brings up the difference between the energy density of the fusion reaction and the energy density of fusion plus the confinement system to enable the reaction!
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by anticensor on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:51PM (#39110448)
Hmm, then the challenge is to find a more efficient confinement for a fusion reaction.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by adrianN on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:14PM (#39106257)
Now do a lump of plutonium.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by conesus on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:19PM (#39106330)
How did that lump of plutonium become a lump? That part wasn’t natural.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by mapreduce on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:50PM (#39106858)
"How did that lump of plutonium become a lump? That part wasn’t natural."

Allow me to become a little philosophical but since human beings which are product of nature made plutonium, isn't the making of plutonium natural too?

I mean everything that is happening in this universe is natural!

I know the general usage of the words "artificial" for human-made and "natural" for everything else. But when we are talking at the grand scale of life and universe I think a human-made plutonium is as natural as bee-made honey.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:11PM (#39107186)
I love debating this with people but ultimately it's just playing games with semantics. The notion of artificial x natural is very recent and very localized. Some cultures would differentiate raw from cooked in a similar sense. But it's like talking about what is really green vs what is really blue. Completely circular since it depends on the definitions of the terms.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by jonhohle on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:43PM (#39107700)
It's easily extendable to the animal world as well. Is a nest created by a bird or a den created by one of various mammals natural or artificial? Is a nest made by mice in my garage from synthetic fabrics, flexible plastics, and whatever plant matter it can find natural or synthetic?

My wife was recently asked to make a meal for someone who didn't eat "processed" foods. What level of manipulation needs to happen before a food is "processed"? Can beans or rice be dried and put in a bag? Can chicken broth be used if it's homemade, but the chicken came from a commercial farm? Or is extracting broth from a chicken processing it?

I've increasingly noticed many sub-cultures adopting odd definitions and interpretations of commonly used language with the expectation that everyone who interacts with their group understand their dialects. It's not really jargon or vernacular since the words are common to the language, just used to mean something different than the general population would understand. Similarly, artificial is now assumed to mean bad and natural good, when neither ascribe value by definition or in practice.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:03PM (#39108003)
You could approach the language problem like that as well. Before imperial efforts in recent centuries to normalize languages in certain territories, there was no Standard French or German or Italian. Vocabulary and accents changed slowly across the landscape, following geography - places isolated diverged and places integrated converged. Migration, trade and conquest added layers of complexity to this variation.

But your idea that people are failing to use Standard English and creating language subcultures around peculiar meanings of artificial/processed/chemical vs natural/homemade/organic is itself based on a very artificial distribution of language.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by achierius on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:08PM (#39107150)
Perhaps a better phrase to have used would have been "not prior to a complex system" -- as the lump of plutonium exists only because of a complex system doing its thing, it should be considered a consequence of the complex system rather than an alternative.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by InitialLastName on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:34PM (#39110218)
To attempt to pedantically clarify, is "exists only because of a complex system doing its thing" not true of basically any pure lump of material that exists?

To me, the actions of stars fusing heavy atoms and then those atoms ending up in lumps of material somewhere sounds like a pretty complex system doing its thing.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by forinti on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:26PM (#39106454)
Life is a great entropy accelerator.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:57PM (#39107911)
compared to a black hole though?
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by forinti on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:31PM (#39108453)
It might be too soon to tell. We might start creating them ourselves.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bell-cot on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:54PM (#39107881)
Which isotope? It makes quite a difference, and there's no "naturally occurring" with Pu.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by notfed on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:49PM (#39108749)
This is enlightening. Has anyone posted some kind of comparison table somewhere?
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by evanb on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:06PM (#39109837)
The sun's power density is approximately the same as compost.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by drewrv on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:27PM (#39110107)
Can you elaborate on that or drop a link that explains more?
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by mr_toad on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:06PM (#39111248)
The rate of fusion in the Suns core is actually very slow and gram for gram it is not producing much energy. But the core of the Sun is well insulated by the vast bulk of itself, so even a slow release of energy builds up to extreme temperatures.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun#Structure_and_fusion

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:46PM (#39110366)
Live/fresh compost creates heat as a byproduct of cellular metabolism during decomposition. I assume this is is using thermal output of this compost as a measure of energy.

What more do you want to know.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by evanb on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:15AM (#39113890)
Here's a decent stackexchange discussion: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/370899/suns-powe...
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by worldsayshi on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:02PM (#39112284)
So does that mean that making a fusion reactor makes as much sense as building a containment vessel for a compost reactor?
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by lajy on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @09:16PM (#39112813)
Stars have to have enough mass to have enough gravity to start and sustain a nuclear reaction that constantly blasts energy out in all directions. This limits just how energy-dense they can get. What they lack there, they make up for in size and lifespan.

We can make sustained nuclear reactions in much less space using engineered pressure instead of gravity, so that skews the energy density ratio.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bmitc on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @10:58PM (#39113454)
The Sun uses gravity, due to its mass, for fusion containment. Fusion reactors on Earth use electromagnetic containment.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by hermitcrab on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:37AM (#39114648)
Fusion only happens in the Sun due to incredibly rare quantum tunnelling events. That is why the sun can burn for billions of years. It takes a long time for the energy generated to reach the surface and escape, that is why the sun has a high temperature.

IIRC fusion reactors on earth use magnetic confinement to raise the temperature much higher than the sun's interior for a much higher rate of fusion reactions. I'm sure someone will be along to correct me if I got that wrong. ;0)

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by s1artibartfast on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:35PM (#39110222)
The average American also outputs about 125W/kg if you include our technology, and not metabolism.

US Primary energy consumption = 30 Trillion Kwh/ year [1]

30 Trillion Kwh/ year / 8760 hrs = 3.3×10^12 W (watts)

3.3×10^12 W (watts)/ 330million = 10 kW/ person

10 kW/ person / 80kg = 125 W/kg

https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/us-energy-facts/

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by echelon on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:42PM (#39110324)
So we really are batteries for the Matrix.

Joking aside, this comparison is really beautiful.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by calf on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:29PM (#39106517)
That is mind blowing! It reminds me of Conway and Wolfram's automata theories although perhaps those models did not emphasize the energy aspect of it.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by WaxProlix on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:24PM (#39106426)
So we're all agents of Entropy, spinning our circles until we die all in the service of heat death? I don't like it!
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:16PM (#39107266)
I don't understand this view at all. We are what we are. Entropy is a concept in our mind and heat death is a very particular phenomenon that depends on the systems experiencing it being very specifically defined in ways that the Universe cannot be.

We are. Descartes had the right idea. The experience of consciousness is irreducible. To say "we are atoms thinking" and variations thereof is utterly meaningless. All words and concepts used for such word play is dependent on the experience of human consciousness. They don't exist independently. Consciousness is the only thing we can posit that has independent existence. Everything else is just a concept created by a conscious being.

It's like the tree falling in the forest with no one to hear it. A universe without consciousness experiencing it really exists? Existence is a property of consciousness. We can't conceive of things that are not experienced, by definition. Even if we imagine a dead universe with just energy and no consciousness, that is an image that exists inside of a conscious mind.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by dvt on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:29PM (#39107482)
> Existence is a property of consciousness.

Kant would vehemently disagree. Not that I'm a Kantian, but he makes some pretty good points. So I think there's a lot of work here that needs to be done to make your argument stronger.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by wolvesechoes on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:15PM (#39108186)
> Not that I'm a Kantian, but he makes some pretty good points

It is even debatable what points he really made. As always in philosophy.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by dvt on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:26PM (#39111453)
I'd say that existence not being a predicate of any object is kind of non-debatable :)
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by wolvesechoes on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:06AM (#39115252)
It is, actually. Kant differentiates between "real predicates" and "logical predicates", and only states that existence doesn't belong to the first category, because it "doesn't enhance the concept". The whole distinction is quite unclear, and Kant's claims can be interpreted in multiple ways, as people do in some publications.

Actually this famous slogan that "existence is not a predicate" is closer to proposals of Russell and Quine.

Disclaimer: quoted phrases from Kant may not match exactly what you can find in English translations. I know Kant from Polish translations, so I improvised a bit.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:36PM (#39107585)
I'm not into winning debates. I just find interesting that conscious beings think they can imagine the absence of consciousness. For us consciousness is the fundamental reality.

Furthermore I find the verbosity of German philosophy nearly unbearable, to be honest.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by zoogeny on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:48PM (#39110393)
You say: "We can't conceive of things that are not experienced, by definition"

I mean, you probably don't even realize that this view is influenced by Kant. You are giving a very poor retread of 200+ year old German idealism.

For example, from the Wikipedia article on Critique of Pure Reason [1], Kant's major work: In the preface to the first edition, Kant explains that by a "critique of pure reason" he means a critique "of the faculty of reason in general, in respect of all knowledge after which it may strive independently of all experience"

I think it is fair to criticize his prose but it isn't like you don't have access to well over 200 years of commentary and follow-ups to one of the most famous and important philosophers within the Western tradition. For a gentle introduction I suggest this video [2] (42 minutes) where Geoffrey Warnock (at the time the Vice Chancellor at Oxford) provides an overview of Kant's ideas.

It is also fair to disagree with Kant, but it is pretty obvious when you are talking about the subject he dominates while having no experience with his work. The reason he is so famous is that he had very compelling things to say on this very subject.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critique_of_Pure_Reason

2. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlEMkAkGS1I

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:56AM (#39114775)
It's a fairly narrow view if you think I shouldn't philosophize unless I conform in full to all YOU have read.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by zoogeny on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:17PM (#39119857)
I'm not telling you what you should or shouldn't do. I'm pointing out a few facts including that your viewpoint is well over 200 years old, that specifically Kant addressed it and influenced the entire discussion around it, that it is clear you haven't considered his or any other philosophers rebuttal to it.

To give an example, it would be like you were talking about gravity and saying that Newton was right. Then someone mentions Einstein, and you respond that you couldn't be bothered understanding the general theory of relativity because the math is too hard.

I mean, no one is saying you should read Einstein, just that Einstein had some things to add to the ideas of gravity that are worth considering. And if you want any theory of gravity that you have baked up on your own to be taken seriously, you will find that others will expect you to show some familiarity with his theories. And further, there is a wealth of material on his theories that does not require you to engage directly with the esoteric math.

The same is true about Kant (although, to be fair this is philosophy and not physics, so he didn't supplant Descartes in the same way Einstein did Newton). He added explicitly to the question about the bounds of knowledge with respect to experience. So if you are making claims about that subject then it is not unreasonable to expect that you have at least some familiarity with his contribution.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:31PM (#39120035)
> So I think there's a lot of work here that needs to be done to make your argument stronger.

> You are giving a very poor retread of 200+ year old German idealism.

You kept putting me down because my ideas don't jibe with your readings. Now you're comparing philosophy with physics.

I am trying stay away from such pedantic bibliographic review. You keep appealing to authority to minimize my contributions. This is why I didn't want to go down this road. Thanks for dragging me.

> your viewpoint is well over 200 years old

Hate to break this to you but the ideas I'm talking about are well over 3000 years old. Kant et al are a cul de sac in this tradition.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by zoogeny on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @12:59PM (#39120475)
> Kant et al are a cul de sac in this tradition.

Perhaps, yet how would you know if you refuse to engage with it?

I'm not sure how to respond when someone insists on remaining ignorant of alternative viewpoints and then suggests that any attempt to point out relevant arguments against their position is victimizing them.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:27AM (#39141002)
So refusing to engage with you and your readings is refusing to engage at all with the subject and insisting on ignorance?

I saw the self importance a mile away and I said I wanted none of it. Like I said, I dislike German philosophers verbosity and I'm getting to dislike its fans' self importance.

edit: you've called my ideas half baked, you've called me ignorant. it's pretty clear to me now you just wanted to play vocabulary ping pong with dead man's ideas to feel smart. I pretty much intuited it, and regretted every engagement with you so far.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by saiya-jin on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:30AM (#39119282)
> A universe without consciousness experiencing it really exists?

As long as we don't discover something truly novel this is how reality of this universe looked like before we came since its creation. And it fared just fine.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by namaria on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:47AM (#39119504)
> since its creation

Interesting turn of phrase about a supposed reality deprived of consciousness. Created.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by mordechai9000 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:14PM (#39107240)
As someone said about thermodynamics: You can't win, you can't break even, and you must play the game. (Source unknown)
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by mrkstu on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:14AM (#39105311)
Is there already a theory for life->greater complexity similar to that of entropy in physics? It seems just as inexorable.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by pizza on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:45AM (#39105829)
You might really like the short book What is Life? by Schrödinger, it delves into exactly that.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bmitc on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:22AM (#39105432)
The theory is that they are one in the same, or better to say that entropy is the process that drives life. In that, life grows in complexity in order to dissipate heat (i.e., increase entropy) more efficiently.

Just look at Earth. Life is incredibly complex but is ultimately driving everything towards dust.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by lioeters on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:25PM (#39106446)
> entropy is the process that drives life

Depending on how you look at it, life is driven by the opposite of entropy. Schrödinger in his book, What is Life?, calls it "negative entropy" or even "free energy".

> In the 1944 book What is Life?, Austrian physicist Erwin Schrödinger, who in 1933 had won the Nobel Prize in Physics, theorized that life – contrary to the general tendency dictated by the second law of thermodynamics, which states that the entropy of an isolated system tends to increase – decreases or keeps constant its entropy by feeding on negative entropy.

> The problem of organization in living systems increasing despite the second law is known as the Schrödinger paradox. This, Schrödinger argues, is what differentiates life from other forms of the organization of matter.

> Schrödinger asked the question: "How does the living organism avoid decay?" The obvious answer is: "By eating, drinking, breathing and (in the case of plants) assimilating." While energy from nutrients is necessary to sustain an organism's order, Schrödinger also presciently postulated the existence of other molecules equally necessary for creating the order observed in living organisms:

> "An organism's astonishing gift of concentrating a stream of order on itself and thus escaping the decay into atomic chaos – of drinking orderliness from a suitable environment – seems to be connected with the presence of the aperiodic solids..." We now know that this "aperiodic" crystal is DNA, and that its irregular arrangement is a form of information.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropy_and_life#Negative_entr...

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bmitc on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:40PM (#39109441)
I don't think you understand my point or what Schrodinger wrote. The Wikipedia synopsis of Schrodinger is unlikely to be accurate.

https://www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-thermodynamics-theory-o...

https://www.bbvaopenmind.com/en/science/leading-figures/ilya...

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by lioeters on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:42PM (#39110311)
Thank you, I'm familiar with the work of Ilya Prigogine, and the first linked article is one of my favorites that I've read several times. The relationship between life and entropy is a fascinating topic for sure.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bmitc on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:26PM (#39111977)
It seems we've talked at each other then, haha.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by lioeters on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:32PM (#39120916)
Oh I didn't notice you were getting downvoted up there in the parent comment, it wasn't me! :)

Anyway, I'm now going back to read Prigogine's book, Order Out of Chaos. It's also brought me around to think and study more about self-organization and emergent properties of complex systems.

About "A New Physics Theory of Life", and the idea that life exists because "the law of increasing entropy drives matter to acquire lifelike physical properties".. I see this is what you meant by "entropy is the process that drives life".

> Besides self-replication, greater structural organization is another means by which strongly driven systems ramp up their ability to dissipate energy. Thus, England argues that under certain conditions, matter will spontaneously self-organize.

Re-reading the article, I'm struck by how entropy and organization are, seemingly paradoxically, two sides of the same coin. It feels like there's something profound there, some principle that explains many phenomena at different scales all at once.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by knome on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:58AM (#39106034)
>life grows in complexity in order to dissipate heat

This seems silly on the level of the anthropic principle.

It's like claiming a calculator exists to use up electricity.

We're eddies in the flow of energy from high to low entropy because it's free energy.

We create more entropy in capturing energy than we capture because it's impossible not to.

There's no purpose for life there. It's just where life lives.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by keithwhor on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:18PM (#39106309)
> It's like claiming a calculator exists to use up electricity.

sighs in bitcoin

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by uoaei on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:35PM (#39106629)
There is a minor pedantic point to make that akshually heat dissipation carves channels of energy flow that look to us like life rather than the causality going in the other direction.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by manmal on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:54PM (#39106910)
Very interesting. Do you have an intuition for why there is selection pressure towards energy dissipation?
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by jmcqk6 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:12PM (#39107209)
My current intuition goes something like this:

Energy MUST flow. No matter how energy is captured and stored, there is a pressure for it to continue moving.

The movement of energy means that matter is always moving, and new configurations are always being "discovered."

Some configurations allow for energy to flow more easily, and when one of those configurations is "discovered" the movement of energy keeps that configuration in place. I think it's literally a strange attractor from chaos theory.

Areas of stable energy flow create correlations across space time that allow for more complex correlations to emerge.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by rileyphone on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:49PM (#39108742)
Here’s an interesting network-focused view as to why that might be: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspb.2012.286...
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by sydbarrett74 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:06PM (#39109828)
Sorry if this question is answered elsewhere in this post's replies, but would you say that matter can be viewed as 'captured' energy, or energy at rest?
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by nyssos on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:48PM (#39110401)
> matter can be viewed as 'captured' energy, or energy at rest?

No, matter isn't 'captured' energy any more than it's 'captured' mass or momentum. Energy is a quantity, not a substance.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:00PM (#39111190)
Energy is a behavior, or alternatively a probability.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:59PM (#39111185)
Tweak your intuition: energy IS motion. When things are not moving, there is no energy. When there is energy, things are moving.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by jmcqk6 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:28PM (#39111476)
How would you describe a rock sitting on the top of a mountain? It is not moving relative to the matter around it, but it certainly contains quite a bit of energy, in a variety of different forms.

I am trying to recognize that even in that rock, energy is dissipating in multiple ways, and any number of different events can lead to it dissipating in different ways.

I suppose you can say that the individual atoms composing the rock are moving, but are those movements connected to the potential energy it has by virtue of being far from the relative minimum in a gravity well?

That rock could fall down the mountain mostly intact - a highly energetic event, compared to being eroded away chemically by rain over millennia.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:50PM (#39111648)
potential energy is. IMO, largely a pedagogical tool. it's an explanatory position, rather than a thing.

the rock, does, obviously "contain" energy thanks to e=mc2. but the notion that the rock is energetically in a different state as it sits on top of the mountain that when it sits at the bottom never sat well with me in high school, and it still doesn't, 45 years later.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by nerdbert on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:37PM (#39112083)
It takes energy to move a rock to the top of a mountain, and you can get some of that energy back (minus friction etc) if you let it roll down. So it's got something.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by spiralx on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:02AM (#39116756)
I mean any type of energy is just as intangible as potential energy, so I don't see that the energy stored by doing work (i.e. interacting with one four forces) is that different to the idea of energy stored by being in motion. You never measure "energy" directly after all, but it's a useful abstraction - after all, everything in science is an explanatory position.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:17PM (#39121478)
Yes, everything in an explanatory position. That's precisely the point I was trying to get to.

I just happen to consider the explanation that a rock sitting on top of a mountain having "potential energy" to be relatively content free.

There's always a tension in physics (or has been for a couple of centuries or so) between force-based explanation and energy-based explanation.The force-based explanation (gravity) of why the rock might move downhill makes vastly more sense to me than the notion that it has "potential energy". However, the force-based explanation is not always clearly the right one either.

Also, I wasn't referring to "the idea of energy stored by being in motion". This is precisely the hangup that trips up so many. An object doesn't have energy because it is moving. And it doesn't move because it has energy. The motion and the energy are the same thing, just two different ways of talking about the same thing. The distinction matters because the way we've developed the semantics of "motion" and "energy" in physics means that, for example, "motion" is not something that is transferred between objects, but "energy" is.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by pizza on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @08:53PM (#39112657)
A static point mass in a gravitational field is already at its lowest energy state (a literal ground state if you will). It can only really do one thing, which is to stay. The logarithm of the number of states then is zero. So in some sense it cannot encode information at all. In fact I think more generally speaking, things that are at a global minimum of energy level cannot really be used to encode information (unless you have a mechanism to add entropy w/o increasing energy), because they have one state, and the log of the number of states then gives you zero bits. Probably another way to look at the idea that gravitational potential path-independence means memorylessness means devoid of bits of information.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by csomar on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @10:32PM (#39113283)
The rock is continuously applying pressure to the mountain. That's why we have round planets and not huge random looking rocks. On an atomic level, the atoms themselves are full of action, though that will take a really long time to see the consequences of that.

ps: I subscribe to the heat death theory.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by Wissenschafter on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:10AM (#39119037)
That rock is moving though, at c through time.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:03PM (#39111222)
Then energy is relative? An object is 'stationary' in space, a comet comes along and hits it. The comet has energy.

OR the comet is just sitting there, 'stationary', the object hits it. Not the object has energy.

There's no total energy to a system, except calculated from some point of view?

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @06:15PM (#39111341)
energy is a term we use that describes the probability for some unit of matter to be in a different state at time T' than it was at time T.

if you consider the state to include position - relative to a frame of view - then energy describes (at least in part) the likelihood that the position at time T' is different than at time T

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by hughesjj on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @01:47PM (#39107761)
I love it. Was susskind inspired by this at all with his complexity=action (duality) [1] hypothesis?

Theres a bunch of lectures of him on YouTube going off about how complexity increases asymptotically greater than entropy in a black hole, but I need to refresh myself on the lecture. Disclosure: I'm an idiot, and may be spewing nonsense

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CA-duality

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by jamesblonde on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:18PM (#39108228)
You forgot to mention that Prigogine's model includes a system boundary. Within the system, the 2nd law of thermodynamics no longer holds - the system does not tend towards entropy, as the system ingests energy and exports entropy.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @05:58PM (#39111174)
Put in Prigogine's terms: the system is not at, and does not reach, equilibrium (the state that most other chemical science tends to assume).
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bloopernova on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @03:05PM (#39108973)
I absolutely adore the simplicity behind this: Energy must balance, so it flows from high concentrations to lower concentrations. Things that help that flow are selected for.

From that springs everything we are. Utterly amazing to me that from a gradient plus some random chemicals plus time equals humans, sex, violence, loss, birth, love, games, music, and so much more.

All just to help the earth cool down a little bit faster.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by tsunamifury on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:07PM (#39109851)
Absolutely none of this follows
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by friend_and_foe on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:51AM (#39114410)
It doesn't help the earth cool down faster, it actually traps energy for longer in metabolic processes. But it does red shift it. The film of muck on the surface that we call life lowers the planet's albedo and the radiation that shines out of it is of a longer wavelength than if it were just reflected.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by kaashif on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @02:32AM (#39114617)
> Things that help that flow are selected for.

I don't get this part, why does this follow?

Why would life that transfers heat faster get selected for? This seems backwards to me: in reality it seems like life that is more capable or more adapted reproduces more, and that results in more heat moving around most of the time.

But progress can go backwards, if there were a nuclear war this would reduce heat transfer.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by ajuc on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @04:20PM (#39110012)
So where's the bacteria outcompeting moon dust?

Theories which make life inevitable are inherently shaky because we have 1 sample.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by nerdbert on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @07:39PM (#39112096)
You can't have theories without life to conceive of them, so in fact life is inevitable under any theory.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by ajuc on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:52AM (#39115151)
That's just antrophic principle, no need for any selection pressure or any particular theory at all. That's why all of them are shaky.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bmitc on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:04PM (#39113491)
Where are the conditions for life on the Moon? You can't have something if the conditions to form it are missing. Your question is equivalent to asking why stars don't form outside dust clouds.
Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by ajuc on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:51AM (#39115147)
There are ways for the matter on the moon to dissipate energy faster than moon dust. We could build a moon base for example. It doesn't do it.

In fact as far as we know - most of the space in the universe is doing the dissipation in a very inefficient way.

Which means the theory that it will do it simply because of the "selection pressure" is empirically wrong.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by bmitc on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:11AM (#39119056)
> Which means the theory that it will do it simply because of the "selection pressure" is empirically wrong.

Again, this is not true. We have empirical evidence that life on Earth began as soon as it could. And the universe doesn't spontaneously do things as you're wishing it to do to support your argument.

> Let's say a huge asteroid sterilized Earth 100 years ago. What could the life do to outcompete that?

That doesn't negate anything. Entropy increases over time. Given the various conditions available in the universe, its processes follow that directive relevant to their conditions.

Re:Is the emergence of life an expected phase transition in ... by ajuc on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:53AM (#39119571)
> And the universe doesn't spontaneously do things as you're wishing it to do to support your argument.

That's the whole point. The theory reduces to "if conditions are right life will happen" which moves the whole predictive power to the "conditions are right" and leaves the theory with 0 value added.