News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by xnorswap on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:35AM (#39088804)
Despite a policy of "use original titles", the HN software automatically mangles titles.

This is one of the more bizarre auto-editing of titles it does because of how pointless it feels.

"The man who" is established English convention. "A man who" is changing the meaning for the sake of it without producing a clearer title. The person is unambiguously defined, so the definitive article is entirely correct. If the person isn't one of a set of people to whom the description could apply, it makes no sense to use the indefinite article. If a title was, "The man who starts every day with steak and chips" then switching to, "A man who starts every day with steak and chips" feels correct, he almost surely is not alone in doing so.

In contrast, "A man who coined the word Robot", is not correct, it alters the meaning to suggest that someone else could also have coined the word.

HN also removes "How" from the start of titles which often destroys meaning too. That is explained as trying to "reduce clickbait" titles, but the effect is often to make the title nonsensical.

It's one of the many contradictions about this place.

I feels as if whoever set up this system hasn't truly understood the meaning that "The man who" conveys, and has attempted to force a version they see as "more correct" despite it producing nonsense.

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by arrowsmith on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:01AM (#39089029)
Looks like it doesn't change all titles that start with "the", see e.g. these two from the current front page:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39066795 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39082552

So it only changes "the man" to "a man"? (And I'm guessing also "the woman" to "a woman"?)

I'm struggling to understand the reasoning here. Can someone give me an example of a title starting with "the man" which sounds excessively clickbaity, but "a man" fixes it? I can't think of one.

Now I'm wondering what other auto-editing rules HN applies. Is there a list somewhere?

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by j4yav on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:20AM (#39089782)
Sometimes a human also fixes them afterwards.
Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by dumbo-octopus on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:09AM (#39090235)
https://www.rollingstone.com/feature/up-in-the-air-meet-the-...

> Up in the Air: Meet the Man Who Flies Around the World for Free

> Meet the Man Who Flies Around the World for Free

> The Man Who Flies Around the World for Free

> A Man Who Flies Around the World for Free

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9916974

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by networked on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:28AM (#39089304)
You can edit the title of "a" submission when this happens.

My experience is that, if a moderator hasn't touched it, the title of a story remains editable throughout the edit window of the first two hours. It doesn't matter what automatic changes were applied to the title on submission; they are not reapplied when you edit.

I restore the original title if HN's software changes it poorly. When I look at /newest or even the front page, it seems few submitters do. Either they are unaware of the possibility, or they think it isn't allowed. (AFAICT, it is allowed as long as you don't use it to break the guidelines. Here is a recent comment by dang saying you can do it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38993985.)

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by jojojaf on Monday January 22, 2024 @07:56AM (#39088984)
I say go the Slavic route and lose all the articles; "Man who coined word 'Robot' defends himself"

Fits with the 'robot' theme

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by Y_Y on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:02AM (#39089034)
Man coins "robot", defends self
Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by Almondsetat on Monday January 22, 2024 @08:04AM (#39089054)
"robot" man self defends
Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by robertlagrant on Monday January 22, 2024 @09:31AM (#39089887)
Defensive "robot" coiner.
Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by csours on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:57AM (#39090827)
Coin Operated Boy: A Man, Da.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YAnyYTjjhJ0 (Dresden Dolls singer is Amanda Palmer - A Man, Da)

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by jojojaf on Tuesday January 23, 2024 @12:53PM (#39106905)
"Robot"er defensive
Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by pvg on Monday January 22, 2024 @01:59PM (#39093739)
go the Slavic route

полека, лампата!

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by Danieru on Monday January 22, 2024 @10:43AM (#39090638)
IMHO, the "The" and "How" handling were smart decisions back during the digg era.

Over time those features of clickbait have become defocused. Removing The and How handling might make sense now.

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by FearNotDaniel on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:16AM (#39091188)
> If the person isn't one of a set of people to whom the description could apply, it makes no sense to use the indefinite article.

> he’s the guy who (along with his brother Josef) invented the word “robot.”

Just to be superly, unnecessarily pedantic: in this case the person is one of a set of people, so although I don't agree with the title being rewritten, it does actually make sense.

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by stcredzero on Monday January 22, 2024 @11:19AM (#39091227)
This is one of the more bizarre auto-editing of titles it does because of how pointless it feels.

Someone should take a page from "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep" and create an AutoGPT "replicant" version of HN, including LLM versions of the moderators, PG, and the top commenters and submitters.

Re:A Man Who Coined the Word "Robot" Defends Himself by neuromanser on Monday January 22, 2024 @02:45PM (#39094383)
Of course, in light of Betteridge's law, that version would be called Androids Don't Dream of Electric Sheep.