News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by dreamcompiler on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:54AM (#39090098)
It's going to be very difficult to avoid the 737 MAX going forward. Airlines love these planes because they save fuel and Boeing has a waiting list for them out to 2030. AFAIK you cannot order a new 737 from Boeing that is not a MAX.

The only viable solution is an independent safety board (paid for out of Boeing profits) that supervises every aspect of design and production at Boeing and its contractors until Boeing learns how to build safe airplanes again.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by jmward01 on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:17AM (#39090328)
Comparing the 737 max (all variants) to nearly any other passenger transport shows that it is safe and we are seeing why in real time. An issue happened which correctly caused immediate grounding and inspections followed by an in-depth review and likely corrective action both to the issue and the practices that created it. Implying it isn't safe is continuing to feed a false narrative that encourages unreasonable fear of flying and is holding aviation back.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by OvbiousError on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:39AM (#39090592)
Except if part of the wall goes flying off you mean?
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by hedora on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:31AM (#39091393)
Or if the still-not-redundant air speed sensor fails.

There’s also the recent report that parts of the tail wing were not properly torqued, and they’re internally falling apart.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by dghlsakjg on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:38PM (#39093426)
Do you mean the AoA sensor?

There have always been at least three airspeed pitots on every 737 model.

Also, as of 2022, there are 2 physical sensors and a computed value from alternate sources for AoA on all flying MAX planes

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by NikkiA on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:09PM (#39099115)
The 737 has had an empennage assembly problem since the 737-classics, every few years boeing promises they've tightened QA and it's solved, then it happens again.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by swasheck on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:32AM (#39091404)
it does seem like there's been an uptick in "incidents" involving boeing planes, in particular, and maybe that's because of the fallout of the merger between boeing and md (https://qz.com/1776080/how-the-mcdonnell-douglas-boeing-merg...), and even then i'm not sure if that's _statistically_ accurate. this does not, however, invalidate the CP premise that it's generally safe to fly, even on the Max series and that is largely because this part of the process is working (grounding, checking, remediating) even if the development and manufacturing processes have failed.

however, i'll also agree with you that being subject to the effects of iterative improvement is uncomfortable in the air transport context.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by turquoisevar on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:52PM (#39092727)
I’ve said this before, and I’ll repeat it: yes, flying is statistically safer than other forms of transport to the point that you’re more likely to die on your way to the airport than on a flight.

BUT that knowledge shouldn’t be used to become complacent to the point that we let things slip, nor should it be used to ignore other indicators that could signal a negative trend.

“And we are seeing why in real time” only plays into that complacency because it suggests that the post-incident acts are the goal, while it used to be that they’re means to a goal, the goal being that they’re not needed in the first place.

In particular, with the door plug, the issue is that they go against best practices that have been established yesteryear (i.e., making them bigger than the hole and plugging from the inside to leverage cabin pressure instead of working against cabin pressure) and that’s aside from the knowledge both inside Boeing and supplier Spirit AeroSystem of quality issues.

On a macro level, there’s a more considerable erosion of aviation safety at play, however, especially in the US. This erosion has only marginally led to increased deaths (albeit preventable) but has significantly increased the level of near-catastrophic events. This, in my humble opinion, is an essential signal in terms of potential future fatalities.

I’m talking about:

- things at the manufacturer level, of which Boeing with their 737 MAX fulfills an emblematic role (e.g., MCAS, door plug, loose bolts, etc); - regulators’ lack of proper enforcement (e.g., FAA being extremely hesitant to ground planes after the MCAS incidents, making them one of the last ones to do so, FAA being extremely deferential in the certification process, allowing Boeing to essentially self-certify most of the essential stuff, if not outright granting them waivers or allowing Boeing to omit information about specific systems from flight manuals); - lacks regulation on crew hours, leading to fatigued crew; - overworked and understaffed ATC; - “safe enough” mentality when it comes to protocols at and around airports to increase the number of movements

The list goes on and on. The common denominator? Money.

It’s cheaper and more expeditious to let Boeing evade proper certification and to let them sell a range of different models under the same type certification.

It’s better for the economy not to ground planes made by America’s darling manufacturer.

It’s cheaper for American airlines to only count the hours the planes’ doors are closed as work hours and to not be too strict with mandatory rest requirements.

It’s cheaper to hire contractors to do ATC and to have one person do a job that would be safer to split amongst 3, especially when it costs more to attract two more people.

It’s cheaper to cram more planes onto a runway than to spread them out; it also makes more money for airlines and airports. So it’s better to have pilots do a visual approach and visual separation; not only does this unload some of the responsibility to the pilots, freeing up ATC resources, but it also requires less separation, which means more movements at the airport. This practice has the blessing of the FAA, by the way, this is straight from the FAA Safety Alert For Operators SAFO 21005[0]. IFALPA, in turn, released a bulletin to highlight how the US practice isn’t in line with ICAO practices and to advise non-US pilots on how to handle this[1].

On their own, none of these might immediately lead to a noticeable effect in aviation safety, but combined, they most certainly do.

For every incident that makes headlines, ten never make it into mainstream news, which hides the significant uptick in near-catastrophic events[2].

So yes, while statically aviation is a safe mode of transport, it doesn’t help to proclaim that “there’s nothing to see here folks, everything is super safe.”

It’s a miracle nobody died in this door plug incident, a straight-up miracle, and not the result of some grand safety design.

Any attempt to paint it as other than a miracle is just confirmation bias.

0: https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/SAFO21005_0.pdf

1: https://ops.group/blog/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/21atsbl04-...

2: https://sfist.com/2023/08/21/close-calls-on-sfo-runways-are-...

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by dmix on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:32PM (#39096468)
I didn't downvote you but it's easy to blame money/greed than the overt encouragememt and endorsement of Boeing's domestic monopoly by a litany of power players both in gov and most importantly, private players directly feeding into gov / other major corporate decision making.

Boeing gets to do what it wants (like bypassing approval processes) because it's the only player in town. Even after the worst possible QC embarassement, and a massive financial loss few other companies could eat, they still have lots of orders for MAX because of that near monopoly. Largely supported by their OTHET convienient near monopoly in a few markets the US gov also actively encourages, to an even worse degree.

Airbus might be good competition in a narrow sense but only because having one is worse than just two. There should have been market players getting a bunch of capital to compete with them long ago but I guess there are market and regulatory barriers that have made that untenable.

The failures, blatant regulatory capture, and complete lack of real alternatives can be hand waved by reducing it to "money" (to a few) but if anything theres a lot more money to be made if the US had a wide selection of better planes, that aren't grounded for 2yrs, with greater global market demand and old planes getting replaced sooner by much faster by more powerful and enfficent ones.

We as a society (EU too) give space, national defence, and aeronautics basically an unchecked green light for this type of behaviour constantly for so thin rationale about domestic security needs and "but it's complicated and expensive", as if America and the west can't do better.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by turquoisevar on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:07PM (#39099530)
I actually agree with pretty much everything you said.

My comment was already getting quite long so I chose to summarize it as “money” because I think that ultimately, if I had to choose just one primary motivation, it comes down to money.

But I’ll happily admit that it’s not as cut and dry as I make it out to be and a lot of nuance gets lost by my choice to pin it on “money”.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by bimguy on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:02PM (#39096807)
Apparently Boeing employee's trawl hacker news threads because someone downvoted your post.

I'll never forget that Boeing made a secret flight system that actually crashed planes and then blamed pilots of third world countries for mistakes that Boeing made in not training pilots from ANY country about their secret flight system.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by jwells89 on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:53AM (#39090769)
> The only viable solution is an independent safety board (paid for out of Boeing profits) that supervises every aspect of design and production at Boeing and its contractors until Boeing learns how to build safe airplanes again.

At this point I’d go further than that. Their ability to manufacture and sell aircraft should be at stake. This needs to be an existential threat for Boeing to take it seriously.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by JCharante on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:42AM (#39091563)
> It's going to be very difficult to avoid the 737 MAX going forward.

Maybe. Delta doesn't currently have any 737 max and they have ordered 100 max 10s, but they aren't approved by the FAA yet and they might change their order. There are still airlines that prefer airbus.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by echelon on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:58AM (#39090130)
"If it's a Boeing, I'm not going."

I already look for these planes and will schedule my itinerary around avoiding them.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by redcobra762 on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:14AM (#39090290)
You can try, but the point is that will only get harder, and it’s not like the economic pain will be felt in any specific sense. You’ll just fly less.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by lawlessone on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:22AM (#39090391)
Is this a US thing? In the EU and i've found as long as avoid Ryanair everyone else is using Airbus.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by redcobra762 on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:25AM (#39090421)
Southwest and United have the most, so yeah.

https://simpleflying.com/boeing-737-max-airlines/

Americans fly the most out of any country though, so it’s unsurprising America also buys the most planes.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_airline...

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by hedora on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:34AM (#39091434)
United is absolutely horrible, so I’ve been actively avoiding them for over a decade.

Southwest was my go to, but I’ll happily fly a crappier non-boeing airline if it’s an option.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by colingoodman on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:18PM (#39092151)
I don't care for any airline, but while I see your disgust for United expressed often I haven't had any issues with them. Granted I only fly them a few times a year. Either they've improved a lot or I have been lucky!
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by the_doctah on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:47AM (#39090685)
So just like almost everything else we just have to collectively accept it getting shittier and more dangerous? Decline of civilization in full effect. Bring on the diversity hiring to accelerate!
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by amiga386 on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:24PM (#39092239)
It doesn't matter the colour of employees' skin. It matters how many there are, and how the company insists they act. A company that cuts its own staff, reduces the bargaining power of unions, lets its supplier fuck it even harder, and cares about volume over quality... is going to be worse.

https://www.levernews.com/profits-and-payouts-over-passenger...

> "Cost-cutting was the single major reason behind selling commercial aircraft-parts operations [to] the new entity named Spirit Aerosystems [which] introduced its own cost-cutting strategy, even harsher than Boeing's"

> Spirit executives explained that they "hired 1,300 fewer people than the predecessor had employed" and implemented less-favorable union contracts which "provided for wage reductions of 10%"

> Boeing took advantage of Spirit's weaker union and more cutthroat business tactics by further squeezing their supplier to do faster, cheaper work.

> In a federal securities lawsuit [...] some of Spirit’s former employees alleged [...] many serious production issues including "out-of-calibration torque wrenches" that mechanics were using, and "defects such as the routine presence of foreign object debris (“FOD”) in Spirit products, missing fasteners, peeling paint, and poor skin quality."

> The complaint concluded that "such constant quality failures resulted in part from Spirit's culture which prioritized production numbers and short-term financial outcomes over product quality."

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by andsoitis on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:58AM (#39090862)
> we just have to collectively accept it getting shittier and more dangerous? Decline of civilization in full effect.

Aviation safety has been improving, not getting worse.

https://www.icao.int/safety/Documents/ICAO_SR_2023_20230823....

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:06AM (#39090985)
Was with you until the ignorant diversity comment

Diversity actually tends to IMPROVE results — including corporate financial results — by bringing aboard different points of view. And if you somehow still think that some races are more intrinsically intelligent than others, you're simply ignorant of the fact that the supposed racial results disparity in tests like the SAT measures more accurately disparity in opportunity [2]. There are many more references for both, and I'll stop at ignorance, but you really should get more educated before posting ignorance like that.

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/karstenstrauss/2018/01/25/more-...

[1] https://hbr.org/2019/03/when-and-why-diversity-improves-your...

[2] https://www.brookings.edu/articles/race-gaps-in-sat-scores-h...

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by the_doctah on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:31AM (#39091385)
> you're simply ignorant of the fact that the supposed racial results disparity in tests like the SAT measures more accurately disparity in opportunity

Literally all this chart shows is disparity in performance, thereby proving my point. Unless you're trying to say standardized tests are racist?

>And if you somehow still think that some races are more intrinsically intelligent than others

Black people just have more access to sports, which is why they are more athletic. Disparity in opportunity, right? Asians just don't have access to enough basketball courts. But yeah, I'm the ignorant one.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by EGG_CREAM on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:07PM (#39092970)
The person above didn’t explicitly say it so I will: you’re a racist.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:35PM (#39093374)
>>Unless you're trying to say standardized tests are racist?

Quite the opposite. While the tests were criticized as racist, further sutdy is showing that the results correlate most strongly with educational opportunity, and basically document the broader disparities.

>>Disparity in opportunity, right? Asians just don't have access to enough basketball courts. But yeah, I'm the ignorant one.

Yes, you are.

You entirely ignore the role of culture and disparate opportunity in athletic results. For starters, in some minority cultures, sports is a primary route AVAILABLE for success, so both more athletes go into those routes, and more stay in. A couple of examples.

I knew a serious football player, played for 'bama, won the Rose Bowl, was recruited by multiple top pro teams. Declined it all and went into software sales (which is where I met him, recruiting my company to be a VAR), because he wanted to have knees that worked after he was 40. He was white and had the opportunity to do something else.

Or, take the speed events of alpine ski racing, Downhill and Super-G (something I know a bit about from having been internationally ranked and on my national ski team and the pro tour decades ago). For decades, the Austrians dominate. At various times, a Swiss, Norwegian, German, French, Italian, or American will be on top, but there are always Austrians in the top 10 and usually dominating at the top of the podium. Yet Austria is only a country of 8+ million people, not much larger than Massachusetts. And there are serious skiing mountains and training programs in dozens of larger countries, and far larger potential talent pools.

I can also tell you that Downhill racing is one of the absolutely most intensly demanding sports - over 2 minutes of peak demands on strength, aerobic capacity, and skilled fine-tuned control required to merely make it to the finish line, let alone win.

You clearly suggest that it is genetics that determine sporting outcome and anyone claiming opportunity or other factors is ignorant.

So, what is it about the Austrians' gene pool that gives them such perennial prowess in Downhill ski racing? Is their genetic makeup somehow that different from the next-door Swiss or Germans? Obviously not. What IS different is their culture where they have great training programs and a huge portion of their talent pool goes into ski racing — Austrian kids want to win at Kitzbühel or Wengen the way American kids aspire to win a Super Bowl or World Series —and that's differentially where much of our talent pool goes.

As for Asian basketball players, obviously they CAN be great [0], but anecdotally, their culture values things other than basketball, so we see lots more of them at the top of math competitions than we see Austrians.

So, while I could go on at far greater length, the answer is clearly that YES you are the ignorant one on those sorts of topics, and should stop spreading your ignorance.

[0] from literally a 2-second search: https://basketballmentality.com/best-asian-nba-players/

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by the_doctah on Monday January 22, 2024 @03:29PM (#39094969)
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @05:08PM (#39096195)
Let's also deal with the facts here, from actual data on Boeing and Spirit.

You claim that diversity is accelerating the decline, in this case in the context of airline technology and management failures. Looking at their bios & photos, [0, 1,2] here's the breakdown:

Out of the 13 Boeing Board members, 8 are white men, 3 are white women, 1 is a black man and 1 an Indian, 1 a mixed woman.

On Boeing's 21 member executive council, 13 are white men, 5 are white women, and 3 black/mixed men.

Spirit Aerosystems has 10 Board members, of which 7 are white men, 1 black man and and 2 white women.

Spirit's 14 executives are 10 white men, 1 black man, and 3 white women.

You are saying that out of 58 people, the 38 white men got overwhelmend by the 13 white women and 6 black men and 2 others who completely and illegitimately dominated their choices and forced them to make such bad decisions that their fleets are again grounded and subject to inspection?

Because that is what is required for "diversity to accelerate" this decline — that those 38 white men are so weak that their superior judgement is overwhelmed by any minority of women or non-whites.

More likely, the dominant white men are just making inferior decisions all on their own, and the minority either goes along to get along or cannot outvote the commanding WM majority.

Either way, diversity is NOT the problem. The problem is that the old white guys (esp from the McConnel-Douglas cultrue) are forking it up and deed to be replaced.

Go peddle your racist ignorance elsewhere. (&re: your Twitter ref: you are obviously incapable of understanding an argument beyond mischaracterizing it — I'm not simply saying "here's an exception to your statistical generalization"; I'm describing and providing evidence for OTHER FACTORS that you ignore, and which actually dominate. Yese genes and opportunity play a part, but cultural push dominates top athletic prowess)

In general, you can spend your life using confirmation bias to confirm ytour racism. That does not make you any less ignorant. I makes you willfully ignorant

I sincerely hope your "doctor" moniker has nothing to do with practice of medicine. You would be a plague on your patients, and should quit. Wow, what an awful person you are.

[0] https://www.boeing.com/company/general-info/corporate-govern...

[1] https://www.boeing.com/company/bios/index.page

[2] https://investor.spiritaero.com/corporate-governance/OD/defa...

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by schmookeeg on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:35AM (#39091448)
How many different points of view on "we should really tighten all of the bolts on this emergency door plug" does anyone need? :)

Your remarks make sense darn near anywhere else except a "let's all panic and hand-wring about a Boeing manufacturing lapse" thread

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:42PM (#39093484)
Agree.

This is rebutting a gratuitous, false, and racist comment claiming that addressing structural racism would "accelerate" "everything... getting shittier and more dangerous" and the "Decline of civilization".

We shouldn't have to rebut that kind of racist claptrap in such a technical discussion, but evidently someone calling himself "the_doctah" thinks it's appropriate to include and defend.

Yup, the trash stinks while it's being taken out.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by aydyn on Monday January 22, 2024 @12:35PM (#39092435)
> Evidence that board diversity benefits firms, however, has been mixed. A 2015 meta-analysis of 140 research studies of the relationship between female board representation and performance found a positive relationship with accounting returns, but no significant relationship with market performance. Other research has found no relationship to performance at all.

From your own link shows very strong evidence for a null effect (keep in mind there's strong incentive to show a statistically significant effect).

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:05PM (#39092941)
OK, for the sake of discussion, let's say that diversity of the board & exec suites has a null effect, and take a closer look at GP's statement.

That is certainly a vastly different claim vs the extreme negative effect claimed by the GP of "accelerating" everything getting "getting shittier and more dangerous"

He's literally claiming that including people from diverse backgrounds will make things shittier and more dangerous. That is literally the trope of the dangerous black man coming to destroy society. So, yes, thinking about it, I'll go beyond ignorant and call it out as racist. Because if you can say that with a straight face, you really have a deep problem with attitudes about race.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by aydyn on Monday January 22, 2024 @04:27PM (#39095704)
Interesting that you address a completely different point and (poster!) in response to what was written by me.

Regardless of what GP wrote, you made a claim as well.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Monday January 22, 2024 @06:27PM (#39097054)
Yes, I made a claim and specifically addressed it — and it's consequences

Since your counter claim was un-cited studies showing "mixed" results or no benefit, there was little to discuss about your point, other than the consequences, so I did.

Making the assumption that neither of us have decisive data, I granted for the sake of discussions that your counter-claim was correct. And went on to address the consequence, which is still that the GP is deeply wrong by asserting that leadership diversity accelerates the decline of civilization in general and aircraft building in particular.

In short: the worst case you can come up with is that it is more fair and does no harm. The best case is that it is more fair and causes improvement both locally and to society at large.

If you were trying to support GPs racist assertions, you failed. If you were trying to assert something else, it's not become clear in two posts. I'll be happy to respond if you could elaborate on what is exactly your point in referring to un-cited studies about null results?

EDIT: add "In short"..."

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by aydyn on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @02:06AM (#39100414)
The point is your claim is wrong by the text you yourself linked to.

The data, assuming we just go by what you linked, IS decisive. It shows you are wrong.

Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:34AM (#39105641)
Are you claiming that one of the links shows that it is harmful, or only null, as you stated above (& which link, where?)? If it's null, then I addressed that - again, worst case is neutral, but more fair performance.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by aydyn on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @11:42AM (#39105788)
You did not address it nor did you correct your incorrect claim.
Re:Kayak's New Flight Filter Allows You to Exclude Aircraft ... by toss1 on Thursday January 25, 2024 @10:20AM (#39130435)
And you have not even bothered to specify anything beyond "it asserts null", which I addressed and an otherwise unsupported and unspecified "you are wrong".

I'm happy to have a discussion, but not engage with zero-effort passive-aggressive empty assertions. Say what you mean, with some specificity, or go away. Have a nice day.