News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by dotnet00 on Friday January 19, 2024 @12:28PM (#39058186)
Even if it was private space tourism, what's the problem? They'd be spending their massive wealth funding further development of space technology. This isn't a virgin galactic style technological dead end death trap.

As prices come down for access to space, there is obviously going to be a point between only being affordable by governments and being affordable by everyone, where only governments and particularly rich people can afford it.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by diggan on Friday January 19, 2024 @12:39PM (#39058378)
> Even if it was private space tourism, what's the problem?

I don't think everyone is as excited to have capitalism take over our priorities in space, after seeing what it has done to Terra.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by jpadkins on Friday January 19, 2024 @12:50PM (#39058594)
Why? Populations that adopted capitalism are significantly better off than they were before usage. And it's the best economic system we have invented.

Totalitarian regimes in space haven't gotten us very far, and frankly sound very depressing for the future of humanity.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by soperj on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:06PM (#39058862)
> And it's the best economic system we have invented.

That would be the market economy, not capitalism. Since we have state capitalism as well as other varieties that aren't free markets.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:18PM (#39059774)
If we're being particular about definitions, then I wouldn't say that space tourism or any kind of tourism market is promoting capitalism.

I think the criticism upthread was aimed more generally at large undertakings for the sake of profit with barely anyone getting goods/services out of the deal, which does fit space tourism.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Alupis on Friday January 19, 2024 @12:45PM (#39058490)
99.999% of all man-made objects in space (and all of their benefits you enjoy every day) are there because of capitalism...
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by dotancohen on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:02PM (#39061130)
I don't know if you are referring to communications satellites, but only with the advent of Starlink have comms birds outnumbered reconnaissance birds.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by diggan on Friday January 19, 2024 @12:47PM (#39058532)
I'd say despite capitalism, but lets just agree to disagree :)
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by dotnet00 on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:08PM (#39058887)
Then you don't know anything about the history of space exploration, or are so deluded by your ideology that you are intentionally blind to it.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by diggan on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:26PM (#39059128)
Or, I just happen to have a different opinion from you, and a different conclusion? It's not impossible you know
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Alupis on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:15PM (#39059728)
Well, your opinion is not grounded in reality. Nearly every item in space that is man-made was put there for commercial purposes. The space race may have started out with government/exploration, but it was vastly propelled by commercial interests seeking to deliver services around the planet.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by soperj on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:08PM (#39058881)
That sounds made up. Sputnik wasn't because of capitalism, and capitalism didn't put a man on the moon.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by edgyquant on Friday January 19, 2024 @01:52PM (#39059442)
Sputnik was one satellite decades ago. Most things in space are commercial satellites at this point so the OP is correct
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by soperj on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:13PM (#39059703)
99.999%. Doubt it.

edit:

https://www.esa.int/ESA_Multimedia/Images/2021/05/The_increa...

Rounding up to 30000 objects in orbit (not even in space), that would mean 0.3 objects weren't made by capitalism. 1 object put up by government invalidates OP.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:29PM (#39059910)
1. Someone being hyperbolic when smashing the 9 key doesn't "invalidate" their argument. In this context, 99% can serve the same purpose.

2. If we do want to be pedantic, they said "in space" and sputnik is not in space anymore.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by soperj on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:24PM (#39060592)
Sure, but the flag on the moon is, along with rovers, along with the moon space cart, along with voyager 1 & 2 and many other things. 10 years ago, nearly all of it was put up by government funded vehicles. Even SpaceX wouldn't be where it is today without Government funding (might not even exist).
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Dylan16807 on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:06PM (#39061182)
I think they were counting NASA as "because of capitalism". If you disagree with that, then that's a much better line of argument than going after the exact percentage.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Alupis on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:21PM (#39059802)
Starlink has a little over 5,000 satellites in orbit currently, with expansion planned up to 42,000 in the future.

At the end of 2022, there was only 6,718 active satellites[1] in space - total.

The amount of government objects (from any country, of any kind, station, spy satellite, probe, rover, etc) is dwarfed by commercial interests. This just illustrates the sheer volume of commercial objects in space...

In fact, here's a list of all publicly acknowledged satellites launched by the USAF since 1984[2]. It shows 331 in total, counting inactive satellites.

[1] https://blog.ucsusa.org/syoung/how-many-satellites-are-in-sp...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_USA_satellites

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by soperj on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:25PM (#39060616)
Doesn't mean that OP was correct which was what I was responding to.
Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Swenrekcah on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:34PM (#39059983)
It is impossible to know however, if large economies under different systems than capitalism would not have made for instance satellite phones a priority 40 years ago rather than landlines and cell towers. Capitalism didn’t because it was more expensive but a central planner might well have because they thought it was cooler.

So it’s kind of unreasonable to be adamant that only because of capitalism we have stuff in space.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Alupis on Friday January 19, 2024 @02:46PM (#39060135)
Which centrally planned economy can/could afford to operate a constellation for phones?

The initial Iridium constellation is estimated at around $5 Billion in 1998 money (~$9 Billion today), and it nearly killed the company in the process. That was just initial constellation expenses - monthly subscriptions are still cost prohibitive for majority of the population/general use, and ongoing maintenance is very expensive.

The point is - it's not only cheaper to do land-based communications, but it's more reliable.

There doesn't seem to be any reality where a centrally planned economy would take this sort of project on just for funsies...

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Swenrekcah on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:47PM (#39061673)
The Soviet Union operated all sorts of uneconomical undertakings because they felt they needed to.

All that is needed is motivated labour that gets fed and housed. There is no magical law that you have to pay “market rates” so people can buy themselves gadgets.

Now to be clear I am not advocating for the Soviet Union or central planning, far from it. I am only saying that there is no inherent reason why you’d need capitalism to fill space up with stuff.

It is obviously a very powerful system but it is not the only possible system or necessarily the best. Again I very much like regulated and properly taxed market capitalist economies and want to keep living in one.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Alupis on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:45PM (#39062392)
The collapse of the Soviet Union was complex, but uneconomical undertakings did play a significant role... including the "Space Race".

Which cements my point... commercialism is the only way these sorts of activities can exist.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Swenrekcah on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:50PM (#39062436)
We should just agree to disagree.

Was ancient Egypt capitalist and the pyramids a commercial enterprise?

Again I am not advocating for anything except that we don’t turn economic systems into religious beliefs.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Alupis on Friday January 19, 2024 @05:59PM (#39062536)
> we don’t turn economic systems into religious beliefs.

Sure, I agree entirely with this statement.

> Was ancient Egypt capitalist and the pyramids a commercial enterprise?

Slave Labor is difficult to beat, eh? This is a strange way to make a point about government spending vs. commercialism.

The overall point was the incentive for someone to make a profit is what motivates many if not all of the risky endeavors. If governments were solely in charge of launching rockets, then there would be no push by SpaceX to develop cheaper alternatives (and therefore win contracts, therefore make money).

The government being solely in charge of any particular industry has rarely if ever resulted in innovations and ultimately a better service/product. The incentives are just not aligned under those circumstances.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by Swenrekcah on Friday January 19, 2024 @06:12PM (#39062669)
> Slave Labor is difficult to beat, eh? This is a strange way to make a point about government spending vs. commercialism.

If we’re being brutally honest a lot of today’s economy depends on slave-like conditions for workers. Not necessarily in the “developed” world although people debate that, but definitely in poorer areas of the world.

> The overall point was the incentive for someone to make a profit is what motivates many if not all of the risky endeavors. If governments were solely in charge of launching rockets, then there would be no push by SpaceX to develop cheaper alternatives (and therefore win contracts, therefore make money).

I don’t entirely agree with that statement. Of course the profit motive is powerful and it does matter to people but that is largely because of the capitalist system itself. So if that is changed the profit motive ceases to be as strong.

The case could be made that many of the greatest companies were founded by people motivated by strong vision and the desire to make an impact, much rather than profit motive. However in order to be able to do anything under capitalism they needed to focus on things that could be made profitable.

And certainly taken too far the incentives of the system are not at all aligned with making ordinary people’s lives better, but rather that they keep buying or subscribing to your stuff. See social media motives and incentives for instance.

Re:SpaceX launches 4 people for private mission to the Inter... by soperj on Friday January 19, 2024 @06:34PM (#39062896)
> Slave Labor is difficult to beat, eh?

Pyramids weren't built by slaves.