News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by pests on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:34PM (#39049499)
I find it so crazy everyone is so concerned about the terms of service, while in every other thread we have discussions on artists rights...

Artists must allow AI companies to harvest and learn from their output but people can't take OpenAI output for the same thing?

These companies already offer "styles" of other artists, what's wrong with making a "OpenAI" style?

I feel so many has lost the hacker spirit.

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by ben_w on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:56PM (#39049733)
ToS rules are contractual, so they apply if your use of their services even when copyright doesn't.

Conversely, if you don't use their services, as the output of AI models is (reportedly) non-copyrightable, I'd assume you're free to train on it so long as you don't actually make the requests yourself?

But I'm not a lawyer, and I'd ask one first before doing anything that risks expensive mistakes.

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by dvngnt_ on Thursday January 18, 2024 @07:12PM (#39049884)
Im not sure OP is violating their ToS

since they're not selling the model access to compete with chatgpt they're two different products.

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by ben_w on Friday January 19, 2024 @04:01AM (#39053252)
I think only some of their ToS are conditioned on competing, where I (not a lawyer) would seek advice first is:

"""For example, you may not:

…

• Attempt to or assist anyone to reverse engineer, decompile or discover the source code or underlying components of our Services, including our models, algorithms, or systems (except to the extent this restriction is prohibited by applicable law). """

May be fine, IDK, I'm not a lawyer.

I may also be looking at the wrong ToS entirely: https://openai.com/policies/terms-of-use

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by jurynulifcation on Thursday January 18, 2024 @07:22PM (#39049959)
Whatever the laws are, imo it's pretty clear that OpenAI are robber barons of data. It's totally justified to steal from a robber baron. How many people did they ask consent from before hoovering up their data? We should be doing everything possible, including breaking ToS, to get as much value from ChatGPT
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by ben_w on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:53AM (#39053181)
> it's pretty clear that OpenAI are robber barons of data. It's totally justified to steal from a robber baron. How many people did they ask consent from before hoovering up their data?

Clear morally if you assume their stated goals are bad faith and just arse covering[0], not necessarily in law — I have, sincerely, wondered how Google got away with crawling the web to create its search index. As this was before they were sued by newspapers for including snippets of search results, they ultimately didn't get away with it.

> We should be doing everything possible, including breaking ToS, to get as much value from ChatGPT

Generating additional and better models may be a tempting "screw the rich" option, but also the exact wrong option if you see their behaviour as IP theft that needs to be fixed — go to court, order the model to be destroyed, don't make more of them.

[0] I don't think they were originally, but (a) I generally look for the best in people, and (b) even if I'm right it is always possible they were/will be swayed by the presence of a huge pile of non-hypothetical money.

Does anyone besides the old board of directors even know why that board fired Altman a few months back?

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by jurynulifcation on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:44AM (#39056785)
I was happy to assume it was good faith until Altman started trying to engage in regulatory capture to protect his competitive moat. You are correct in saying we should pursue lawfare against OpenAI to make sure such blatant and widescale theft can't happen again. I believe you are incorrect in saying it's a bad idea to produce more models. We should do our best to destroy their extralegal competitive moat via extralegal means, then also do our best to ensure such a moat can not be legally constructed again.
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by ben_w on Friday January 19, 2024 @10:59AM (#39056946)
> I was happy to assume it was good faith until Altman started trying to engage in regulatory capture to protect his competitive moat

I've not seen him do that, just a lot of people saying that's the only thing they can believe he must have meant.

What I've seen in his comments, in the original transcripts, is basically "regulate GPT-4 and better, don't bother regulating anything smaller or simpler than that, don't regulate open source models".

> You are correct in saying we should pursue lawfare against OpenAI to make sure such blatant and widescale theft can't happen again. I believe you are incorrect in saying it's a bad idea to produce more models.

Contradictory position. To produce more models based on one you characterise to be "theft" is to actually make it happen again.

Making new models from the output of their models is one of three ways I can see of doing this, along with court ordering their models be published (rather than destroyed), or some other company retraining from scratch on their own crawl of the web. This third option is also why I think anyone using the "moat" metaphor with regard to OpenAI's models needs to stop and think about how they're acting like a stochastic parrot.

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by jurynulifcation on Friday January 19, 2024 @03:12PM (#39060452)
Oh, just to be clear, I have no problems with models built on OSINT. My problem is someone doing that, building a commercial product on it, and then telling others they can't do it to them, while also using the money they get from the endeavor to make the world worse for everyone else.
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by freeqaz on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:51PM (#39049679)
Is there any precedent to suggest that OpenAI is actually able to enforce their TOS? I know that if you use GPL software that the outputs aren't subject to GPL. Is that the case for OpenAI?
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by ShamelessC on Thursday January 18, 2024 @07:02PM (#39049802)
> Artists must allow AI companies to harvest and learn from their output but people can't take OpenAI output for the same thing?

No one said that. Just that you're probably violating ToS and OpenAI might come after you. Is that fair in light of what OpenAI has done? Of course not. But if you're running a business, it's still worth considering.

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by behnamoh on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:36PM (#39049512)
Don't conflate "hacker spirit" with "unethical spirit".
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by albert180 on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:39PM (#39049560)
I don't see anything unethical. OpenAI doesn't care about the copyright of the people who have generated their training data. Why should I care about theirs?
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by deepsquirrelnet on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:57PM (#39049744)
Ethically you might not respect it, but practically, you might not want to be the one testing their TOS in court — or maybe you do. In either case, it’s worth caring about at least a little.

Someone with gumption might just go ahead and use GPT to train a model and then open it up as a paid competitor. Poking the bear is certainly an interesting way to spend a year for the adventurous.

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by DennisP on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:49PM (#39049646)
Especially since content produced entirely by AI is not protected by copyright in the US.

https://builtin.com/artificial-intelligence/ai-copyright

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by MacsHeadroom on Thursday January 18, 2024 @11:57PM (#39051708)
You shouldn't. You should care about the contractual terms you agreed to with them. If you did not agree to their ToS and acquired content from OpenAI elsewhere, go ahead.
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by albert180 on Friday January 19, 2024 @09:17AM (#39055703)
Nah I'm a end consumer in Europe. Most of the bullshit companies write in their ToS isn't applicable at all here, because Lawmakers know that nobody reads them anyway I doubt that even in the US they wouldn't sue if they weren't 100% of winning. They wouldn't like to have a precedent that you can use it to train other models, where right now they can scare away most people from doing it
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by Paul-Craft on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:43PM (#39049601)
Don't conflate "ethical" with "legal."
Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by thrwayaistartup on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:46PM (#39049622)
Yes, but opposite conclusion.

If I were the author I'd never do this because I would want an exit and this strategy + twitter thread wildly complicates any potential exit.

Even though I don't think there is anything particularly morally problematic here (I'm an information freedom maximalist).

Re:My AI costs went from $100 to less than $1/day: Fine-tuni... by pests on Thursday January 18, 2024 @06:39PM (#39049558)
I'm not.