News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:03AM (#39067625)
Incredibly talented people complain when technology lets talentless people make some of the beautiful things that they imagine but never had the talent to make real.

It's like rich people saying money does not matter. "Easy for you to say." I can't draw. But now I can take the talent I have and extend it to make images.

Is it art? I don't know. I don't care. I was not able, now I am able, and the people who are able complain.

Screw 'em. This is what tools are for. The strong should not tell the weak they cannot use props.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by Hoasi on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:41AM (#39067982)
> Incredibly talented people complain when technology lets talentless people make some of the beautiful things that they imagine but never had the talent to make real.

If we are speaking about the democratization of tools, this is not what is happening here.

In effect, prompting Dall-E or Midjourney does not make you a creator.

And herein lies the problem. It doesn't enable the talentless to create something beautiful. It allows anyone to prompt aggregated images, regardless of talent or years dedicated to a craft. These images have no intrinsic value and, on top of that, don't belong to the prompter.

This technology is a collage tool, and it's great, but it doesn't make anyone a creator. If you believe it does, you're in for a rough awakening.

Right now, the best models are only working thanks to bypassing the will of thousands of artists who didn't agree to have their work used for training data. As such, we are not essentially speaking about talent but the democratization of theft.

Again, it's not the technology itself that is the problem. Most artists are pro-technology and don't oppose it. Besides, if you learn how to draw (anybody can learn this skill, come on!), you probably won't be impressed by most Midjourney results.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by thrwayaistartup on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:44AM (#39068003)
> This technology is a collage tool, and it's great, but it doesn't make anyone a creator. If you believe it does, you're in for a rough awakening.

Hannah Höch would like a word.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:12PM (#39070482)
This is entirely not the point.

I want to see a picture of a 5 kilometre high tower surrounded by spiralling cones of line on an infinite plane made of tessellating fractals.

Now I have that picture. Great.

I did not make than image "to be an artist". I made that image because I wanted that image. If it came out of a search engine rather than an AI, I wouldn't care.

This kind of utilitarian creation of images is like photography for things that don't exist. Fine art? Art? Craft? Search of latent space? Collage? I don't care.

Creator as an identity? I don't care.

Whether machines are allowed to learn from humans is a hot topic. Every working artist studies, in great detail, other artists. They often make exact copies, as exact as they can, of great works to learn how those artists made them.

Be very careful that in banning AI learning you do not also ban human learning. A law that covers one might also cover the other.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by Hoasi on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:40PM (#39072069)
> This is entirely not the point.

It's not the point for you. Fine.

For the record, I'm not advocating for laws or banning AI. It's an impressive technology you can use in a myriad of ways. Ethical ways would be preferable.

Using AI does not make you an artist, just as having a pencil in your hand doesn't make you a qualified draughtsman.

AI's whole value, the dada, was obtained without living artists' consent. That's a fact. Without data, there are no images, no spirals, nothing. The unfortunate side effect is that, at scale, it devalues these artworks. Prompting AI tools, you get a synthetic substitute for art made by real people.

If that is what you want, why not? If you sell this spiral as your art, it becomes slightly more complicated.

> Be very careful that in banning AI learning you do not also ban human learning. A law that covers one might also cover the other.

False equivalency.

And again, I'm not advocating for banning anything. AI art, or imagery, if it's not art, who cares, is not going away. Whether AI output is stunning, incredibly beautiful, or cheap, synthetic, the equivalent of junk food, is already pretty clear. The question becomes: who owns it?

Perhaps artists will find ways to make it better and truly impressive. That said, it's not unreasonable for artists to ask back some of the value they unwillingly provided. Or just for their work to be removed from the pool of data scraped by AI companies.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Sunday January 21, 2024 @04:36AM (#39077006)
This is pretty simple.

Either we maintain that it is illegal to learn from copyrighted images without a license — which is going to destroy human culture very fast I believe,

Or we accept that anybody can study a copyrighted work and learn from it, including using a machine as their agent.

If a 12 year old kid prints out an image made by Hirst and hangs it in their bedroom that is fair use. If a corporation uses the image on a t shirt they need a license.

Now the same thing, but “in the style of Hirst”

The copyright infringement is generally at the point where somebody is depriving the artist of income and what I’m hearing here is HOME TAPING IS KILLING MUSIC.

No, friends, refusal to enforce monopolies laws is killing music. Home taping is how music survived.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by dorkwood on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:37AM (#39068606)
> Is it art? I don't know. I don't care. I was not able, now I am able, and the people who are able complain.

> Screw 'em. This is what tools are for. The strong should not tell the weak they cannot use props.

Really? This famously maligned group of people, who have endured a lifetime of jokes about their useless art school degrees and student loans they'll never repay, we're now calling "the strong"?

Artists aren't upset because a few developers made a machine that can generate pictures. They're upset because the machine couldn't have existed without their work, which they did not consent to being used, and it's now on the way to destroying their livelihoods all across the globe.

Can't you see the tragedy in their story?

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by unraveller on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:00PM (#39070354)
No machine could have been invented without taking from the human work that came before it. Those people provided the inventor with a task to be done.

As they tell inventors, you can't patent an aim, only a method, and only for a time. Indeed, the aim is everything they mean to promote by patents... better, faster, cheaper ways of operating in the world.

I thank the artists for their aim. That some don't want what they were aiming at to fall into lesser hands tells me they never did art for the right reasons. The accolades becoming diluted is no tragedy.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:17PM (#39070540)
When a talented person tries to ban the tools that make an average person able to do the same stuff the talented person can do, this is intentionally disabling people to preserve a class privilege.

If there was a pill that gave people +40 points of IQ would we have born-smart people trying to ban it? Yes, some.

If we had a machine that put knowledge right into people's heads by nanobot magic would we have people trying to ban it? "This four week doctor training is an unacceptable threat to the medical industry" You bet it is pal, you bet it is.

This is not to say that *art is not vitally important* but it's not so important that we should ban talentless people getting access to the ability to make something that you will not be able to visually distinguish from art just to protect the monopoly of the talented-and-trained ones.

I can't draw. Now I can draw-with-machine-assistance. Maybe it's not the same as "drawing" for some numinous reason. I'm too talentless to care.

Somebody is going to take this away from me to protect the people who can draw?

No.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by messiah_complex on Saturday January 20, 2024 @02:46PM (#39071511)
>When a talented person tries to ban the tools that make an average person able to do the same stuff the talented person can do, this is intentionally disabling people to preserve a class privilege.

And now we're back to denigrating merit again. No denominator. No distinction. Everybody gets the same gold star.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:01PM (#39071659)
No, I don't want a gold star, I want a robot that can draw for me when I want something done.

I'm not trying to pretend AI image generation is art. I have no interest in that question right now.

What I'm saying is that it's completely unreasonable to ban a tool that ordinary people find massively useful and empowering to protect people who have training and talent.

Billions can't make the images in their heads real to protect the class privilege of a few hundred thousand professional artists worldwide?

No.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by messiah_complex on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:02PM (#39071670)
You're not thinking about the consequences of your position. What I said stands.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:16PM (#39071819)
"Billions can't make the images in their heads real to protect the class privilege of a few hundred thousand professional artists worldwide?"

I thought about that extensively before I wrote it down.

If you think it is flawed explain why, please.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by dorkwood on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:07PM (#39074779)
This appears to be basically the same argument I responded to originally, but rephrased in a different way -- that the privileged artists want to prevent anyone else from attaining their power and it's not fair.

You didn't address my original point, which is that your drawing-assistance-machine was only made possible by surreptitiously training on a vast amount of artist's work without their permission.

To use your nanobot analogy, would you see any problem if the nanobot company attained its power by secretly scanning the brains of surgeons without their permission, so that it could mimic their neuron structure and give its users the same memories and motor skills? Or is the process by which the power was attained a non-issue for you?

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Sunday January 21, 2024 @04:37AM (#39077014)
All artists study other artists.

Are we to ban this too?

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by dorkwood on Sunday January 21, 2024 @06:22AM (#39077494)
You're not making a serious attempt to engage with anything I've said so far, so I don't want to keep arguing with you.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Sunday January 21, 2024 @09:32AM (#39078749)
I am not willing to change my mind based on the case you have presented.

I have engaged. I am not persuaded.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by viraptor on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:19AM (#39067754)
That's not what Nick Cave says though, is it? He's not complaining about the tech enabling people to create. He says the whole song results suck and only have surface level similarity to someone. The closest he gets is actually just accepting: "ChatGPT may be able to write a speech or an essay or a sermon or an obituary". He's not even saying anything about using LLM as a tool to help you express what you actually want to create, ("here's the beginning, now I need a line about X, but [constraint Y]") but rather criticises the complete "song in style of ..." result.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by thrwayaistartup on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:35AM (#39068577)
No. His critique is one of process, not of output quality.

He is asserting the existence of an "unconscious human spirit", asserting that ChatGPT "is fast-tracking the commodification of the human spirit by mechanising the imagination", and that we should fight against AI as we would fight against genocide: "just as we would fight any existential evil, we should fight it tooth and nail, for we are fighting for the very soul of the world."

Incidentally, I agree with the importance of struggle and soul-work. I agree with the general valence of the lament, but come away with a very different call to action. In particular: I just don't think I have the right to impose luddism on the rest of the world for my particular niche while benefiting lavishly from the rest of the world's alienation form their much more essential labor.

To me, it's the ravings of an angry, arrogant, and entitled elitist who fears being dethroned from his comfortable luxury and refined status. And a hilariously hyperbolic one at that. Of all the actual evils I would write something like this about, AI Art probably isn't even in the top 1,000,000. Can you imagine looking at the world today and writing that last paragraph? My god.

---

Quotes:

> ChatGPT rejects any notions of creative struggle, that our endeavours animate and nurture our lives giving them depth and meaning. It rejects that there is a collective, essential and unconscious human spirit underpinning our existence, connecting us all through our mutual striving.

> ChatGPT is fast-tracking the commodification of the human spirit by mechanising the imagination. It renders our participation in the act of creation as valueless and unnecessary. That ‘songwriter ‘you were talking to, Leon, who is using ChatGPT to write ‘his’ lyrics because it is ‘faster and easier ,’is participating in this erosion of the world’s soul and the spirit of humanity itself and, to put it politely, should fucking desist if he wants to continue calling himself a songwriter.

> This impulse – the creative dance – that is now being so cynically undermined, must be defended at all costs, and just as we would fight any existential evil, we should fight it tooth and nail, for we are fighting for the very soul of the world.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:21PM (#39070610)
I feel like this is a bit like the whole thing with "do submarines swim?"

I'm not interested in the question of whether an image I make with AI is art or not. I've written decent fiction in my time. Maybe here and there I inhabit the artistic category of "an unpublished genre fiction author." But I can't draw or paint or any of that stuff better than a reasonably talented 11 year old, and I'm 52. If I had artistic pretensions it's not happening.

But once in a while I want to see an image that I can't make and, well, AI boom boom yes here we go.

I don't claim that's art. I don't claim that the AI is an artist any more than I claim that a submarine is swimming. Those categories are irrelevant to my interest, which is simple.

I wish I was artistically talented so I could do stuff and now I can do some of that stuff without being artistically talented.

I feel good about this. It makes me feel better in the world.

Are we going to take this away from billions of people to protect people who can draw and have some training?

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jazzyjackson on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:08AM (#39067661)
the tech would not exist if not for the talented people you are screwing
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:15AM (#39067726)
Mine workers extract iron ore.

Iron ore is made into iron which is made into machines which shovel iron ore.

"Tell it like it is

Till there's no misunderstanding

When you strip it right back

Man feed machine

Machine feed man" to quote a (human) poet

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jazzyjackson on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:37AM (#39067943)
an interesting analogy, thanks, I'll trade you some lines I heard from Johnny Cash:

Well John Henry hammered in the mountain, he'd give a grunt and he'd give groan with every swing, the women folks for miles around, heard him and come down, to watch him make the cold steel ring, Lord what a swinger, just listen to that cold steel ring

But the bad boss come up laughing at John Henry, said you full of vinegar now, but you bout through, were gonna get a steam drill to do your share of drivin, then what's all them muscles gonna do, huh John Henry, gonna take a little bit of vinegar out of you

John Henry said I feed four little brothers, and my baby sister's walking on her knees, did the Lord say that machines ought to take the place of living, and what's a subsitute for bread and beans, I ain't seen it, do engines get rewarded for their steam?

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by spacecadet on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:56AM (#39068140)
Classic. When I worked in industrial automation, I use to refer to the moment when testing said automation would fail, as the "john henry test".
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jazzyjackson on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:12AM (#39068316)
i liked the part where the machine breaks down while the man pushes past his breaking point

but ofc the machine is repairable, the late john henry less so.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:25PM (#39070672)
And if we had banned these digging machines would be be talking to each other on the internet now?

Somehow work survived.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jkic47 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:17AM (#39067731)
Do you think so? I can see the AI being trained with crowdsourced input like "does picture A look more like a Mondrian than picture B".
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by viraptor on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:21AM (#39067778)
You're still screwing Mondrian in this case and the training system would not exist without Mondrian.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by skerit on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:55AM (#39068128)
It's a bad example anyway since Mondriaan has been dead since 1944 and all copyright on his works have expired.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jazzyjackson on Saturday January 20, 2024 @10:19AM (#39068405)
hehehe

speaking of, IMO there would be a lot less hullabaloo around OpenAI being derived from unlicensed works if we reverted copyright to 14 years like the constitution says (well, copyright act of 1790)

Everyone could ingest whatever they want up through 2010 and if they want it to know what the New York Times said after that they can pay for it. The midjourney ceo basically said they couldnt be bothered to reach out to individual artists cuz there's too dang many of them, and for that I can sympathize - too much work remains off limits

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jkic47 on Saturday January 20, 2024 @04:11PM (#39072369)
Take a minute to extend your argument, and it will fall apart: SNL is "screwing" Trump/Biden because their jokes wouldn't exist without Trump/Biden. Movie critics are "screwing" actors, because the review wouldn't exist without the movie.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jazzyjackson on Saturday January 20, 2024 @05:15PM (#39072995)
that's a fair counter but there are laws about this, and your examples are parody and commentary, neither of which effect the market value of the original

the "screwing" is in the form of getting paid for reselling the work of others (depriving the others of the ability to sell their own work - less downloading a movie for free and more like selling bootlegs in front of the record store), not merely being, like, chronologically dependent.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jkic47 on Sunday January 21, 2024 @11:09AM (#39079716)
I agree that my examples are about parody and commentary, and I apologize that my intent wasn't clear. I was trying to convey that a derivative work made by studying the original (Mondrian / Biden / Trump speech) should be OK. Like Admiral Cloudberg or Mentour Pilot can take an air-crash investigation and make it more compelling than a Mayday documentary, or, indeed, the FAA report itself. They use the same base material, but sculpt it into something perhaps more compelling. The fact that an AI does this instead of a human seems irrelevant.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by viraptor on Saturday January 20, 2024 @11:16PM (#39075504)
SNL jokes are not in the same category. They're not "a speech like Trump's" which would bring nothing new, but jokes based on those. The whole post from Nick Cave is about a generated "song in the style of Nick Cave" rather than something novel that takes inspiration from his songs.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by mvandermeulen on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:14AM (#39067719)
How are they being screwed?
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by jazzyjackson on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:25AM (#39067817)
They are being outcompeted by a megacorp selling bootleg derivatives of their work

Not being screwed looks like royalties for content that the machine derives its value from

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by Hoasi on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:45AM (#39068023)
> They are being outcompeted by a megacorp selling bootleg derivatives of their work

and driving the value of their hard work to the ground.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:04AM (#39067636)
"Supermodels complain about plastic surgery letting ugly people look better" type headlines abound in AI
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by rafaelmn on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:23AM (#39067798)
Plastic surgery only gets you so far. Likewise for AI generated content.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by Hoasi on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:47AM (#39068030)
Perfect analogy.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Saturday January 20, 2024 @01:23PM (#39070635)
Yes, I think that's absolutely true of both plastic surgery and of AI. I don't mind, it's better than where I was before!

I can semi-draw with AI help. Good enough.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by Hoasi on Saturday January 20, 2024 @03:52PM (#39072184)
> I can semi-draw with AI help. Good enough.

Good for you. But that's not drawing, though. You won't know what drawing is until you try. Then you'll come back with more questions. It's an open-ended endeavor.

Drawing is not something you solve with an app.

That's why the whole premise of this thread is a bit sad. AI is a tool that bypasses the joy (and the point) of drawing entirely.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by leashless on Sunday January 21, 2024 @04:43AM (#39077038)
Oh I tried. I suck.

If I worked at it, I would still suck.

Am I to be deprived of the capability to take images from inside my head and turn them into pixels TO PROTECT THE CARTEL OF PEOPLE WHO CAN DO IT MANUALLY?

Seems like a bad idea.

“good artists borrow, great artists steal” —- Picasso.

Whether AI generated work should be copyright able is a MUCH MUCH harder question.

Maybe the answer you seek is there.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by 8jef on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:28AM (#39067840)
Moreover, calling upon bible's genesis as an analogy for creation makes for a very weak, backward argument.
Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by Almondsetat on Saturday January 20, 2024 @09:18AM (#39067744)
Artists complain because they are being hit with the fact that most people don't care about art.

Why is AI taking over corporate designs? Because, my dear artist, the stuff corporations commissioned you wasn't art, they were formulaic cogs into a soulless machine.

Why is AI taking over porn? Because, my dear artists, almost all of your NSFW commissions wasn't art, its single purpose was making someone cum.

Before automation people were forced to hire artists. Do you think the Church in the middle ages would have hired so many painters to decorate the walls of the myriad of minor churches in their possession? No, they would have saved them for the big meaningful projects and let AI do the job elsewhere.

The people really paying you for your art are a minority and won't go away. Deal with this fact however you like. Perhaps if you're such a good artist then use AI to round up your weaker skills such as marketing or story writing.

Re:Why strive? Stephen Fry reads Nick Cave's letter on the t... by famahar on Saturday January 20, 2024 @07:08PM (#39073982)
I wish people had a bit more confidence about making art. Not everything needs to be a flashy colorful realistic looking drawing. I'd argue they weren't talentless, just unconfident and narrow minded towards what art can be. Grab a canvas and go wild. People will be surprised with how easy it is to make art and you'll quickly shape your own unique art style.